Skip to main content

Way back in the stone ages when I was 10/11 years old I remember poring through the Lionel 1957 and 1958 catalogs and absolutely drooling over the Norfolk and Western 746 J Class Northern.  At that point in my life I never saw anything so magnificent.  The smooth and exquisite bullet nosed shape of the engine with its striking orange and yellow stripe accompanied by a streamlined tender also with the orange and yellow stripe completely captivated me.  I would stare at the catalog renderings of this beautiful steamer for hours and wished that I could have one.  This was out of the question of course because the price tag on the 746 was far more than we could ever afford.  Instead I had to be content with running my Grandfather's little Lionel 249 2-4-2 but content I was because this little engine and tender also has a matching orange stripes and when I watched it run I made believe I was watching the 746.   An 11 year old kid's imagination is capable of almost anything.  

 

In any event, the years passed but nevertheless my interest in toy trains never completely waned nor did my love of the 746.  When I reached my late 20s  and early 30s the toy train rebirth was in full swing but with increased interest came increased prices.  I had a family to raise so the 746 remained out of reach.  When I retired in 1997 command control systems and larger engines were coming into vogue and like so many I got caught up in the frenzy with TMCC, DCS and scale sized engines.  At train shows and auction sites I would still admire the post-war 746 but I spent my dollars elsewhere.  The 746 was still pretty much holding its value and I felt I wanted more "bang for my buck" so I always went for the bells and whistles of the modern era engines.

 

Over the last couple of years I found that my interest in post-war trains was returning and since I kept all of the old engines I had purchased I began to operate them more and more on my layout.  I also began searching for that old 746.  As I searched I found that a 746 in reasonably good shape still commanded a fairly high  price.  I try to maintain a fairly strict train budget (the operative word there is try) and old habits die hard so I resisted the urge to spend the high dollar amount that most of these engines were going for.  Finally, last week I accidentally stumbled on a 746 in excellent to like new condition with everything working superbly that was listed with a starting bid far below the usual asking price.  The bidding was to end in less than two hours and not a single bid had been made.  I placed my bid and held my breath figuring for sure there would be a bevy of last minute bids on such a fine engine.  It never happened.  I won the auction with a base line starting bid. This was a case of being in the right place at the right time.  This engine was not listed in the regular post war 1945 to 1969 listings but rather the modern era listings.  I guess at this particular point in time all of the 746 bidders were concentrating on the post-war era enabling me to slip through the cracks and virtually "steal" a premier post-war engine.

 

When I received the engine I placed it under the tree and ran it through its paces.  Smooth as silk and a great smoker with a sweet sounding air whistle and barely a scratch on it.  Then I retrieved my 1957 and 1958 catalogs and turned to the pages which advertised the last great steam engine the old Lionel Corporation ever produced.  I turned all of the lights off in the living room save the tree lights and let this venerable old legend strut its stuff.  The smoke billowed from the engine and the soft, haunting sound of its air whistle sweetly echoed from its tender.  I stared at the 746 pictured on the pages of the old Lionel Catalogs.  Time stood still.  I was both eleven and sixty six.  A young boy's dreams had come to fruition to the delight of this old man.  I may be prejudiced but only the magic of toy trains makes such an odyssey possible.     

Last edited by OKHIKER
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I know how you feel about this engine.  My dream growing up in the late 70s/80s was to find a N&W J in someone's attic!  The only way I would ever be able to have one as a kid or teenager!

 

Through the years, I have always wanted a PW Era "J".  I did buy the Lionel Scale J last fall, but I would like someday to have a PW Era "J," there is something about that engine...Great find, glad to see you got what you wanted!

So that is what happens to me when the kids leave the house and only come home for money. Just joking around, nice personal story. Thinking back not as many years as you did I didn't have a favorite dream engine. But I do remember playing with my father shooting rockets at the exploding box car. I still have that set and it always brings back the great memories each Christmas when it comes out.

