Skip to main content

Got the tender opened up and see the antenna wire (black w/white trace) is connected to a screw which holds down the speaker (not the two wires going to the speaker itself), which fits with Scott's statement the entire tender body is the antenna.  Check for continuity between all the wheels, axles, tender body to wheels/axles, draw-bar ... all of it and none of it is showing any continuity, so I'm thinking the tender is isolated.  Swapped radio board with one from Sunset with no improvement.  I should clarify this locomotive has never run  well due to lost signal issues.  A return to Sunset didn't improve it.

I'm going to unscrew the ANNT wire from the speaker, attach it to a long piece of wire and thread that out the tether hole in the front of the tender to see if that improves it.

Puzzled how this will ever work without just having it upgraded to ERR .... spendy.

Is it accurate to state there is no way to improve the antenna reception beyond what we've tried?

Last edited by Kerrigan
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I think this may be an occasional problem for 3rd Rail locos. Continuity tests in a "sterile" environment may not reveal the problem, since it could occur when the tender is in service.

The isolated tender shell as antenna should work well. The secret is to isolate the shell from the frame. So, buy a roll of Kapton tape and some appropriately-sized nylon screws. Tape all around the edges of the frame, making sure that no part of the shell contacts the frame; secure the frame to the shell with nylon screws.

rex desilets posted:

I think this may be an occasional problem for 3rd Rail locos. Continuity tests in a "sterile" environment may not reveal the problem, since it could occur when the tender is in service.

The isolated tender shell as antenna should work well. The secret is to isolate the shell from the frame. So, buy a roll of Kapton tape and some appropriately-sized nylon screws. Tape all around the edges of the frame, making sure that no part of the shell contacts the frame; secure the frame to the shell with nylon screws.

That's the ticket we're gonna punch, Rex.  Got the ingredients and just have to find the time to do it.   These locomotive have great detailing and the older Z-8 has never left the layout.  That said, the smaller ones are lighter pullers being brass instead of cast.

The prices rising faster than a hot air balloon from all the makers has turned the new-stuff-budget into the repair-existing-stuff fund.

Fixing it will be challenging; have to lay down a lot of Kapton tape to isolate the Vanderbuit-bottom tender, as well as around the frame and ends where the shell lies on the frame.

The flying wire antenna will proof the guess it's the antenna for sure.

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I can't imagine why it's not liking the whole tender as the antenna, my guess is as it runs you're getting some connection.  Check and see if it's connected to the locomotive and rolling stock that the tender shell is still isolated.

My guess is that the trucks are not truly "floated" from the tender, as in intermediate contact. I think you addressed. the 3rd Rail issue before.

Anyway, I have a couple of brass locos (Weaver, 3rd Rail) that display the intermediate loss of signal, which I can "fix" with a "jiggle" of the tender. So, when I get a couple of round tuits I'll get on to the job.

Craignor posted:

Why not send it back for warranty repair?

Long out of warranty.  Sent it back when I first received it and nothing changed.  Scott suggested just having Sunset upgrade it.

As we know it's an antenna related problem I'm not giving up yet ... have my rolls of Kapton tape and nylon screws ... :-)

gunrunnerjohn posted:

I can't imagine why it's not liking the whole tender as the antenna, my guess is as it runs you're getting some connection.  Check and see if it's connected to the locomotive and rolling stock that the tender shell is still isolated.

Appears to be isolated by ohm meter ... but there could be a leak somewhere.  Just going to tape it up and try that ...

 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×