Some times when running my steam locomotives.I noticed some thing kinda odd.I had a MTH mountain type steam locomotive locosound it had been a while since I operated it.Well I started her right up and while on the move.Some thing caught my eye.Stepping to take a closer look.That is when I saw it.It was kicking out smoke rings.I have not done any thing to it.Noticed a few of my other steamers will do this to.I kinda like it cool effect.Even thou I did not do any thing to it.So do you guys have locomotives that do this?
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Its fairly common. I have even seen post war engines do. It helps if there is nothing blocking the airstream like a piece of batting or the smoke unit not lined up with the engine stack.
Pete
Most of my steamers do at low speeds.
@Norton posted:Its fairly common. I have even seen post war engines do. It helps if there is nothing blocking the airstream like a piece of batting or the smoke unit not lined up with the engine stack.
Pete
I have a lionel 736 it smokes but it never puffed out smoke rings.Although I have seen old movies and videos of post war trains doing that.
@Jushavnfun posted:Most of my steamers do at low speeds.
It does not happen all the time.Happens every now and then as if they had a mind of their own.
I have an MTH RailKing Southern Pacific that is outstanding at putting out smoke rings at slow speed
My Premier Dreyfuss (first run from 2000 Vol 2) blows smoke rings every other puff when running at low speed. Pretty neat.
My Lionel, Southern RR, USRA 0-8-0 smokes perfect rings, most of the time. It’s the best conventional locomotive I have.
Yes, my MTH GN R2 makes great smoke rings, every time I run it. Thought it was the best "undocumented feature" of that engine!
The real ones do it too....
@SantaFe158 Wow! I've never seen smoke rings on a real steam engine, thanks for posting the video, 765's rings are impressive
@Prr7688 posted:@SantaFe158 Wow! I've never seen smoke rings on a real steam engine, thanks for posting the video, 765's rings are impressive
The exhaust nozzle, petticoat pipe and stack have to be in perfect alignment for this to happen. The wind also has to be pretty calm, too.
Check this video, at about 35 seconds in...a whole bunch of 'em!
My PW Lionel #2026 makes perfect smoke rings, as does my K-Line PRR A5.
@Rich Melvin posted:The exhaust nozzle, petticoat pipe and stack have to be in perfect alignment for this to happen. The wind also has to be pretty calm, too.
Check this video, at about 35 seconds in...a whole bunch of 'em!
WOW!I did not know this really happens in real life!Another thing that is a fine whistle to.It would get me to notice it.
Lionel 671 and other post war engines
After I upgraded my TMCC Scale J with GRJ's supper chuffer / chuff generator my 606J has been doing this fairly regularly. Here is the test run.
Also here is the real 765 in Pittsburgh years ago in a video I shot. At the 1:50 mark you can see a smoke ring rise above.
Our 736, 2046 among a few others puff nice smoke rings.
Favorite smoke loco is a lionel 1946 version # 726 and 671 with smoke bulbs, at night running the smoke comes high out of stack lighted has a beautiful constant flicker to it, not puffing out just there it is similar to a campfire unlike a regular postwar smoking steam engine. When the pellet starts to get used up the height of flicker slowly goes back down until it diminishes completely.
Really surprised that it is not mentioned more .
One day need to shoot a short video to show this effect.
For fan driven smoke, I think you'll find that a significant percentage of MTH locomotives and locomotives equipped with my Super-Chuffer will do this. It relates to a technique for controlling the fan that MTH has a patent on and I had to license to use in my Super-Chuffer. The fan is stopped using dynamic braking and not just allowed to coast to a stop. This cuts off the smoke abruptly and seems to frequently cause smoke rungs to form.
It's the same reason many mechanical smoke units (puffers) throw smoke rings, when the piston reverses, it suddenly cuts off the smoke and allows the ring to form.
Although I've seen this with some Lionel locomotives with fan driven smoke, it's less often, at least in my experience. Lionel doesn't dynamically stop the smoke fan, so the smoke tails off after the chuff and doesn't form a ring.
The speed of the locomotive and chuff rate also have a lot to do with it. My Lionel Hogwart's upgrade with the Super-Chuffer will throw streams of perfect smoke rings at a specific speed, however slower or faster, they don't form nearly as often.
I have a MTH Imperial Triplex that does it and I LOVE IT! I show it to everyone and they also think it is super cool!