Skip to main content

@Hot Water posted:

Wonder who came up with such an incorrect "Nick-name"? I've always heard those referred to as "Super Cabs", or "Wide Nose".

Those CN units pre-dated "Super Cabs" and "Wide Nose". I also saw them called "Safety Cabs" and "Comfort Cabs". The CN developed them with EMD to be more comfortable for the crews in the harsh Canadian winters.

I saw the older cab style called "Spartan Cabs" as well. You can probably thank the guys from the railfan magazines.

I don't know why, but it took a very long time for this project to get traction. Reservations were sluggish for several years. When reservations grew to the critical level, we swiftly scheduled design and production. But COVID caused havoc with our teams as lock down after lock down disrupted their workers. Design usually takes 3-4 months, it took nearly 2 years. After the lock downs were lifted, things started to move again, but there were a lot of errors. Corrections were ignored and Jonathan had to review the same drawings at least 3 time, sending the same corrections again and again. It was a daunting task.

We didn't let production start until all corrections were adhered to and confirmed to us. Production started in November of 2023 and again, usually this only takes about 3 months, but it's been 6 months since they started. This time the delays were due to the huge numbers of detail configurations for the 30+ Road Names planned. But our team at the factory diligently organized production and powered through the difficulties. Now here we are, almost done.

Finally, these are finishing production with painting and lettering complete and assembly, testing and boxing up. They plan on ordering a container the first week of May. It takes about 1 month from that point to receive them, probably the first week in June. Those with reservations will receive shipping information once the container is on-board. It was a wild ride, but from the pictures I share with you on our web site, these are fine scale models through and through. Yes, there will be some errors, there always are. But as a modeler myself, perfection is something to strive for, but never attained. Our goal is to capture the essence of the prototype, which I whole heartedly think they did.

I hope all of our customers enjoy these models when they arrive. As always, we are here to swiftly and efficiently take care of any problems that arise from shipping.

I want to thank the many people that assisted us in reviewing and correcting drawings and photos of the production samples; Jonathan being the point man. THANK YOU.  And to our many patient customers, I can't believe how long you can wait for these models. It's amazing. What a lucky business owner I am to have such supportive help and customers. THANK YOU. It's why we are still in business. Onward...

Sincerely,

Scott Mann - Sunset Models / GGD / ERR

Last edited by sdmann

AMAZING effort to launch a model in so many roads and variations!  In my opinion, this was a release of three distinct models:  SD40-2, SD40T-2, and GMD SD40-2W.  I can only imagine the research that had to go into each paint scheme and road specific details. 

I hope this is a success for 3rd Rail and that we'll see a rerun in the future. 

Great job and thanks Scott, Jonathan and Team!

Hi Folks,

I'm glad you are all getting your SD40-2s. When you receive your boxes, please check the labels on the side to make sure you received the correct road names. We've got some reports of the wrong road name received, which means my guys goofed and put UPS labels on the wrong box, or worse yet, I pulled the wrong models, and my guys missed it on the 2nd round of checking. Let me know quickly so we can coordinate an exchange.

And PLEASE, change out the 3 Rail Front Coupler with a Kadee insert at least. I wish we could have moved those back, but the truck is right up against the back of the pilot.

This is what shipping looks like in our Warehouse.

Customers are asking when we will know what we have left. The answer is, when all these mis shipments are corrected we will know what we have left. This can take several weeks after we have shipped.

20240606_073636

Cheers,

Scott Mann

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 20240606_073636
Last edited by sdmann

Finally got outside in our 100 plus temperatures that are common in June to get some quick (emphasis on quick!) shots of my various SD40-2s.  I'm very happy with the final outcome!

South of the border with a late phase version that has extended range dynamic brakes.

1000013471100001347210000134731000013475

Now north of the border with a CN SD40-2W.  No dynamic brakes, a wide cab and those distinctly Canadian ditch lights.

1000013476

Single light on the rear:

1000013478

10000134791000013480

Hard to read in this photo, but the builder's plate is the correct GMD plate for Canadian built EMD locomotives.

1000013481

The Union Pacific inherited D&RGW and SP SD40T-2 locomotives.  This one is of SP heritage as evidenced by the unique lighting on the SP units that has been removed by their current owner and plated over on the rear and removed completely on the nose.

1000013483

1000013484

1000013485

1000013488

Norfolk Southern's high hood fleet came from both the Southern and the Norfolk & Western.  This one is a former N&W unit.  Spotting features include the bell on the short hood instead of the long hood.  NS also was kind enough to mark the heritage of this locomotive on the cab sides.

