Skip to main content

Announcing Lee Marsh Models a new importer of o scale brass. His first American prototype ( that I know of) will be the Southern Pacific GS series steam locomotives. A pilot model is due to be displayed at the up coming Chicago O Scale Show in March 2019.

Attachments

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I go to England every year and his models are regarded as the best, well above my price range, I still have a look at his locomotives and rolling stock and talked to people that have bought them. He usually has a stand at Guildex the largest O Gauge only show in Europe that's where I have seen his models.

If you can afford to spend that type of money it would not be wasted.

Now back to my plastic locos!  Roo.

Adriatic posted:

Actually, the links don't work for me. 

For some reason I can only view about half of the PDF files I run across.

Nothing new.  I've never .... or more precisely, non of my 8 computers/devices in the last 5 years have ever really "liked" the format much.

"PDF hates me"  

You have to download PDF reader software, which you can find with a web search.

Look for free Adobe PDF reader.

Simon

daylight posted:

OK, $4500.00 AND NO SOUND AND SMOKE. 

Thank the Lord for THAT! 

SINCE THE GS-4 DAYLIGHT IS NOT A HIGHLY DETAILED ENGINE TO BEGIN WITH WHAT WOULD MAKE THIS MORE DESIRABLE THAN THE LATEST LIONEL VERSION?

Fully sprung and equalized drivers & running gear. Plus, he will be making one, or maybe both of, the GS-5 locomotives, i.e. 4458 and/or 4459, which had roller bearings on all axles.

OK, WOULD PROBABLY DESIRE BRASS OVER DIECAST BUT FOR MORE THAN $2500.00 ADDITIONAL?

Apparently you are not  a 2-Rail SCALE modeler.

DOUBT THAT THESE WILL SELL AT THAT PRICE

I think you will be surprised.

 

Actually, price is not what would hold up production of these models. It would be lead times and production delays. People won’t stand for 10 year project time frames and constant delays like you get with the “K” importers. He’ll produce a pilot model and the reservations will come in. I plan on reserving one

Hot Water posted:
daylight posted:

OK, $4500.00 AND NO SOUND AND SMOKE. 

Thank the Lord for THAT! 

SINCE THE GS-4 DAYLIGHT IS NOT A HIGHLY DETAILED ENGINE TO BEGIN WITH WHAT WOULD MAKE THIS MORE DESIRABLE THAN THE LATEST LIONEL VERSION?

Fully sprung and equalized drivers & running gear. Plus, he will be making one, or maybe both of, the GS-5 locomotives, i.e. 4458 and/or 4459, which had roller bearings on all axles.

OK, WOULD PROBABLY DESIRE BRASS OVER DIECAST BUT FOR MORE THAN $2500.00 ADDITIONAL?

Apparently you are not  a 2-Rail SCALE modeler.

DOUBT THAT THESE WILL SELL AT THAT PRICE

I think you will be surprised.

 

Well, I do 1/32 and narrow gauge (brass) in two rail. I know some individuals don't prefer smoke but do like sound.

I have had an Accucraft Narrow Gauge Denver & Rio Grand K-28 converted to DCC Zimo Sound and a back EMF smoke unit converted by TrainLIusa; love it.   I hope the Marsh engines  get made and sell very well!

I also realize that Kohs and Key models  (like the cab forward that finally came out, with sound) are pricey and well respected.  I think the cab  forward, if still available was around $5400.00

 

 

 

 

 

Well, a KTM USA type Daylight model would be a good thing, and I agree that $4500 would be a bargain for that kind of quality.  The Daylight shrouds cover a lot of detail, and even the Max models had that detail.

I would love to see the scrambling to assemble the pilot model the evening before the March meet.  KTM showed us the cored castings a year before production started.  Even MMW showed us some photos before his production started, or even before pilot models appeared.

I have no standing to comment.  As much as I like Daylights, I have no desire for this level of purchased model.  Doesn't mean I won't admire the craftsmanship.

OK, $4500.00 AND NO SOUND AND SMOKE.   

SINCE THE GS-4 DAYLIGHT IS NOT A HIGHLY DETAILED ENGINE TO BEGIN WITH WHAT WOULD MAKE THIS MORE DESIRABLE THAN THE LATEST LIONEL VERSION?

OK, WOULD PROBABLY DESIRE BRASS OVER DIECAST BUT FOR MORE THAN $2500.00 ADDITIONAL?

DOUBT THAT THESE WILL SELL AT THAT PRICE

First any lionel engine is 3 rail only, which makes if undesirable for most scale modelers.   

