Skip to main content

Since I am trying to get as much as I can as running a couple of trains, a trolley and a yard for putting together consists, I am staying with my original O36 Fastrack Curves and Switches. I was thinking about but it is going to limit what size trains I can run.

 

I now have a somewhat local solution for the bigger stuff!

 

I am now a Member of NJ HiRailers and can run my bigger stuff on the clubs layout!

 

This home layout will be for the occasional stress release and when I have the Grandkids over for a visit. (Not that I will not be having them come up to the club at some point also)

 

The plan is to use half of one side of the finished basement, with the other area my train work bench etc. (may have to run a spur over there but that will be later)

 

Now I want to get your opinions of any final tweaks that you feel that might be needed, as there is a whole lot more people out there that know more than I.

 

After that will be the benchwork, taking offers to help if you can! LOL

 

So, take a look, as I want to start getting the benchwork started no longer than Thanksgiving and get the track laid before Christmas. (At least some of it)

 

Attached should be a pdf of the layout and a RR-Track Ver 5.0 file.

 

Thanks in advance,

 

 

 

Attachments

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Dennis,

 

Three comments:

 

1. No identified access hatches in middle of plan;  reaching those switches and eventual derailments in the middle will be very difficult without them.  And, how long will you be comfortable "ducking" the long way to a hatch?

 

2. Yard configuration/length isn't going to be adequate unless you are only talking about 4-6 car consists.  Yard also lacks the often recommended "yard lead."

 

3. How will your upper level be supported?  If the lower level track underneath will not be visible, think hard about how complicated you want the hidden track to be.

 

Even with these potential issues, your plan still looks like a lot of fun!

 

Chuck

If it's just for occasional use and grand kids, I think it's overly complicated.  I would do one or two spurs for switching just for the heck of it, a separate trolley line in super streets for ease of install, and some big loops that snake around a bit for visual interest.  Add some features close to the edge that they can play with, a farm, etc. and use inexpensive 0-27 rolling stock that you don't have to worry about.  

 

 

Dennis, this looks like a fun layout, and I get using O-36.   However, with some adjustments, it appears that you could use O-48 for the outside line on the left side.   It will better match with the O-36 as two parallel lines flowing through the curves at the corners for a better and more satisfying look.  

 

There is less friction going around wider curves, so a decently-long train (10 cars) will slow less going around O-48 curves than it will with O-36.  It appears that the outer line is also going up a grade, so the friction element will be important to train performance, and less throttle management to get the train up, and avoid a runaway on the way down.   For that matter, the wider curves can support higher train speeds so a high-speed derailment on the way down becomes a bit less likely (any kids at the throttle?).

-Ken

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×