Skip to main content

Lock On's vs Soldering - My experience... Listen to the folks who tell you soldering is better

The other day during a pleasant operating session, we had an engine come to an abrupt halt on a section of main line.  A three foot section of track was dead.  But when I put the multimeter on the rails, it showed power.

I pulled out a lighted passenger car.  No lights... except when I pushed on the car.  Then the lights would illuminate.  The MTH Scaletrax lock on I used had come just loose enough to lose contact, but when pressure was applied to the track, then contact was made.

IMG_20200104_105638424IMG_20200104_105733945

For some back story, we have been building this particular layout since 2012.  The mains were the first thing installed so we could run trains.  In the beginning, I used MTH Lock On's 45-1033.  It's a neat three wire clip that clips into the plastic ties to make contact with the rails.  I'm lazy and was not very good at soldering, so I used several of those when I could find them in the hobby shops.

45-1033

As I read more and more on OGR over the years about soldering track wire leads, I started doing that instead.  It was cheaper and it provided a better connection.

At this dead section of track, I happen to have used one of these lock on's.  The problem, it the track was nailed down and ballast had been glued in place. In order to fix this I was going to have to tear things up which did not interest me at all.

What I ended up doing was applying just enough pressure on the rails for the lock on to make contact.  Then I applied some CA glue to the area for a quick set.  That seemed to work.  I'll probably regret that decision if and when the time comes to ever dismantle the layout.

IMG_20200104_105530764

So the point of this long thread is to listen to these kind experienced folks on OGR and solder your track leads.  You will have a better connection and you will have access to these connections in the future after you use ballast and glue.

Have Fun!

Ron

IMG_20200104_112015273

 

Attachments

Images (5)
  • 45-1033
  • IMG_20200104_105530764
  • IMG_20200104_105638424
  • IMG_20200104_105733945
  • IMG_20200104_112015273
Original Post
×
×
×
×
×