Skip to main content

Reply to "Potential Problem With Williams USRA 2-8-2?"

Originally Posted by Bob Delbridge:

PS...I'm still having trouble finding the correct tach tape, don't fully understand why Dave Hikel's method calls for something more than 48 stripes when MTH uses it as a standard.  My steam chuffs, driver revolution, and speed are still a bit off.  I timed the engine over my 1/3 mile mainline.  It should have taken 20 seconds to go the 1/3 mile at 30smph, but I had to increase it to 35smph to get the 20 seconds.

Seems to me if your Williams goes 30/35=85.7% of commanded speed, then you need to have 85.7% of the 48 stripes or 41.1 stripes.  Since stripes must be even, you'd use 42 stripes or 21 black + 21 white and live with an "uncorrectable" 2% speed error.

 

If your speed numbers are accurate and assuming Williams and MTH scaled the wheels properly (same diameters of the model), then MTH must be using a Gear Ratio of 18 instead of Williams' 21.  18/21=85.7%.

 

 

×
×
×
×
×