Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

They are catalogued with Lionel's selection of traditional, semi-scale O gauge engines. However, when comparing them to similar O Scale Legacy diesels, they're within an inch of each other in length (the LC+ NW2 is 12" and Legacy is 12.25"). Therefore, I'd say they're near scale proportioned, and when I run my LC+ Nickel Plate NW2 alongside my LC+ Hudson Steam engine, the NW2 does look pretty large for a switcher.

Hope this helps. Overall, I'd say semi-scale O gauge, but near scale-proportioned. I could be wrong.

Lionel created the postwar NW2 as a scale model, but like many other “scale” models of the period (including Athearn’s first-generation models in HO and Arnold Rapido’s early N scale models), the models weren’t precisely accurate. 

Specifically, the postwar Lionel NW2 body used for the modern LionChief line has a hood that’s too wide, giving it a chunky look. The cab is also a hair too long. But it definitely is not traditional-sized.

I have an Atlas UP SW9, which has great scale fidelity, and a LionChief BN NW2. I’m happy with both. 

image

Attachments

Images (1)
  • image
@Phil55 posted:

Is it real O scale or the traditional semi scale O guage?

@Jim R. posted:

Lionel created the postwar NW2 as a scale model, but like many other “scale” models of the period (including Athearn’s first-generation models in HO and Arnold Rapido’s early N scale models), the models weren’t precisely accurate. 

Specifically, the postwar Lionel NW2 body used for the modern LionChief line has a hood that’s too wide, giving it a chunky look. The cab is also a hair too long. But it definitely is not traditional-sized.

I have an Atlas UP SW9, which has great scale fidelity, and a LionChief BN NW2. I’m happy with both. 

image

I run these engines at the club during shows on our waterfront section to push hoppers up to our rotary coal tipple because they can be run hard for 6 hours straight and when they do finally fail they are inexpensive to fix or replace.    There is nothing wrong with being a rivet-counter.  But like all other walks of life you will come across one you just want to smack upside the head - price of being human.   My point is that when I do encounter one who fits that description at our shows they've commented on everything but the fact the engine I'm running is not scale.  So if that matters to you, they're close enough that it's unlikely anyone will notice or comment. 

-Greg

 

After looking at the pictures that were posted I found that I was impressed with the handrails being wire formed. If they are using postwar molds would they be the same for when the switcher was changed and got cheapened with sheet metal rails instead of the wire form rails on the earlier models?

Someone commented on that they liked that the postwar molds were being used  instead of Chinese ones. But, if the postwar molds are being  used aren’t they  being used in China?

Alan

I have a  LC+ Southern NW2 and easily swapped shells with my 1994 U.S.Navy NW2. It’s dependable, powerful (compared to the puny original Navy motor) and smokes like a dream. The only modification I had to do was drill holes for the smoke. The electronics fill the cab, so I printed up some card stock for the interior.

604E8404-835D-4A1E-9DB2-2599F016F747

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 604E8404-835D-4A1E-9DB2-2599F016F747

I have always been a fan of the Post War NW2. I have no Lionchief engines but have upgraded a couple of Williams NW2s to TMCC back when it was affordable, both the engines and electronics. 

This is a 37 dollar Williams engine with an ERR Cruise lite ($35) and ERR Railsounds.

Something to consider if Lionel.has not made a particular roadname you are interested in.

Pete

Attachments

Videos (1)
trim.9211315B-8ACB-41A0-95B8-6E2A00DF3667
Last edited by Norton

Most of the PW molds were moved to China in 2001.  They have been tweaked etc over the years.  The handrails being mounted to the frame would not affect the body tooling.  They have also added detail back to PW molds such as portholes in the F units etc.  These NW2s do have new scale diecast trucks.  A very nice value.

I was referring to the complete new designs of lower end Chinese / some formerly Korean sourced locos.  Not a fan of that new Berkshire, baby Hudson, Camelback, 0-6-0, etc.  Prefer those lower end locos based off the PW tooling.  

Last edited by Mike W.

The lionchief+ NW2 I just bought new has a very "droopy " front electro coupler. It fires ok but it's so low it won't couple to anything. It appears to have a lot of slop in it. How is this thing fastened to the truck?  I'm wondering how difficult it would be to remove the shell and try to tighten the coupler or would I be better off just to return it?

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×