Skip to main content

High-tech items like model trains are very complex.  All those beautiful and amazing features we love can result in issues from time to time.

I have bought both NEW and USED locomotives and had more problems with brand-new ones than with models another hobbyist has previously owned.  This has been true of locomotives bought from individuals or from resellers like Trainz.  I have also observed that Lionel TMCC (Cab 1) engines from the early 2000s have been better when those were made in Korea (vs. China).  The Koreans of course have a long background of excellence in (for years) brass and later plastic-bodied engines. 

Trainz in the past have always UNDER-rated the products.  But in 100% of my purchases the items were better- sometimes far better- than what was stated.  In my most-recent experience, I just yesterday received a Lionel M1a Mountain from Trainz.  They described the Mountain on "the auction site" as "functional". 

What I got was a good price, packed and shipped carefully (and fast).

It was not perfect- had a bent tender axle- I straightened it.  The IR connection between the loco and the tender was being disrupted- I tweaked the two parts for a reliable connection.  It runs GREAT now.  The only way these could have been found would be with a fair amount of time and testing  on track.  (But you don't get THAT with a brand-new one either.)

But no needing to return for warranty service, no time wasted on the phone with "Customer Service".  Just a nice piece at a fair price. That was easily corrected.  Kudos to Trainz!

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have purchased numerous American Flyer engines and rolling stock both used and new old stock.  I've only had one that had problems the dealer took immediately took care of the problem. Trainz was great to work with.  I have been lucky with the old new stock never a problem.  Up until recently I purchased only old new stock but recently, I purchased 2 sets Alton Limited and New Jersy Central Blue Commit.  Both are like new and run great. 

I have had much better luck with buying second-hand vs. brand-new trains. Most of the second-hand locos I have bought are MTH equipped with PS2, and I have had zero issues. Some of them were previously run, while others were still NIB, but in both cases, there have been no issues other than old traction tires and noisy smoke unit fan motors, but I consider those items routine maintenance, not a mechanical failure, especially on a 20 year-old loco that has been sitting idle.

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×