Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have to say that this is a very nice looking model. If Lionel can turn out one of these steamers a year then I might find myself giving S another shot.

 

The thing that just boggles my mind is that they are lagging so far behind with the track system. Personally, I won't be buying anything in S until there is a fully fleshed out Hi-Rail track system from Lionel or MTH. Perhaps in a year or two things will be different?

while I post these pictures today, I am taken back by the events that have unfolded here in Connecticut today My heart is out to all those who were effected today by this unspeakable event, while Christmas is what started my entry in American Flyer in 1950, I cannot comprehend what scars will be left on the children that survived.

Originally Posted by toy1:

while I post these pictures today, I am taken back by the events that have unfolded here in Connecticut today My heart is out to all those who were effected today by this unspeakable event, while Christmas is what started my entry in American Flyer in 1950, I cannot comprehend what scars will be left on the children that survived.

Amen...

 

Mark in Oregon

Originally Posted by toy1:

Well today I started tolevied the new locomotive, and to my supersize legged no orange module, the last time On my challenger I had a defective one and it took 3 months to get a replacement. This is unbleivable and just plain poor quality control!!!!!!!

I'm not sure about lionels s scale legacy stuff, but I know with the o guage locos you can load the info manually if you don't have the module. Theres no excuse for the lack of a module, but loading the loco manually will get you running with full legacy features in less than three months.

Originally Posted by RickO:
Originally Posted by toy1:

Well today I started tolevied the new locomotive, and to my supersize legged no orange module, the last time On my challenger I had a defective one and it took 3 months to get a replacement. This is unbleivable and just plain poor quality control!!!!!!!

I'm not sure about lionels s scale legacy stuff, but I know with the o guage locos you can load the info manually if you don't have the module. Theres no excuse for the lack of a module, but loading the loco manually will get you running with full legacy features in less than three months.


IIRC, at the fall York, Lionel was considering not including orange modules anymore and instead had other ways of getting the info uploaded into the locomotive or to make you enter the set-up manually.  It was discussed here:

 

https://ogrforum.com/d...ent/9595974437609776

 

But I cannot say for certain that anything was ever decided.  If you can confirm it, please let us know.  If I understand correctly, these 2-8-8-2's are some of the first Lionel locomotives with the IR sensor on the bottom of the tender and it may well be that it is one of the first to not offer an orange Legacy module.

Found this on Page 2 in the Lionel . . . Keep the orange !! thread, October 23:

 

"Folks,  The Orange module may not be included with the loco in next year's O gauge product.  Currently it is not included with current production Flyer locos.  The Legacy V1.51 operating system presets all of the module settings, and even expands the functions with the AUX2 menu.  The only item you need to enter is the name and road number - which is very quick, and only once.

 

While this seems like an inconvenience, many folks change the name we pre-select, opting for a better identifier after loading the Orange module.  The IR track and LSU allow over-riding the Orange module settings.  Many of the new features in V1.51 we are now bringing to you cannot be preset by an Orange module.

 

At some point you have to move forward and expand the features, even if it changes the product deliverable.   Note for MAC users, the iPad is your solution as we plan to migrate the LSU features to the iPad. 

 

And note: we can make the module available for a particular loco via Customer Service (for a handling charge). 

 

jon

CTO, Lionel LLC"

 

Now, I don't have a Legacy system, so I don't have a clue about the modules, orange or otherwise. I run TMCC via a Trainmaster Command Base and a DCS TIU.


Rusty

Originally Posted by NotInWI:
The steamer runs and looks fantastic! The packaging had nice foam rubber inserts to help protect the engine from FedEx Santa while it was in shipping. It is only running around my conventional Christmas layout under the tree so I have not gotten to try all the legacy features yet. Can't wait to see the SD70's! Ben

Ben, glad to see that you like your Y3 so much!  Enjoy man!  Was curious if you can say what version of Legacy yours came with.  Since it did not come with an orange module, did it happen to come with v. 1.51 as Rusty referenced above? 

Great to hear that Y3s arriving.   Would love to know, better yet hear, which whistles come with which road names or if they all got the same whistle.  Based on YouTube videos, their O gauge counterparts seem to have some with one whistle and others with a different one.  I'd like the hollow haunting whistle that the Virginian O unit has as opposed to, for example, the one in the PRR units.

