Skip to main content

I'm building benchwork which amounts to 4x8 tables which will be abutted to one another and then screwed together. For each table, i'm contemplating how to join the legs to the frame.   I plan on using two 2x4's for each leg, planed down and glued together.  The question is, would it be better to stagger the leg pieces so the benchwork support frame rests on top of one 2x4 while the other extends upward on the interior (1st photo), or place both on the interior together (2nd photo) and screw into the bench top frame from the sides?  (As shown, the vertical 2x4s represent the legs, and the table top would be where my blue garage floor is, so you're looking at the table from the bottom). Is it better to partially butt the legs up to the table frame (option 1, left) or is it sufficient to butt up to the table and screw into the legs from the table frame (option 2, right). 

 

design mockup photos....

option 1 (left):  one leg butts up to the table top frame, the other butts up to the table top. (screws from top and sides as shown) 

option2 (right): both legs butt up to the table top, screws to table frame from the sides as shown.

 

tablelegs1tablelegs2

any structural engineers out there?  

(5/8" plywood table top)

Attachments

Images (2)
  • tablelegs1
  • tablelegs2
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have never built tables with a 2/4 frame. I have always used 1/4's. I make my legs out of 2/4's. I attached them to the table with 5/16 bolts. Two bolts per leg. The bottom of the leg I use 5/16 carriage bolts for leveling screws. I drill a hole for the bolt then I drill a little larger hole for the nut  ...............Paul

DSCN2422

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN2422

I plan on staggering mine. On the ends that don't get bolted to another table, both legs will be full length to form a 4x4. Where the ends do get bolted together, I plan on one leg being a short cleat about 12" long. When the tables are bolted together, the 2 full-length legs will then form the 4x4. I see no reason to end up with two 4x4 legs so close to each other. I've used 4x8 tables with single 2x4 legs. Where the tables were bolted together, I didn't bother with a double set of legs. The legs had bottom rails for stability and weren't subjected to a lot of weight though.

Last edited by DoubleDAZ

You will find that using 1" x 4" white pine will make for less warping and twisting of the legs and frame members.  Plus the finished product will actually be stronger than tables made from 2" x 4"s.  Working with 1" x material will be easier also.  It's lighter and simpler to drill pilot holes for screws.   

The legs should be made from two pieces of 1" x 4" screwed and preferably glued together to form an "L".  

In your case, where you are going to fasten the tables together I would suggest using "sex bolts".  They will allow you to dismantle and reassemble the tables if that is something you have in mind for the future.  

Thanks all for the suggestions.  Well, i have the 2x4's and they are a nice grade (no warping... of course i hand-selected each piece at the shop).  It's probably overkill and I'll end up with a table space that's probably walkable. 

legs-and-frame-joists

(cut table legs and table frame joists)

plan

the concept plan.  I'm cursed with a room with diagonally-opposed entrance and exit. Train storage closet entrance is upper right, Hallway entrance and rest of basement is the lower left.  Trying to keep it to a minimum o72 in the space, so it's a variation on a dogbone overlapped on 2 levels.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • legs-and-frame-joists
  • plan

I just visited a large multi-level layout (thanks Peter) that uses 1x4 frames in 4x4 modules with 2x4 legs and 1x2 angled braces. The first module has 4 legs and subsequent modules have only 2. The modules are topped with 1/2" plywood underlayment screwed to the frame with drywall screws and a Homasote-like sub-roadbed is glued on top of that. The modules are bolted together and the result is walkable and very stable. I was going to use 2x4s for rails and 3/4" plywood, but now I'm going to follow his methodology, assuming I can find the Homasote-like material he uses. He also runs GarGraves track and I was completely surprised by how quiet it was. It has caused me to reconsider using GarGraves (Made in USA) and I'm in the process of reworking my design to accommodate its curve sizes. It'll be a lot cheaper and more readily available than either Atlas or ScaleTrax.

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×