If you are looking at the repro of the original Lionel Hiawatha, I'd recommend the 1988 Lionel repro, which was actually made by MTH. Or you can get one of the current production ones, which are available either conventional or with PS/2. The MTH repro made around 2001 or so is also an option, but the paint jobs on the engines are pretty bad - poor metal prep on the die casting is the word on the street. They are fine mechanically, though.
If you are looking at the other Pride Lines Hiawatha, the one with separate cars and an observation that looks like a real Beaver Tail, your choices are to take a chance, and fix things as they come up, or do without. That's the one I have. I have to say, it's a pretty cool looking train. A much nicer and more prototypical paint scheme than the old Lionel and its repros. Mine now has a 1988 Lionel/MTH motor and the leading truck, valve gear and some other stuff from MTH. Runs great now that all the Pride Lines mechanical parts are gone.
Here's a picture. 1988 Lionel repro on top, Pride Lines non-articulated set (runs on 031) on the bottom. Click on the photo link at the bottom of the post to see a bigger version of the picture.
Originally Posted by baltimoretrainworks:
Originally Posted by Southwest Hiawatha:
The Pride Lines models were interesting and quite attractive, but if my Hiawatha is any indication, quality control was abysmal. On mine, the motor was defective (bad field), small castings were brittle, various moving parts were out of line, and most of the holes for axles, etc. were not drilled square. The locomotive on mine has been almost completely rebuilt with MTH and Lionel parts. The cars are OK after replacing some defective wheels, axles, and truck sideframes.
I have been considering getting a Pridelines Hiawath for some time now but after reading this I'm not so sure now. I have the UP MP10000 and I really haven't noticed problems but it really doesn't see much run time due the fact my curves are a bit to tight for it. The one thing I thought was odd is a rather large weight that is epoxied inside the locomotive, looks like an "after market" add on but if QC is lacking it might just be factory installed. Anyone else out there have any Pridelines items care to chime in?
Jerry