My local Home Depot sells 2" pink rigid foam insulation sheets which is so popular with this forum's users, but my local Lowes only sells 2" green rigid foam insulation sheets. They appear identical except for color, but are they? For model railroading purposes of using foam insulation sheets for track underlayment covering a bench work's plywood decking, do they work equally well at deadening sound track noise? Do they work equally well for carving, cutting, and creating land formations? Do they take paint equally well? Does either the green or pink have any obvious and real advantage over the other for model railroad use? I would likely go with the pink foam boards except I'm making a small 4x4 z/n gauge layout. Unforrunately H.D. doesn't sell 4x4 pink sheets but Lowes does have 4x4 green sheets. I need advice. What do you think?
Replies sorted oldest to newest
If your doing scenery get the one with the smooth's surface.
Clem k
I haven't seen any of the green sheets. However, if they LOOK identical (except for the color), then they most likely ARE identical (except for the color). The color is undoubtedly the method of distinguishing one manufacturer from the another.
Geez, 1 -4x4 piece of foam. Does it really make a difference?
Green made by Dow Chemical, pink by Owens. Both have many names, but the key word for you is Extruded Polystyrene. That’s what you want. Both products are basically the same.
This stuff also usually has a very thin plastic cover so a make sure you pull that off before you start shaping or painting it. Good luck with the project.
larry
I started using pink foam when I was building my railroad...I would buy one sheet at a time, and more as I needed it. Well I happened to buy one sheet of the Blue foam, and it was slightly off thickness wise enough so that I had to shim it. So stick with one or the other... don't mix the two brands. That was my experience, yours may vary.
Bob
Actually the green Lowes board is Kingspan not Dow...Dow is blue. Pink is Owens Corning Foamular. Both are extruded polystyrene... and essentially the same for our purposes. I would look into Polyisocyanurate board for scenery. Its messy, BUT imminently more wore workable. You can shape by abrasion (with a pencil!) and its available in HUGE blocks. You might look into insulation distributors to see if the carry/fabricate the polyiso product.
I've used both for scenery, just get a lot of snap blades for carving
Rob is correct , all these colors are really giving me more senior moments? And I bet I used at least 10 4x8 2 inch sheet of pink and forgot how many 1/2 inch sheet.
Larry
I bought 4x8 sheets of 2" pink foam for my layout from HD. It works great for me.
The color does not matter if made out of the same stuff.
William 1 posted:Geez, 1 -4x4 piece of foam. Does it really make a difference?
Depends on how you use it, as house insulation probably not.