Skip to main content

My Lionel ZW C transformer bit the dust back in early December. Although the repair part is readily available, I have not found anyone willing to dig into the transformer and make the repair.

My only option was to order a new ZW L. Thinking I would never need a ZW L I have not paid much attention to reviews about the ZW L.

I would like to hear from users of the ZW L about their experience with this transformer and any advice they may have about using it.

One question I do have is regarding phasing the ZW L with post war ZW transformers.  I have two PW ZW transformer that were phased with my ZW C. They are used for accessory power and an alternative power source (protected with fuses for circuit breakers) for switching in the yard. I downloaded a manual for the ZW L, but I have not found any information about phasing the ZW L with other transformers.

One final question - My ZW C would never consistently supply 18v for track power because the gears on the throttles would never stay calibrated. was this problem corrected on the ZW L?

I'm looking forward to hearing your thoughts about the ZW L.

Thanks,

Richard Gonzales

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have a ZW-L and and PW ZW and I have them in phase.  I used the plug from the ZW-L as the guide since that has one prong larger than the other for polarity, I then matched the ZW to that using the phasing techniques covered in other places on this forum. 

I love my ZW-L, tons of power, fast acting breakers and I recently added TMCC to my layout and have the handles on the ZW-L programed as tracks which is great since the ZW-L has the powermaster technology built in.  I run 4 tracks off my ZW-L with 5 trains on them, a mix of Lionel Legacy and PW / MPC engines and this transformer doesn't have any issues.  I really like the gauges built in, they are really helpful when running my PW or MPC stuff so that I know exactly what voltage to set so I can get the speed I want. 

Also, a little silly, but it just looks so amazing next to the layout! 

I grabbed one I saw at a local hobby shop last year before all the prices started to climb which I think makes this a great bargin.

Just one thing to think of, do you need the post war ZW's? The ZW-L is rated at 620 watts, that might be enough to cover your needs (though you could use the PW ZW's for accessories of course). Not saying you should do that, but might be simpler wiring and a smaller footprint. Combined you zw-c (360w) and postwar ZW (380 output for the two) is 740W total, but would 620 suffice?

My Lionel ZW C transformer bit the dust back in early December. Although the repair part is readily available, I have not found anyone willing to dig into the transformer and make the repair.



Richard,

There are many people who've posted on this forum over the years about how much they like the ZW-L, but we have no strong knowledge of how many ZW-L's have failed since it was first introduced in 2013.

You likely already know about the ZW-C's limitations because you have one, but with it we still have no idea how many of them have failed since they went into production.

Without these numbers it's a guess.  Just gut feel.

I say go with the ZW-L because it looks better.

So, ultimately the answer really lies in your first sentence.

Because what we do know quite well is that if you can't get someone to fix your broken ZW-C then you won't be able to get your new ZW-L fixed either, especially if it dies soon after the warranty expires, or even at some time after it gets older.

Mike

Last edited by Mellow Hudson Mike

I have two ZW-L's, in service 7 years, no issues. The handles are set at a constant position, a Cab 2 is used to adjust track voltage for conventional operation or to set the preselected voltage for Command control operation.

As a two railer I really appreciate the foldback circuit protection. When I run an engine into an open turnout causing a short, (happens more frequently than I should admit) I have about three seconds to move the engine back a couple inches off the frog without tripping the breaker.

I have no idea of the cost of a new Lionel Transformer. I have been using two ZW pw units for over 30 years. I always had trouble getting the horns, whistles and bells to work., especially on Weaver and MTH engines. It was suggested I upgrade to MTH's big transformer. I purchased it at York for $600  and have loved it since. It goes up to 24 volts and all the bells and whistles operate. Just adding my two cents here. Bill

Well, once again the OGR forum has really come through with great answers to my questions about the ZW L

There are too many replies to comment on individually. Thak you all for the great advice and clearing up all my concerns about the ZW L.

I received a note from RO yesterday to let me know my ZW L has shipped. I will post some pictures after I get in installed on the control panel.

Thanks again to all,

Richard Gonzales

@Richard Gonzales, I just glanced at your thread showing interest in the Giant ZW-L Lionel transformer and decided to see what was on your mind. I’ve lifted one of these transformers and they are heavy. Seeing that you have one ordered, I recommend you get/borrow a sturdy hand truck for taking this truly nice train controller up to your really cool train room. Congratulations on getting the best and let us know your opinion on how it works for you. Happy New Year…. It’s time to plan a trip to Memphis in next few weeks. Happy Railroading Everyone

Thanks Larry,

It's good to hear from you. I got roped into local politics four years ago and did not have much time for trains. I really enjoyed being on the Lakeland board of Commissioners, but four years was enough for me and especially the wife! 

