Skip to main content

Discussion from a different thread leads to this idea for a discussion thread where folks can record and share their experience of what works.   Analysis of what center spacing clearance is needed (or works fine) for different locos at different curve diameters.  I have data points to contribute: 

         LOCOs/Cars                                                       Inside Diam.    Outside Diam.                 Center Spacing

  • LC+ steamers, train-set passenger cars             O36                    O44.5                                  4.25" (easily)
  • LC+ scale SD60M and smaller diesels                O36                    O44.5                                  4.25"
  • MTH RailKing SD70Ace                                         O36                    O44.5                                  4.25" (easily)
  • LC+/Conventional FT&Passenger                        O36                    O44.5                                  4.25" (easily)
  • Lionel Legacy Big Boy                                           O72                    O82                                     5" (barely-GRJ)

 

Some interesting data points would be nice to have as a reference resource:

  • MTH RailKing Big Boy                                          O31 or O36          ?                                        ?
  • MTH RailKing Challenger                                    O31 or O36          ?                                        ?
  • Lionel Legacy Big Boy                                          O90                   O99??                                   ??

 

Notes:

  • O42 and O44.5 FasTrack discussed HERE
Last edited by Ken-Oscale
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

You only have half of the equation.  Assuming the locomotive is on the inside of the curve, what is on the outside?  I have 4.25" center to center spacing on O72 inside curves.  My biggest engines (Lionel Y-3 2-8-8-2 and MTH Centipedes) work fine with a freight train (scale 40 to 50 foot cars) on the outside curve.  The combination of one of these locomotives on the inside with a passenger train (scale 80 foot cars) on the outside results in a sideswipe.  A friend has tested a scale Big Boy in the inside with scale 80 to 84 foot (21 inch) passenger cars on the outside and found that 5.5" center to center spacing was required.

Yep, we determined that we really need at least 5.5" on O99 curves to allow the VL-BB and 21" passenger cars on the adjacent tracks not to get together.  The scale Allegheny, Challenger, and Y6b come in right behind with just a bit less overhang.

On the smaller side of things, RailKing and Lionel semi-scale and smaller scale locomotives typically don't require nearly the same amount of clearance. My scale A-5 hardly hangs over at all.

If you're laying track, it's likely very important to determine the worst case for your current and intended future locomotive and rolling stock mix to determine what clearance you will need.

Add Reply

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×