Skip to main content

It seems that most of the issues that model railroaders are facing these days seem to be related to current production or products produced over the past twelve months or so. There also does not seem to be any one producer or product affected, but anything from engines to rolling stock to transformers and most recently to command control systems.

 

These issues range from engines not properly decorated with the correct logos or not operating on the minimum curves originally advertised to smoke units failing and those engines that run for a few minutes then die or are DOA. Rolling stock that is not decorated correctly or the color is wrong or not what was advertised or to passenger cars whose bodies are too high on the trucks to failures of the lighting systems.

 

Then all the issues with the command control systems from one particular manufacturer. The issues range from not being able to find the base to runaway engines to systems that worked one day and then did not work the next. Fried boards or broken control panels to charging systems that don't work.

 

You don't seem to hear about some of these issues especially about the engines and the control systems from past production. Production from say three to four years ago.

 

Now I'm not saying that there weren't problems, there were, but not to the extent that they are today.

 

I wonder if these issues with current production have more to do with, perhaps changes in specifications or components rather then who made it or where it was made.

 

Having to return items to the manufacturer or service centers is a pain even if they pay the postage, not to mention the cost to the manufacturer and loss of good will.

 

Any thoughts??

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I think the internet is the issue. It magnifies the problems. People seem to post their problems and try to use the forum to "shame" the manufactures into correcting them.

 

I have been in O gauge for over 20 years and have bought a lot of trains, I run DCS and mostly MTH railking. I can count the failures on one hand. If it really was as bad as some make it out to be, I think most of us would have given up on it long ago.

People, including me and I imagine most folks on this forum post more often when things go wrong than when they go right, yes.  I like that - want to know if others are having problems -- otherwise I assume, like most, that no news is good news.

 

But as long as I have been in O-gauge (about seven years now) it seems the same type of among of problems have been happening to about the same degree.  I don't have comprehensive surveys and stats to back this up, but I've really seen no evidence of an uptick in quality issues in the last year or so.  

 

As to is it as bad as it seems?  I guess it depends on what you consider bad.  The quality of toy trains, particularly new models as opposed to perennial favorites and RTR sets, etc., does seem lamentably poor to me, but I lieve with it nonetheless and it does not cause anything more than minor annoyance.  

 

My experience over the seven years is about 6% of new locomotive purchases have given some problem within the first month of ownership.  However, I tend to buy new models and often there of rather limited, special model runs, so these would be the most prone to problems.  

 

No manufacturer stands out one way on the other as to quality or lack of it: lately I've had more problems with MTH but there was a year or two not that long ago when my headaches were from Lionel and Atlas. 

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×