Skip to main content

Hello,

This is my first ever layout and I built it with little knowledge, I wish I would have found this site before I built it.  As you can see I neglected to make a turn around anywhere on the layout. Trains can only go one way so I added the inside loop 0-31 and run my LionChiefs there and on the outer loop O-36, I run my MTH Subway sets, the blue track is O-27.  I ordered the MTH TUI which hopefully I will be receiving in a couple months.  I would like to connect the inner and outer loop, but can't figure it out, lol.

IMG_1685[2)

my space is 11'x48" on back wall and 9'x40" on the side wall...

Maybe some of you guys can give me some tips

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_1685(2)
Last edited by Rich Melvin
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Jorge, thank you for posting the file.  Unfortunately, SCARM doesn't warn when tracks don't actually work in the real world, as is the case with trying to place O31 inside O36 curves without widening the outer diameter in some way.  In the image below, the Show Roadbed setting is enabled.  The orange track's roadbed overlaps the outer grey loop, which in turn also overlaps the light blue loop below.

Overlapping Roadbed



You'll be able to see the overlapping tracks in SCARM Version 1.8 if you go to Tools Menu - Settings - 2D View and and turn on Roadbed.

Roadbed Setting

Before adding reversing loops, crossovers, and grades, you'll may want to consider some changes to make your basic plan work in the space available and/or allocate a little more width on the bench for the outer loops.  If you could widen the back Grey O36 back loop, this would give you more flexibility.  Maybe the easiest way to widen the loops would be with short straight sections oriented at 9 and 3 o'clock.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Overlapping Roadbed
  • Roadbed Setting
Last edited by SteveH

One more thing to consider when planning your layout is center rail to center rail adjacent track spacing to avoid overhanging locomotives and cars going around curves from colliding.  NRMA standard specifies 6" spacing between center rails.  With smaller locos and shorter cars, you can get away with less.  Testing with your longest cars and locos will help you figure out what you'll need for your layout.  After you've determined the minimum spacing your trains need, you can use the Tape Measure tool in SCARM to check this as you continue planning your layout.

Click the underlined Link below go to a recent topic on this subject with some very good commentary and pictures to help explain this:

Track Diameter and Spacing

Last edited by SteveH

One possible solution would be to add any of the three switches shown in the attached (it looks like you are running CCW) or incorporating a single or double crossover at the 4 locations shown. These are switches just connected back-to-back. If you're using Fastrack you could use two or four O-72 switches. I'd have to check to be sure, but these would give you about a 6" centerline to centerline spacing which would be sufficient for passing on the straights. As Steve said, you may need to move some track around to fit them in.

If you didn't want to use switches, you could incorporate a 22.5 degree Fastrack crossover with a little re-arranging of the track.

By connecting the tracks, the TIU will generate a signal to all areas of your layout - however, you will need to add power drops all around the layout and may need to create blocks.

InkedIMG_1685[2%29_LINEW LAYOUT 8TRACK 4

22.5 DEGREE CROSSOVER

Attachments

Images (4)
  • InkedIMG_1685(2%29_LI
  • NEW LAYOUT 8
  • TRACK 4
  • 22.5 DEGREE CROSSOVER

I agree with the above advice.

Congratulations.  You have made it to the point where you have made a layout and now you want more.  One wonderful feature of sectional track is that you can easily take it apart and play with it, especially when your layout is flat.

I would start by thinking about your biggest possible (L-shaped) "grand tour" route.  The crossovers and direction changes work best in pairs, but this is not absolutely necessary.  I would consider putting as much of this switching action as possible at the angle where the "L" comes together.

Thanks for all the tips guys, I'm waiting for the new TIU to arrive, then I will tear down the layout and redo it with more space.  I wasn't aware of all the different sizes of tracks when I did it, I didn't think you can mix and match the different switches until now. I also want to do a second level since its all flat except the small elevated rail.

You might also consider looking at other fora and at track manufacturer's websites for layout design ideas.  I am also curious about a few comments you made.

1.  What are you planning to run on the O27 loop and will it be completely elevated using  Lionel trestle pieces or something custom made?

2.  Are you running your subway sets on the longer track so you can place multiple stops between the track and walls, even if you just painted stops with background city scenery?  (I ask this question because many run their subways on smaller, elevated ovals in a downtown area of a city with just 4 stops, one on each edge of the oval.)

3.  Wouldn't you like to run your subway sets on a smaller, double track oval so those trains can run in each direction around the oval?

4.  Have you considered running anything other than ovals?  Possible examples include point-to-point (usually requires a lot more space), point-to-loop (train leaves yard, traverses layout going through a return loop, and returns to same yard), loop-to-loop (often with a yard between loops) so you can still have continuous running with trains moving in opposite directions, and lots more.

5.  Have you planned for scenery, industries and towns?

Just some food for thought.

Chuck

Last edited by PRR1950

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×