To be clear I promised myself that I would never shell out the big bucks for a ZW L.  My ZW C with its throttle / constant habit of not providing 18v and the need for adjusting the gears was something I was willing to live with. After making the latest adjustment to the gears in December a pin on the Molex connector under the A throttle broke off when I was trying to reconnect the 180v brick. The ZW C must have one brick connected to the A throttle so now it is a door stop because I cannot find anyone willing to make the repair, and I don't blame them. There is a lot of electronics in that ZW c controller, and I do not see any way to easily get to the Molex connector in order to replace it.

The ZW L from RO shipped a few days ago. I will let you know how it goes. Maybe I will hire a crane to lift it up to the second-floor train room window in order to get it on the control panel



Our next Casey Jones Chapter TCA train show will be on February 4th. Let me know If you can make it down here. Send me an email address and I will send you a flyer.

Thanks, and Happy New Year!

Richard

I don’t have one but recommended it to a friend for his massive layout.  It looks and works great, TMCC hook up was a breeze.  Circuit breaker trips with amazing speed.  He runs conventional but I have brought over my tmcc stuff to run.  Didn't know you could program a track with this piece, have to give that a try.  If i needed a transformer this would be the one.

I had two Z-4000 for about ten years ... until the ZW-L was released. 

I bought one in 2014 and sold the Z-4000s.  Not a moment of regret as the ZW-L has a perfect precision and feel & great operational qualities - while looking sharp near the layout.

I'm buying a second ZW-L as soon as the next batch is released ... probably in the next couple of months.

Bit of trivia:  The ZW-L has a very unique feature in that it can allocate amperage to the channel that needs it the most, up to 10 amps per output channel. As long as the 620 watt max was observed, the power is channeled dynamically in real time. The genius behind the software to accomplish this amazing behavior was Lou Kovach.  

@SantaFeFan posted:

Bit of trivia:  The ZW-L has a very unique feature in that it can allocate amperage to the channel that needs it the most, up to 10 amps per output channel. As long as the 620 watt max was observed, the power is channeled dynamically in real time. The genius behind the software to accomplish this amazing behavior was Lou Kovach.  

I love my ZW-L.

Do you know what has become of Lou?  I met him a few times, once here at the Carnegie Science Center. He always seemed like he had a good handle on the model train business.

Ditto on the ZW-L.  Had it for now 4 years or so, no issues.  FYI- pretty much all my engines, pulling 15 or more cars, draw a little less than 2 amps ( 36 watts) each.  I use one output for the constant 18v used to run tracks controlled by TMCC, another at 18v to the switches.  Occasionally I run conventional engines using TMCC to manage track voltage and get walk around remote control.

I run an MTH Bump and Go trolley plus accessories and lighting using two pw ZWs through buck converters to get DC and reduce voltage where I want (the Menard's York Hotel will burn out your eyes on 4.5 v!!).

@MartyE posted:

I love my ZW-L.

Do you know what has become of Lou?  I met him a few times, once here at the Carnegie Science Center. He always seemed like he had a good handle on the model train business.

Marty, Lou is back to his ICC controls work last I knew.  I know his work has to do with custom automation systems, but I don't know much in the way of details.  I connected with Lou a year or so ago, and he was quite busy and doing well.  He did so much design work for Lionel over the years, and he used to tell me with quite a chuckle about how many times Lionel an he parted, but get back together for more projects.  I recall something like 4 times!  Amazing person, I really enjoyed working with him.  Learned a lot from him for sure.  In the early Legacy development time frame, the team used to meet at his house in MI to collaborate, and late at night we would all watch 50's era Sci-Fi movies!  You know for inspiration

Last edited by SantaFeFan

Hi Richard,  We had a great time at the TCA Train Meet in Germantown Tennessee yesterday and meeting so many fine model railroaders and seeing so many nice trains for sale. I look forward to seeing the group in April. My grandsons and wife and youngest son had a lot of fun. On our drive from Clarksville, we drove through a winter wonderland as the trees were gleaming in ice…. Thank you for the invitation. Happy Railroading Everyone 8786C244-B2C8-4B49-BAC2-4328CE9027DCD3D379B7-6E2E-4644-B37E-584ECEEC98C4

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 8786C244-B2C8-4B49-BAC2-4328CE9027DC
  • D3D379B7-6E2E-4644-B37E-584ECEEC98C4

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×