Skip to main content

Reply to "Lionel "Tinplate" for 2017 - Not MTH"

Rocky Mountaineer posted:
D500 posted:

Nothing about this is a "ruse"; it's clearly described.  I intend to order one. ...

I expect the green S-2 set to meet the same fate. But I'm about to reserve one. 

Two thoughts... First it is a bit of a "ruse", because the imaging "suggests" a tinplate set, when in fact that appears to not be the case at all... only "tinplate-inspired", whatever that means.  

 

It's no more a ruse than Daylight AC9's, Cab Forwards or the fantasy BNSF and NS (before NS did theirs) "heritage" locomotives of a few years back.

Seems to me the catalog copy is up front about what the set represents.  There's no new tooling involved and I doubt any new paint masks so Lionel's new product investment is minimal at best. 

I'm surprised no one's jumped in with the old standby:  "It's your railroad, run what you like," yet regarding this set.

I keep finding myself drawn to this set.  I find it a unique offering.  5 years ago I would've jumped on it, but my finances currently have other priorities so unfortunately I won't be ordering one.

Rusty

×
×
×
×
×