Skip to main content

After several years and lots of learning and frustration, I am backing out of the TMCC repair business.  Although I do like a good puzzle, I find some of the repair jobs to be very frustrating because I don't have enough information or parts are not available.  Lionel now seems to have a nice line of "new and improved" power controller products that are probably a better investment than repairing some of the old gear.

 

I also find that repairs greatly detract from my time to do my own train projects. 

 

If I really charged an appropriate fee for my time, nobody could afford my repairs.  For example, just dealing with the initial contacts and preliminary diagnosis, receiving a package, billing and shipping the package back and receiving payment, without even considering any disassembly, repairs, assembly and testing involved, would rightfully run higher than what I have been charging for this AND the repairs.

 

I will continue to work through my backlog, but I don't solicit any new work. 

 

Thanks to everyone who has worked with me.  I am pleased to have been able to help most of you.  I will still offer to consult with people to help them solve their problems.  (I found that some of the bad devices were really OK, but either needed just a RESET or a change in how they were connected.)

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Dale Manquen:

...  For example, just dealing with the initial contacts and preliminary diagnosis, receiving a package, billing and shipping the package back and receiving payment, without even considering any disassembly, repairs, assembly and testing involved, would rightfully run higher than what I have been charging for this AND the repairs.

 

...

This is precisely the same challenge we as consumers face in the electronics industry at large.  For example, a few years ago one of my Sony Blu-ray single disc players was on the blink.  The replacement player now costs $79 at Best Buy.  So who's gonna spend that or more to have an earlier model repaired?    The technology treadmill can be a scary place at times.

 

David

I am not leaving the Forum.  I learn too much here.

 

I was using my earnings from repairs to buy stuff at TTOS, but I found I didn't have time to enjoy what I bought!  I would be surprised if my total net from repairs would be enough to buy a new Legacy engine.

 

To me, the repairs are like a puzzle.  I have generated a lot of documentation on the internals of many of the Lionel TMCC controllers.  Once I understand how a device works, I am ready to tear something new apart to see inside it.

Glad you are staying around and as the others have said, thank you for all you have done here. I hope you continue posting your electronic findings also.  I like reading all the electronics posts around here from all the knowledgeable forum members, many are over my head, but I enjoy them none the less. Some of it may even sink in eventually. I find the electronics part as enjoyable as the trains, maybe even more so at times.

Originally Posted by Dale Manquen:

If I really charged an appropriate fee for my time, nobody could afford my repairs.  For example, just dealing with the initial contacts and preliminary diagnosis, receiving a package, billing and shipping the package back and receiving payment, without even considering any disassembly, repairs, assembly and testing involved, would rightfully run higher than what I have been charging for this AND the repairs.

)

I can identify with this, as can, I think, many folks, certainly many who are self-employed. It can be a real issue. Many customers don't understand or appreciate the time and effort that is required to fix things or resolve certain problems. Because they don't understand or appreciate it, they don't want to pay a proper amount for it.

 

I suppose Gunrunnerjohn's little saying he puts with his posts is appropriate to an aspect of this: "Nothing is so easy as the job you imagine someone else doing."

Sounds good Dale.

I have never charged for consumer electronics, train, Ham radio, or BMW motorcycles repairs and as a result I have always been comfortable to reject any repair that I have not found interesting. It doesn't seem nice when I write it out, but it has served me well over the years...especially with the "can you repair my vcr?" questions.

 

Dale,

But you have to come to York again with your upside down train running on the loop of track!

The cab-1 you repaired for me years ago is still running fine. As for the other one I sent you last year, it is a present for you to break apart and use for your findings.

 

Catch you on the forum and hopefully you will come east again for a York meet in the future.

I am beginning to think about another trip.  My ladyfriend (one year and counting) and I spent 2 weeks at Lake Tahoe recently.  She was apprehensive about traveling with someone for that length of time (something new for her), but we had a great time and got along well.  She is originally from Paris, France, and she wants to see the USA.

 

She is also enjoying my trains.  She won a trophy at last year's Cal Stewart train races.  She has train layouts at her house for her 5 year old great grandson.  The O-gauge postwar layout is on wheels under the bed where he sleeps when he visits, and his Thomas set is out on the floor.  They are talking Polar Express for this Christmas...

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×