Then Lionel and other 3 rail mfg make their steamers with rigid side rods(the rods connecting the drivers) which does not allow a flanged set of drivers to adjust to curves.    All Brass scale models I have seen have articulated side rods (a joint at each driver) which allows the middle drivers to move slightly in the opposite direction for the end drivers thus working into a curve,

Diecast has thick depth is all places such as window frames, tender edges, roof lines, pilot details etc.    Brass generally has thinner proportions where they should be and looks more like a model and less like a toy.

And Lionel generally shows they have no interest in making accurate models.    My current example is the latest run of PRR GLA hoppers.    First they changed the trucks on this run.    The first run had a creditable version of the PRR 2D-F8 truck which is correct for the car.    In the new run, they cheapened it by  using a generic bettendorf style truck.    Then after a nice paint color on the first run, for some reason this run is bright orange - They have cheapened a decent model and in my case made it much less desirable.   

Roo posted:

I go to England every year and his models are regarded as the best, well above my price range, I still have a look at his locomotives and rolling stock and talked to people that have bought them. He usually has a stand at Guildex the largest O Gauge only show in Europe that's where I have seen his models.

If you can afford to spend that type of money it would not be wasted.

Now back to my plastic locos!  Roo.

Hmmm "rolling stock".  Freight cars. Now that I would be interested in.  

Roo, does Lee do freight or passenger rolling stock?

Rule292 posted:
Roo posted:

I go to England every year and his models are regarded as the best, well above my price range, I still have a look at his locomotives and rolling stock and talked to people that have bought them. He usually has a stand at Guildex the largest O Gauge only show in Europe that's where I have seen his models.

If you can afford to spend that type of money it would not be wasted.

Now back to my plastic locos!  Roo.

Hmmm "rolling stock".  Freight cars. Now that I would be interested in.  

Roo, does Lee do freight or passenger rolling stock?

 

I've been around the hobby almost all my life and seen some wonderful models if you want high quality you pay for it, if you don't, buy plastic or die cast but one thing I learnt. don't knock people who want the best. I wear a $50 Timex watch not a $25,000 Rolex watch but if you can afford those things why not? My son makes more money in a week than I made in a year he works very hard for that, doesn't make me wealthy I still battle away happily on my veterans pension I have everything I want, I still live in the first house I ever bought using a war service housing loan, I still fly economy class (and hate it!). 

Not referring to anyone in particular, my opinion only, don't want to start a them against us argument. 

In answer to Rule292 I have only seen his British Locomotives and his English passenger coaches which truly are a work of art never seen freight cars. Roo.

colorado hirailer posted:

Third Rail/Sunset is not high end? ...

I didn't say that - but they are US people looking at the US market. Lee Marsh is looking at things from a UK perspective, where 3-rail just doesn't enter the equation.

We're getting some really good, highly detailed ready-to-run 2-rail O Scale models of smaller British locos now from manufacturers such as Dapol & Minerva; 0-6-0 steam tank locos and diesel shunters, at the £200 mark. Nobody - just nobody - in Britain is calling out for 3-rail versions of them.

Nobody in Britain who can afford Lee Marsh's models will want them in 3-rail, either.

Last edited by SundayShunter
Roo posted:
Rule292 posted:
Roo posted:

I go to England every year and his models are regarded as the best, well above my price range, I still have a look at his locomotives and rolling stock and talked to people that have bought them. He usually has a stand at Guildex the largest O Gauge only show in Europe that's where I have seen his models.

If you can afford to spend that type of money it would not be wasted.

Now back to my plastic locos!  Roo.

Hmmm "rolling stock".  Freight cars. Now that I would be interested in.  

Roo, does Lee do freight or passenger rolling stock?

 

In answer to Rule292 I have only seen his British Locomotives and his English passenger coaches which truly are a work of art never seen freight cars. Roo.

I would have presumed that you were talking about passenger cars but I had to ask. 

Eternal optimist hoping that some other freight car freak like me just might want to produce a model that I'd be interested in.

Another inevitable but not yet asked question is to whether he would be offering them in finescale wheel tread or P:48 profiles?  Again a very small market but a question worth asking.

tripleo posted:

I assume purchasers are going to be running them and not just display them as a work of art. Does anyone know about the operating qualities of the models?

If I had the money to buy his coaches I would be scared to even touch them! Not really, but I would wear cotton gloves.

I don't know why I'm even on this thread it's way above me. I'm happy with my fleet of Atlas SW'S.

Maybe one day I might be able to afford a nice running mechanism from JC for my Red Caboose GP.  Ha Ha . Regards. Roo.

In 3 rail Scott’s models are high end. In 2 rail, his steam models are mid range and his diesels would be more high end for plastic models. He makes really nice stuff and it’s even better that his 3 rail diesels are 2 rail models with 3 rail wheels unlike everyone else who’s 2 rail models are 3 rail models with 2 rail trucks. None of the compromises to make them run on 3 rails are there

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×