Originally Posted by Ireland:
Thank you.
I am considering double faced tape in a few places to preclude the carpet from shifting. An advantage of the Stainmaster brand underpadding it the very thin backing which takes liquid and aerosol paints without cracking or peeling, no matter how sharply it is bent over.
I may just go staight to some heavier cut or loop pile carpet or perhaps Berber.
I can understand what you want to achieve, but the reduction of sound transmission is always a matter of compromises. Some people believe that using dry wall board under plywood makes the platform too heavy. It does, no question about it. But it effectively increases the mass of the platform to stifle vibration, much like running a train on a concrete floor. You have two different problems: one is the vibration and sound transmission from the platform stemming from the train tracks on that platform that induce the vibration from the train itself--the tracks being the conduit. The other is any sound transmitted into the air from the train just going on the track sections. Some have used rigid foam, homosote, carpet, cork, etc. to absorb (but not eliminate) vibration. Different densities of these various materials are more or less effective for this. I would prefer increasing mass first and then applying any of those materials. For a compromise, however, you may just want to place the carpet down over the entire layout (it will increase the mass because carpet is heavier than rigid foam or homosote at the same time it has some density from the piles to absorb sound from the tracks). I used cork myself in this fashion simply because I was able to fix screws into the track and cork without going through into the plywood. Carpet will not allow for this so you might have to screw the track past the carpet into the wood. The compromise: Use fewer, more strategically placed screws. The carpet can absorb some vibration transmitted from the screws into the plywood--so it won't be totally sound-proof, but covering the entire board will help as well. Sometimes even though vibration is not reduced enough, the materials it passes through causes the frequency response of the sound caused by that vibration to be lowered so as to be inaudible or below the threshold of one's offense to the sound that is generated.