1000013489

1000013490

10000134921000013494

1000013495

Attachments

Images (18)
  • 1000013471
  • 1000013472
  • 1000013473
  • 1000013475
  • 1000013476
  • 1000013478
  • 1000013479
  • 1000013480
  • 1000013481
  • 1000013483
  • 1000013484
  • 1000013485
  • 1000013488
  • 1000013489
  • 1000013490
  • 1000013492
  • 1000013494
  • 1000013495
Last edited by GG1 4877

I am running two of the MP SD40-2s on 2-rail 36" radius on my office shelf layout.  Set their DCC addresses to Mopac road numbers 3255 and 3264, put them in MU and have them pulling a local.  My daughter was on the throttle with the bell and horn.  (I'll get her hooked on the hobby in due time - ha!)

BTW, if you got more than one you might find all of the instruction manuals in a single box like I did.  Of course it was the last box I opened. 

Attachments

Videos (1)
IMG_5347
Last edited by Tim Mc
@Tim Mc posted:

I am running two of the MP SD40-2s on 2-rail 36" radius on my office shelf layout.  Set their DCC addresses to Mopac road numbers 3255 and 3264, put them in MU and have them pulling a local.  My daughter was on the throttle with the bell and horn.  (I'll get her hooked on the hobby in due time - ha!)

BTW, if you got more than one you might find all of the instruction manuals in a single box like I did.  Of course it was the last box I opened. 

Very nice! Can't wait to run mine!

Wish I could see your entire train!

@GG1 4877 posted:

Conrail was on my wish list as was ATSF, but so many conflicting interests on these models to decide on which ones I wanted.  The correct Flexcoil trucks makes the Conrail one very special.

I got one Conrail and one Conrail Quality.

The extra paint detailing (white highlights) in the CQ is really nice.

I'm taken back to my elementary and middle school days watching these things shove a coal train over Cresson Mountain and then come back down light with just the whine of the dynamics and a short toot of the horn as me and my cousins waved from trackside in Lilly.

Last edited by rplst8
@rplst8 posted:

I got one Conrail and one Conrail Quality.

The extra paint detailing (white highlights) in the CQ is really nice.

I'm taken back to my elementary and middle school days watching these things shove a coal train over Cresson Mountain and then come back down light with just the whine of the dynamics and a short toot of the horn as me and my cousins waved from trackside in Lilly.

My biggest memory of Conrail SD40-2s was hearing the whine of the prime movers from my Slumbercoach berth ALL NIGHT along the broad way during my college days.     Conrail came through my hometown in the form of patched PC GP38-2s and maybe 6 cars at most being on a commuter line near the last freight customer.

I received mine last week.  They operate great.  3 units were able to pull three 3-car sets of diecast 53’ well cars & one 5-car set of gunderson cars up a 2 degree grade with no loss of traction, and that was a very heavy train.  I did notice however that the front stanchions on all three locos were either bent or broken right out of the box.  Also the cab roofs of the Santa Fe WB’s and Kodachrome units were painted incorrectly (dark blue on the WB’s, and a scallop of black on the KC), but an easy enough fix with some ATSF yellow and an airbrush.  All in all, I’m very happy with them.  

@rplst8 posted:

What I'd really like to see is a comparison on the side from track level. The trucks on the Lionel and MTH versions were always way too far back from the pilot.

Here's a few comparison shots I took yesterday. I included my MoPac Canary SD40 from Atlas.

20240622_155647

MTH20240622_160320

Lionel20240622_160312

Atlas Master line20240622_160301

Sunset 3rd Rail20240622_160256

Atlas & Lionel

20240622_155658

Lionel & Sunset 3rd Rail

20240622_155721

Sunset 3rd Rail & MTH

20240622_155741

20240622_155900

Hope that helps!

Attachments

Images (9)
  • 20240622_155647
  • 20240622_160320
  • 20240622_160312
  • 20240622_160301
  • 20240622_160256
  • 20240622_155658
  • 20240622_155721
  • 20240622_155741
  • 20240622_155900

I’d like to see the NYS&W “Susquehanna” offered in the next run.  There’s the black and yellow paint “regular” paint scheme, as well as the silver & maroon “heritage” paint scheme recently applied to # 3024.

NYS&W #3022 (black & yellow)

NYS&W #3024 (Heritage silver & maroon)

I’d be in for at least two pre-orders!

Last edited by CNJ #1601

I would like to see a cabless, SD40-2B. But since there were just 3 such prototype locomotives, which of the popular road names, that have a greater likelihood of being rerun, could be the closest one, to modify?

I see these SD40-2B sandwiched between 2 BNSF SD40-2, around a local BNSF, hump yard. Apparently, they were all rebuilt from wrecked Burlington Northern, SD40-2.

