Skip to main content

PXL_20250201_153834422.MPPXL_20250201_153844373PXL_20250201_153857835PXL_20250201_153949769

I've been going through the piles of items I've kind of tossed aside from collections I've purchased.  I found 4 engine boxes for engines that I don't have, and as far as I know, were not in the collections that I've purchased.  There are a 2037, 216 (wish I had that engine), a 230, and a 231P box.

Since I didn't necessarily remember what these engines were, I looked them up on Ebay.  Imagine my surprise to find someone asking $350 for a 231P box.  Is that even possible?  I had to pick my jaw up off of the floor.  I've sold empty boxes for what I would consider crazy prices but they were for a Congressional Set and a 2341 Jersey Central Trainmaster box, not a small Alco A unit.  This price just seemed off the wall.  Is the box for the 231P that rare?

Attachments

Images (4)
  • PXL_20250201_153834422.MP
  • PXL_20250201_153844373
  • PXL_20250201_153857835
  • PXL_20250201_153949769
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I am tracking it.  Considering there is a complete boxed set with the boxed 231, all other boxes, including the set box currently at around $200, and a boxed 231 with original box sold for around $150, I'm really interested in seeing why this box has a $350 asking price on it.  I'm kind of wondering if they meant to put it at $35, which would seem more reasonable.

I could see a premium for a good box for the one year only 216 and 230 but the 231 was made for about 3 years and is quite common. I guess time will tell.

Hi Chuck,

Thanks for pointing that out.  I didn't see it before.  The asking prices seem real strange considering many of the boxes are anything but rare.  The brick and mortar store associated with this seller is only about 15 minutes away from me.  I have never used them because they were always "The high priced spread".  I guess that still goes for their on-line accounts.

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×