Skip to main content

Hi Everyone,

I hope to obtain a Lionel Visionline Big Boy at some point.  I hope to run it on a club layout because it won't fit on mine.  However, I would like to be able to set up a basic 072 oval once in awhile to run it at home. 

I am brand new to digital trains.  I understand electronics, RF, IR, microwave, etc.  I've done a bunch of research, but I am having a hard time finding this answer online, even at Lionel.com.  

I will run [u]only[/u] this Lionel Vision engine on this oval.  No conventional.  No TMCC.  Nothing else.  Ever.

I plan on getting the #990 Legacy Cab-2.  Are there any reasons not to?

As far as the transformer goes, this is confusing.  Even after watching Lionel's videos a couple times.  I'm thinking that the Powerhouse IS a transformer.  But the Lionel videos are telling me I would still need a Powermaster "to supply power to the Powerhouse."  I think I only need the #990 LCS, and a 135w or 180w Powerhouse.  But everything I see and read says I also need to add a Powermaster.  Do I?

I have plenty of spare postwar ZW's lying around, and have read about using it with fuses or fast acting circuit breakers.  But, I'm thinking I would rather not go that route. 

Someone on OGR in an old thread said, "The Powerhouse's circuit breaker isn't fast enough."  They said, "The Powermaster's c/b is much faster, and necessary."  Is this true?  To protect a $2000-3000 engine: What should I do?

If I need to run a Powerhouse AND a Powermaster:  For the money spent, should I just get an MTH Z-4000 instead?  Can I run just a #990 Cab-2 and a Z-4000?  Is the Z-4000's circuit breaker adequate?

I noticed the Lionel bricks are the correct, dedicated, 18 volts.  The Z-4000 can be set up to 22 volts, and there is no dedicated 18 v terminal on it.  In my mind: That opens the possibility that the lever could get moved/bumped inadvertently past the manually set, max, 18 v, and do some damage.

Summary:  To run this Vision Big Boy.  Is all I need:  A Powerhouse, #990 Cab-2, 072 track, and 2 straight track sections with terminals?

I welcome all thoughts.  As I said, I am brand new to the digital age of trains.

 Thank you,

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

If you plan to only run the big boy or for that matter, Legacy Command locomotives on that loop, then the Lionel 180 watt brick is the most economical solution IMO. The MTH Z4000 is a brute and we run 4 of them on our club layout at full throttle voltage around 21 to 22 volts and the Vision locomotives run for hours with no damage. However, it’s overkill for your needs. I run three 180 watt bricks at home and the breakers are fast and unlike all the bashing of the electronics you’ll hear on the forum, I have yet to suffer any damage using this configuration. I did install TVS diodes on the output of each brick and you can search the forum using TVS and find all the information you need to obtain and install them. It sounds as if your pretty savvy on that end as you have some electronic experience though. Good luck in your hunt and be patient in your search as they do show up for reasonable prices. I could have had one slightly used this past April from an estate sale for $1650.

Last edited by NYC Z-MAN

I used to have a Z4000 for my carpet layout. Yes, overkill, but more to the point I have found that the smoke performance of Legacy/TMCC engines, including those from 3rd Rail Sunset models, is better with the power bricks or a ZW-L.   Look up the forum debate on Lionel's advice on using chopped sine wave transformers like theirs as opposed to other manufacturers' products if you are interested in the technical details. I also got it straight from Scott Mann at 3rd Rail that chopped sine wave is better for his TMCC products.

Aside from that, the fuses trip on the bricks when they should and don't seem to me to be either over- or under-sensitive. If you eventually decide to add MTH DCS to your system they will power the TIU with no problem although you need an adapter cable, which is not hard to source.

Hancock52 posted:

I used to have a Z4000 for my carpet layout. Yes, overkill, but more to the point I have found that the smoke performance of Legacy/TMCC engines, including those from 3rd Rail Sunset models, is better with the power bricks or a ZW-L.   Look up the forum debate on Lionel's advice on using chopped sine wave transformers like theirs as opposed to other manufacturers' products if you are interested in the technical details. I also got it straight from Scott Mann at 3rd Rail that chopped sine wave is better for his TMCC products.

Aside from that, the fuses trip on the bricks when they should and don't seem to me to be either over- or under-sensitive. If you eventually decide to add MTH DCS to your system they will power the TIU with no problem although you need an adapter cable, which is not hard to source.

I certainly agree on the smoke being better with the bricks. My Vision Genset and Hybrid produce anemic smoke on the club layout compared to home.

If you want to get technical, the question regarding radius, or diameter, and terminal tracks is still not answered. While the locomotive is designed for 072 operation, if you can afford the space, I would certainly choose the largest radius curves, 084 or 096 and add a few more straight tracks to your terminal tracks to boot!

Last edited by NYC Z-MAN

I only have 180 watt bricks. The 135 watt would certainly work for the big boy with plenty to spare, but I don't know if their available, what breaker they use, and how much they cost. If it's twenty or thirty bucks difference, what's that to a $2000 locomotive and a $350 control system? I purchased a spare 180 watt brick last year for around $80 plus shipping. This gives me 10 amps to run my biggest power hog train which tops out at around 8 amps. You should also consider what you'll pull with the big boy. I've seen people pulling seven or eight older passenger cars with incandescent lamps and I've seen people pull 30 Monopoly cars! For my money, it's 180 watt bricks.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×