2 of them (BNSF 300 & 301) look like the following photo that I took in 2014, with the dynamic brakes in the original location as the SD40-2, but at one time, I also saw an elusive BNSF 302, with the original Burlington Northern livery, that look this HO model, from Scale Trains, with the Dynamic Brake section at the front end.

All 3 have high, short hoods, with much smaller front porch, with the high hood, much closer to the front end of the locomotive, compared to my Sunset, BNSF, SD40-2.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

IMG_3989

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_3989
Last edited by naveenrajan
@naveenrajan posted:

I would like to see a cabless, SD40-2B. But since there were just 3 such prototype locomotives, which of the popular road names, that have a greater likelihood of being rerun, could be the closest one, to modify?

I see these SD40-2B sandwiched between 2 BNSF SD40-2, around a local BNSF, hump yard. Apparently, they were all rebuilt from wrecked Burlington Northern, SD40-2.

2 of them (BNSF 300 & 301) look like the following photo that I took in 2014, with the dynamic brakes in the original location as the SD40-2, but at one time, I also saw an elusive BNSF 302, with the original Burlington Northern livery, that look this HO model, from Scale Trains, with the Dynamic Brake section at the front end.

All 3 have high, short hoods, with much smaller front porch, with the high hood, much closer to the front end of the locomotive, compared to my Sunset, BNSF, SD40-2.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

IMG_3989

The closest tooling to this one would likely be the one that uses the Southern / N&W / Norfolk Southern tool of the high short hood SD40-2.  BN units were mostly phase 1a2 production as are the high hood models listed above.  Of course the cab would have to be removed, the number boards and class lights blanked, and the ATSF style plate antenna added to the top with some additional details, but not too difficult to model.  Painting it might be the most difficult part.  Tru-Color GN paints should match for the BNSF colors used on the BNSF factory units.  Interesting units to be sure!

Already posted above, but my NS version for comparison with a closeup of the high short hood.   

10000134891000013496

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 1000013489
  • 1000013496
@naveenrajan posted:

Aren’t all the choices the same as the initial run?

I don’t understand the purpose of offering the same road names, right after delivering the same, just a month ago.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

Sometimes seeing is believing. Maybe too many folks were on the fence about the models until they came out. Once you see these models (online or in person) it's hard not to inquire about ordering them. Many times it is too late and a new run comes quickly.

@naveenrajan posted:

Aren’t all the choices the same as the initial run?

I don’t understand the purpose of offering the same road names, right after delivering the same, just a month ago.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

Same deal with the Superliners. So many people were impressed with the photos of the actual models who didn't order the first go around so they're doing another run. Thankfully I got some from the first batch before the prices went up.

@vash44 posted:

Sometimes seeing is believing. Maybe too many folks were on the fence about the models until they came out. Once you see these models (online or in person) it's hard not to inquire about ordering them. Many times it is too late and a new run comes quickly.

This is exactly what happens.  Many individuals want to wait and see the model first and once it finally arrives the waiting list is much longer than the list of available models.  Also, people may want to order road names they couldn't justify in the first run to add some additional units. 

This is just an announcement, and a 2nd run won't proceed until there are enough orders to justify another run so there is some time.  New road names could be possible, but likely only through a commitment to guarantee a minimum number of probably 15-20 units.  However, if enough different people want a specific road name done, there is a "write-in" option on the 2nd run reservation list.  If any write-in candidates get traction, I'm sure Scott will be sure to let people know.

Also - It’s possible that there were many unfilled stand-by reservations. I think when reservations close, that Locks the number of models to be produced. Those that missed getting a scarce stand-by filled probably Still want a model. Maybe this run will be tacked onto another models run to get a Good # for the factory to execute.
Just glad for the second run opportunity.  Not everyone can get all the models they want - At Once.

Cheers 😉

I understand the comment about the “write-in”.

My original reservation for the SD40-2 was for a BNSF, in the contemporary, colors, with the Swoosh logo. 2 years later, as it got closer to the preorder deadline, Scott communicated that the first run wouldn’t include such repainted schemes and I switched my reservation to the original BNSF scheme.

I will follow the development of this Second Run and see what road names make it to production.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

FRISCO folks. If enough of you step up, it might be possible to get the Beautiful red and white model returned to the offering. It was dropped quite early for a lack of reservations. Those that have reserved the 3rd Rail Frisco FA, come and place a reservation to help get Scott to re-list this road !!!! 😜😜

Cheers 😉

Last edited by TrainBub
@naveenrajan posted:

I understand the comment about the “write-in”.