Picked up my N&W Y3 last night (Friday) at my friendly LHS.  Shot a couple of quick pictures this morning.  Three things come to mind right off the bat.

 

1.  The box is reasonably sized for the locomotive, not the massive monolith suitable for apes dancing around it that the Challenger came in.

2. Heavy metal...  The tender weighs just about as much as the locomotive!

3. I wish these things came with scale wheels.  The Y3 fits so nicely into a scale environment otherwise:

rY3 122212 02

 

Nobody ever takes rear shots of steam locomotives, but I do:

rY3 122212 03

 

Oooo La-La, Close coupling of the engine and tender:

rY3 122212 04

 

And we climb into the Kansas Grain Belt's airship for an aerial view:

rY3 122212 05

 

I haven't put down a loop of S-Trax track to exercise it yet, but we did test run it at the LHS, which brings us to:

 

The Dark Side...

My Y3 failed on the test track.  It ran in fine reverse, but when placed in forward, it wouldn't move and smoke came from the locomotive where smoke shouldn't come from.  The LHS owner said it's the same thing occurred to a Santa Fe Y3 he ordered for store stock. 

 

Resolved:

This one was another he ordered for stock that passed a test run and was in the display case, so he exchanged locomotives for me on the spot.  Otherwise, I wouldn't be writing this.

 

Another customer had two on layaway (Santa Fe and Pennsy) so those were test run immediately with the customer's permission.  Both of them ran fine. 

 

So that's 2 failures out of 5 locomotives, not a good average.  Hopefully, it was just a fluke.  The two failures go back to Lionel.

 

Rusty

Attachments

Images (4)
  • rY3 122212 02
  • rY3 122212 03
  • rY3 122212 04
  • rY3 122212 05
Last edited by Rusty Traque

Jon, you absolutely just made my day. I'm assuming it will be a company like NWSL or similar. Honestly, i don't really care who does it as long as it works. it would be fantastic if all future steam offering could be converted. With your excellent DCC implementation that really opens up a lot of options for a lot of people. As soon as you can confirm the details I'll probably order a pair of Y3s.

 

Great news!

Just finished testing out my Y3. Ran well but one problem: not one wisp of smoke from the stack. The switch is on and I added fluid per the instructions. I also tried all of the legacy smoke settings and still no smoke. I can feel puffs of air from the fan as the loco moves. Not a good track record for me and Lionel big steam: 4 engines (big boy, 2 challengers, Y3) all with problems right out of the box needing to go to Lionel for repair
Originally Posted by Tom Robinson:
My engine also did not include the front boiler number board or the nice  conversion kit to Kadee scale couplers that was included with the Challenger and U33C. There is also no off switch for the AF speed control. I received a very terse reply from Lionel than none of the above was to be included in spite of their pre-delivery announcements.

 

That's because the UP Y3's didn't have a smokebox front number board:

SmokeOverDivide UP Y3

Image: Smoke Over The Divide, Ehernberger and Gschwind, E&B Publishing, c. 1965

 

It's not the first time things changed between the catalog and the final product.  You got the standard "Verify contents/features on the box" type of reply, right?  The "Talk to Us" folks are not always the most helpful or charming people in the world.  I think sometimes they work in an isolation chamber hidden in the basement.

 

Rusty

Attachments

Images (1)
  • SmokeOverDivide UP Y3
Last edited by Rusty Traque
Originally Posted by Tom's Turnouts:

Are the N&Ws the only ones to have shipped so far?  I’m waiting on a PRR model and haven’t heard a thing.

 

Thanks,

 

Tom Stoltz

InMaine

As far as I can tell, they're all out.  A friend of mine has a Santa Fe and PRR sitting on layaway at our LHS, Carl Tuvson's posted a review with the UP.  The only one I haven't seen is the Virginian.

 

Give it a little time, because of Christmas falling so close to the distributors receiving their shipments, shipping from the distributors is a little messed up.  My LHS got part of his Lionel shipment last week and is expecting the remainder this week.

 

Rusty

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×