Skip to main content

Okay, this has been a topic that has confused me for a long time, signaling.  Maybe it's because of the different kinds of signals, or my lack of knowledge as to how railroads normally operate.  Anyways, I have plans for an O scale layout that has two interconnected mainlines.  I tried scanning the track plan, but my printer seems off today.  Anyways, here are my questions:

 

1.  How does signaling work to protect blocks of track?  

2.  On a single mainline, how do railroads run 2 way traffic?  I assume that the railroads put sidings along the route fro trains to go into to wait for a train, but how often are these sidings installed?

 

3. On a model, since our main lines can be busier during an operating session, how does signalling work in that area?

4. During an operating session with multiple people, would DCS or TMCC/ Legacy help with the signaling?  Or is that best used when on your own?

 

5.  Are there methods that modeler's have developed and used on their own railroads?  If so, what are these different methods?

 

If possible, please include diagrams.  I hope a couple people have read books, or worked on the railroad before and are willing to share answers with me.

 

I am also not looking for anything prototype specific, but the general method to signalling used by most railroads.

 

Anything you can give me on the forum is appreciated.  Like I said, I know almost nothing about the area of railroading.

 

Thanks!

 

-James

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

James,

 

Let me start by offering some web links that might help with some of your questions:

 

http://home.comcast.net/~candcb1/index.html - Online Historical Reference of Railroad Signal System Aspects & Indications

 

http://mysite.du.edu/~jcalvert/railway/prraspec.htm - PRR Position Light Signal Aspects with Operating Rules  (Sorry, but I'm a Pennsy fan)

 

Now, let me try to provide some general responses to your questions.

 

1.  A signal usually protects some piece of property or some person ahead of it as well as the property and persons approaching it.  Thus, if a block is occupied or otherwise unsafe, the signal protecting that block should require a complete stop of the approaching train.  Of course, tons of train moving at speed can't stop on a dime, so the immediately preceding signal, in some sort of "caution" mode, should warn the engineer / fireman that a stop may be necessary soon.  Often, if not always, there are two blocks presenting this "caution" signal with the closest to the stop signal requiring the most slowing of movement.  This means, that the signal two or three blocks (depending on the number of caution blocks) will be the last "proceed as normal" signal before the slowing and stopping for an occupied / unsafe block is required.  Thus, to be prototypical on a simple oval would require at least three blocks to allow for a proceed, caution and stop sequence.

 

2.  Sidings are a function of how busy the mainline is at any given point in time and how long the mainline happens to be.  You could run a train from Chicago to LA, and vice versa, with just one siding if those were the only two trains running on that route.  However, if one train or the other was seriously late for the scheduled "meet" at the siding, the timely train would also be delayed significantly.

 

3.  Use of signals in modelling depends on the degree of realism you choose to follow.  Many available signals work on a "timing" basis so that when a train passes the signal, it turns to stop for any following train.  After a few seconds it changes to "caution," and after a few more seconds, it turns to "proceed" again.  On the other hand, signals can be wired to actually stop or slow trains, depending on the indication.  Of course with the "proceed" indication, the train just passes right on down the track.  Depending on your electrical engineering expertise, I have seen stories in various publications where all the signals are wired to a dispatchers desk, and that person controls the flow of trains by setting signals as necessary.

 

4.  Signalling during an operating session is not dependent on the operating power supplies you choose.  Rather, as explained above, it depends on the type of signals you purchase and how you set up their operation.

 

5.  Again, there is a lot of published information on this subject.  Some you will find on the internet, some in older model railroad magazines, and some in other published materials.  I, personally, don't operate yet, but since I'm not handy with electronics, I will probably just use the signals with built in timers to give the appearance of operating signals.

 

Finally, I have not even considered other signal situations you will discover through reading like crossovers, junctions, sidings, yards and crossings with unrelated railroads.  Your choices for depth of realism, amount you want to invest, and depth of knowledge about electricity will determine how you choose to signal your layout.

James,

 

Check out the Custom Signals website. In the menu on the left side of the page, there is a link to signaling with topics on different signal aspects, and signal meanings. Under the Track Configuration Library link, you will find configurations for single track, double track, yards, turnouts and more with diagrams. You can read through the information on TCL, or scroll to the bottom of the page to view the links to the diagrams. Also, Custom Signals has a yahoo users group where they can assist you.

Post
The Track Planning and Layout Design Forum is sponsored by

AN OGR FORUM CHARTER SPONSOR

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×