My original reservation for the SD40-2 was for a BNSF, in the contemporary, colors, with the Swoosh logo. 2 years later, as it got closer to the preorder deadline, Scott communicated that the first run wouldn’t include such repainted schemes and I switched my reservation to the original BNSF scheme.

I will follow the development of this Second Run and see what road names make it to production.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

Naveen, I would want two in that same scheme, so that gets us a bit closer to the reservation requirements.

@GG1 4877 posted:

The closest tooling to this one would likely be the one that uses the Southern / N&W / Norfolk Southern tool of the high short hood SD40-2.  BN units were mostly phase 1a2 production as are the high hood models listed above.  Of course the cab would have to be removed, the number boards and class lights blanked, and the ATSF style plate antenna added to the top with some additional details, but not too difficult to model.  Painting it might be the most difficult part.  Tru-Color GN paints should match for the BNSF colors used on the BNSF factory units.  Interesting units to be sure!

Already posted above, but my NS version for comparison with a closeup of the high short hood.   

Jonathan,

Did you find any differences between the Norfolk Southern and the Burlington Northern, SD40-2? Were there any differences between the truck types on these 2 variants? I am unsure if the SD40 variants had different capacity, fuel tanks as the SD45 variants.

Before I read your informative reply, I had assumed that these SD40-2B were closer to the Burlington Northern versions as they were rebuilt from wrecked Burlington Northern, SD40-2.

These are just my opinion,

Naveen Rajan

Here’s what I’d like to see added.
Comments here please. Emails to Scott if interested in Any of these. Understand nothing new is possible unless decent #s of people respond with messages to Scott with what they’d like to see added.

This is a pretty ambitious wish list. I’ll be tickled to see Any of these Added !!!!

134DD81E-0C43-4195-B56B-C0D595A6BF9D

D6D412E4-C344-4080-A2F5-9AF9F47D5228
FEF2C428-F9EB-495D-BD56-8D158E56ADF3
C992ACA6-038A-4C67-8E11-0EA72F1A6A66
This MP is different from run 1.  It has dynamic brakes  ABBC947D-7759-4307-91F7-A0538C588F6B

Step up with emails to Scott. We won’t see Any of these unless you  
Speak Up !!!!!!!  
It’s All about Numbers !!!!!!!!!!

Cheers 😉

Attachments

Images (6)
  • 134DD81E-0C43-4195-B56B-C0D595A6BF9D
  • D6D412E4-C344-4080-A2F5-9AF9F47D5228
  • FEF2C428-F9EB-495D-BD56-8D158E56ADF3
  • EF5FFC7A-C15D-4CBD-A56F-97C6E41ED764
  • C992ACA6-038A-4C67-8E11-0EA72F1A6A66
  • ABBC947D-7759-4307-91F7-A0538C588F6B
Last edited by TrainBub

Hi Folks,

We announced a Rerun of the SD40-2s to satisfy the stand-by orders and any people that wanted some of the different road names offered in the first run, but couldn't buy them all at one time.

We are NOT going to offer any roadnames or paint schemes other than what was in the first run.

Your suggestions are great, but that would be something we would consider in a future run, 2-3 years down the road. A quick rerun is just that, using the same configuration drawings with the Painting and Lettering developed under the first run.

Any new road name require research for configuration, colors, obtaining color samples, having to go through many different processes before they can be added to a production run. This isn't going to happen on a quick 2nd run, sorry to disappoint.

Perhaps we will revisit the SD40-2s in years to come, with these added roadnames, but not at this time.

Thanks Again for all your suggestions. It's what keeps us going.

All our resources are being used to get ready for production of the following:

E7 4th Run: In production, finishing late Summer.

SD79 - Run #2 is coming later this year. Delivery by the end of 2024.

FA/FB - Early Next Year

Genesis and Chargers - 1st Quarter Next Year

Somewhere in this period of time, we can do the SD40-2 rerun, but we need at least 15 orders for each road name, and 200 minimum total orders to run the project. We should have that by the end of this year. If not, it will delay out further.

After that we are thinking of rerunning several of the other projects we have made in the past such as PAs, FTs, F7s and so on.

Have a Great Summer.

Last edited by sdmann
@TrainBub posted:

Not see thru.

It looks to me like the air intakes are louvers as opposed to screens. Do you know if this is prototypical for any tunnel motors? All models I have seen (any scale) and prototype photos I have seen of SP locomotives are screens. Its certainly possible that louvers may have been correct for certain locomotives or maybe as built. I don’t know enough about or have adequate reference material for this era of SP.

The radiator intake area on the all tunnel motors, the gp15's, and the mp15ac's are all mesh screens.  There are no shutters or other components behind them, which is why they can be seen through.  These locos do have shutters, but they are oriented horizontally above the radiator cores, in the volume that extends above the roof line.

