Skip to main content

My price guide states 3 different times and value. There is 

6017-185 (59-60) figured out this one is the gray one

6017-225 (61-62)

6017-235 (62)

My standard catalog of Lionel Trains 1945 - 1969 only talks about the last one. 

How do you determine which one is which

Last edited by rtraincollector
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

None of those cars were part of the only cataloged set (according to the Greenberg Guide).  That would be set #11385, listed as being made in 1963, The Santa Fe Space Set.  Your caboose is most likely the -235 version.  Also the "B" unit is listed as a 218C.  There were probably many uncataloged sets at that time using the 223 ABs as the motive power.

The 6017-225 number quoted in the Price Guide is completely wrong.  This is just one of many mistakes listed from a “Price Guide”.  Early mistakes keep getting perpetuated, year after year.  The 6017-235 (RED) A.T. & S.F. Caboose was only issued in the Catalogued Set #13018; Uncatalogued Set #9656, in 1962 only.  The actual box number listed in Schmid’s Authoritative Guide is (6017-235 S.  There were only 7600 cabooses (6017-235), made for both Sets, making it a little harder to find, but I wouldn’t consider Scarce.

Last edited by TeleDoc

Chuck, Thanks for the reply, as I went back and looked it up myself.  It appears in Sets 19115 & 19133, both for 1962 only, led by the 211 Texas Special.  In theory, knowing the fact that  Schmid had the actual documentation, to list the caboose with the number 6017-225, the caboose would have been the 6017-235 for anyone looking for the RED A.T & S.F., compared to the typical Grey issue.  I have to agree that the unboxed sets, listed above, have the designation of 6017-225.

I went and looked up the set 9656 and most of the components came with what I bought. I got the 223,and 218C, the 3419 helicopter launching car ( minus helicopter in my set ) also missing the turbo missile firing car, 6448 exploding box car, I do have ( kinda) the Minuteman missile firing car,( missing roof pieces and the guts on the inside) and the caboose. I think I might have a extra minuteman missile firing car, and one point I had two of the turbo launching cars so I may have that also.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×