Originally Posted by ajzend:
The Babylonian quote is similar to some Roman ones as well. However, these reflect youth's unleashed energies. Today's youth have all of that plus a damaged and lower intellect from the massive electronics input, It truly is not the same. For all of the wildness of the roaring 20's America's moral center did not shift. People did not lose their work ethic and achievement orientation. Today's youth, and unfortunately, many of their parents are and are becoming lost causes. I don't say these things just standing on some old valued principles. As a physician I read medical studies that show this as fact. In fact, my father, as a physician as well, identified this situation decades ago when the only screen time was television. The lost intellect when early adulthood is reached is irreversible. This is also observational. I have seen the decline in high school graduates continually sink deeper into the toilet for 36 years. It's just not intellect either. It's moral character as well.
A stranger in a strange land.
Alan
I would love to see scientific studies about the lost intellect due to 'massive electronics input', that sounds quite frankly like pseudo science at best and crackpot thinking at worst. I think there are problems with all this electronic media, I do think that some or a lot of kids face consequences of being immersed too much, but I am tired of those who make generalizations like that, because it was crap. Back in my day we heard how TV was going to ruin us, all this crying about "Johnny can't read" and all that, and for most people it simply wasn't true. There are always problems, but I also am around a lot of young people, and the kids with trouble are generally the kids who always seemed to be in trouble. I also see young people in their 20's who end up revolutionizing the world, new idea are being developed, new concepts created, and want to know a dirty little secret? It isn't happening in the countries who top the list in achievement on standardized tests, primarily it is coming out of the US, and it is as always generally a young person's game.
I also would be careful about 'traditional values', the 1920s and 1930's were peak times for the KKK in this country, we had the America First movement in the 1930's that was all but a branch of the Nazi party in where its sympathies lay. And keep in mind that generation saw WWII, that killed at least 50 million people and saw brutality and inhumanity I could wish would not happen again but might, and it was committed by the most part by church going people who had the 'traditional values' you are extoling.
And while you can claim that the moral center of the world didn't change in the 1920's, people at the time said it was the end of the world, we had *gasp* women showing their legs in public (and in the movies), women were cutting their hair short, and were 'liberated' in ways their elders found shocking...and in many ways it did change, a lot changed then, because society is always changing.
It is always very easy to blame someone for the problems that are faced, people look at the economic insecurity felt in the US and they tend to blame the young, because that is a lot easier,that kids don't want to work, that they are lazy, that jobs go overseas because they demand too much, and what that is IMO is an excuse for the reality of things, that the world is very, very different then let's say the 1950's, where someone could piddle through high school and get a relatively well paying job. It isn't that kids don't want to work, a lot of them do, as much as I did or prior generations, it is that the landscape changed, between jobs being able to shift to places paying 1920's wages, to automation, it just isn't the same landscape it once was. I see a lot of good, hardworking kids, who quite frankly make my generation and prior ones look like slackers, and they have trouble because it simply isn't as easy as it once was.