The screen material is the same as that used for the inertial screens behind the cab, at least on late 1st gen locos onward.  And for 2nd gen units like the dash 2's, after 1976 the same material is used for the radiator intake screens on locos with traditional radiator intake positions.

The inertial filter screens and typical radiator screens cannot be seen through since there are other components behind them, including shutters and cores in the case of the radiators.

The screen material and corrugations106

Inertial filter screen
001

Typical post 1976 radiator screens
010

Tunnel motor radiator screens
2019-07-21_OCRR_4027_SD40T-2_Zanesville_ [7)

All photos are my own.

I suspect that the intake screens are solid on the 3rd Rail models because there is a speaker or some other electronics sitting behind that part of the shell.  Or it's a concession to the cost of tooling.   Either way it's unfortunate that the screens are solid as they are a hallmark of the tunnel motors.  Ironically, while I'm not a fan of tank drives, they would at least make it possible to have see-through screens without having a gearbox behind them.

Jim

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 106
  • 001
  • 010
  • 2019-07-21_OCRR_4027_SD40T-2_Zanesville_ (7)
Last edited by big train

Jim,

Thanks for the detailed information. The see through intake screens are a pretty iconic feature of the tunnel motors and your photo is what my memory recalls.

I’m more of a steam and early diesel guy but I have a fondness for certain 60s-80s vintage diesels and also being an SP and Rio Grande guy, tunnel motors are of high appeal to me.
This detail issue will probably have me sticking with Lionel tunnel motors and eventually doing fixed pilots on them. I love the 3rd Rail GP9’s I got and have SD7/9’s on order but its hard for me to spend $800 per engine with a major detail like this not being correct.

It was a long wait but well worth it.  These are my first 2-rail only engines running DCC and I am very happy with them.  As you can see the accuracy and details are excellent but the best part for me are the sounds and that I don't have to move in the trucks, fill gaps, fix a pilot or even put on couplers because everything correct and ready right out of the box.

I really want to buy two more CSX dark futures but unfortunately, for whatever reason, that paint scheme was canceled early on.  I'm surprised that is not a more popular paint scheme.

I'm new to DCC, if anyone knows how to turn off the second headlight in a consist, please let me know.

Rich

www.toytrainsontracks.com



20240623_12152020240623_12150420240623_12133220240623_121242

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 20240623_121242
  • 20240623_121332
  • 20240623_121504
  • 20240623_121520
Videos (3)
ChessieDuoSounds
ConrailDuoSounds
ConrailDuoAccel
Last edited by Rich Battista
@sdmann posted:

It was my decision to make the screens on the Tunnel motors solid. In the 3D image below, I made this section transparent so you could see what's behind the screens. One would see the electronics in one screen and bundles of wires in the other.

I think a wise decision. I personally don’t care to see the electronics or wires. I also think it also probably helps keep the inside more clear of particulates that can jam up “the works”. Of course - my opinion. 🤔

Cheers 😉

@sdmann posted:

Hi Folks,

We announced a Rerun of the SD40-2s to satisfy the stand-by orders and any people that wanted some of the different road names offered in the first run, but couldn't buy them all at one time.

We are NOT going to offer any roadnames or paint schemes other than what was in the first run.

Your suggestions are great, but that would be something we would consider in a future run, 2-3 years down the road. A quick rerun is just that, using the same configuration drawings with the Painting and Lettering developed under the first run.

Any new road name require research for configuration, colors, obtaining color samples, having to go through many different processes before they can be added to a production run. This isn't going to happen on a quick 2nd run, sorry to disappoint.

Perhaps we will revisit the SD40-2s in years to come, with these added roadnames, but not at this time.

Thanks Again for all your suggestions. It's what keeps us going.

All our resources are being used to get ready for production of the following:

E7 4th Run: In production, finishing late Summer.

SD79 - Run #2 is coming later this year. Delivery by the end of 2024.

FA/FB - Early Next Year

Genesis and Chargers - 1st Quarter Next Year

Somewhere in this period of time, we can do the SD40-2 rerun, but we need at least 15 orders for each road name, and 200 minimum total orders to run the project. We should have that by the end of this year. If not, it will delay out further.

After that we are thinking of rerunning several of the other projects we have made in the past such as PAs, FTs, F7s and so on.

Have a Great Summer.

Then I am out until green MKT SD40-2's are made. I missed the MTH ones back in 2010. I've only seen one of those come up for sale on ebay and it went for the same price as a brand new Sunset model. I see the Lionel model come up occasionally but they made the green way to dark.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×