Skip to main content

Folks,

As I learned to my chagrin, there IS a difference between spackle and drywall joint compound.

I am working on scenery on both sides of the Ohio River for my PRR Panhandle 2 layout.  On the left (Steubenville, OH), I used spackle to create some of the terrain.  It went down nicely over styrofoam, shaped easily, and took paint and ground foam well.  It hasn't cracked or lifted up and looks pretty good.

But I couldn't leave well enough alone, could I?  No.     For the scenery on the right side (Weirton, WV), I decided to try drywall joint compound.  The results were less than stellar - after 2 days it was still wet, had cracked badly, and flaked off easily.

The two are similar and even have the same main ingredient, crystalline silica.  But the formulations are different and for our purposes as model railroaders, the spackle is superior.  


www.bobvila.com/articles/joint-compound-vs-spackle/

So, forewarned is forearmed.

Be well,

George

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Spackle is harder than joint compound and dries faster IMO. Joint compound is designed to flow over sheet rock joints that have been taped and also can be used to fill small glitches on the sheetrock. Spackle is designed more for major patching, it can be put on thickly and it will still set, with joint compound if you put a large amount on it is likely to crack and flake, not designed for that.

Spackle can be harder to work with, lot harder to sand IME. They have a light spackle these days that may be a kind of compromise, it seems to dry quickly, it can fill big areas without cracking but isn't as hard to work with as traditional spackle. I haven't tried it for scenery, so I would recommend trying  it as a proof of concept before getting a lot of it

A small twist - I prefer joint compound over light weight Spackle for mortar lines. It goes on better and when I clean it off the stuff stays in the mortar lines.

So when it came time to fill in the seams of homasote on my layout it is what I had and it is joint compound. So on it went and yea the next day cracks every where. Got to be my technique since it looks good on dry wall...............

Joe

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×