 

So do you have a photo of this great one?

I enjoyed reading your story.Dreams do come true my friend.They have for me also.NickOriginally Posted by OKHIKER:

Way back in the stone ages when I was 10/11 years old I remember poring through the Lionel 1957 and 1958 catalogs and absolutely drooling over the Norfolk and Western 746 J Class Northern.  At that point in my life I never saw anything so magnificent.  The smooth and exquisite bullet nosed shape of the engine with its striking orange and yellow stripe accompanied by a streamlined tender also with the orange and yellow stripe completely captivated me.  I would stare at the catalog renderings of this beautiful steamer for hours and wished that I could have one.  This was out of the question of course because the price tag on the 746 was far more than we could ever afford.  Instead I had to be content with running my Grandfather's little Lionel 249 2-4-2 but content I was because this little engine and tender also has a matching orange stripes and when I watched it run I made believe I was watching the 746.   An 11 year old kid's imagination is capable of almost anything.  

 

In any event, the years passed but nevertheless my interest in toy trains never completely waned nor did my love of the 746.  When I reached my late 20s  and early 30s the toy train rebirth was in full swing but with increased interest came increased prices.  I had a family to raise so the 746 remained out of reach.  When I retired in 1997 command control systems and larger engines were coming into vogue and like so many I got caught up in the frenzy with TMCC, DCS and scale sized engines.  At train shows and auction sites I would still admire the post-war 746 but I spent my dollars elsewhere.  The 746 was still pretty much holding its value and I felt I wanted more "bang for my buck" so I always went for the bells and whistles of the modern era engines.

 

Over the last couple of years I found that my interest in post-war trains was returning and since I kept all of the old engines I had purchased I began to operate them more and more on my layout.  I also began searching for that old 746.  As I searched I found that a 746 in reasonably good shape still commanded a fairly high  price.  I try to maintain a fairly strict train budget (the operative word there is try) and old habits die hard so I resisted the urge to spend the high dollar amount that most of these engines were going for.  Finally, last week I accidentally stumbled on a 746 in excellent to like new condition with everything working superbly that was listed with a starting bid far below the usual asking price.  The bidding was to end in less than two hours and not a single bid had been made.  I placed my bid and held my breath figuring for sure there would be a bevy of last minute bids on such a fine engine.  It never happened.  I won the auction with a base line starting bid. This was a case of being in the right place at the right time.  This engine was not listed in the regular post war 1945 to 1969 listings but rather the modern era listings.  I guess at this particular point in time all of the 746 bidders were concentrating on the post-war era enabling me to slip through the cracks and virtually "steal" a premier post-war engine.

 

When I received the engine I placed it under the tree and ran it through its paces.  Smooth as silk and a great smoker with a sweet sounding air whistle and barely a scratch on it.  Then I retrieved my 1957 and 1958 catalogs and turned to the pages which advertised the last great steam engine the old Lionel Corporation ever produced.  I turned all of the lights off in the living room save the tree lights and let this venerable old legend strut its stuff.  The smoke billowed from the engine and the soft, haunting sound of its air whistle sweetly echoed from its tender.  I stared at the 746 pictured on the pages of the old Lionel Catalogs.  Time stood still.  I was both eleven and sixty six.  A young boy's dreams had come to fruition to the delight of this old man.  I may be prejudiced but only the magic of toy trains makes such an odyssey possible.     

 

GREAT STORY,  I am sure that there are many forum members that can relate to your dream being fulfilled.  Many of us got back into this hobby after a long absence and most were lucky enough to finally afford an engine of train set that we could not as kids.

 

I know what you mean when yo said that you were both 11 and 66 at the same moment. 

 

Whats 55 years between friends?

Congrats on the buy!  For me, it was one engine that I too wish I had.  But you see, I did have the opportunity to play with one at one time.  My brother received one of those 1958/59 sets when I was 5 years old.  My Dad had actually ordered a lesser set, but the store from which he ordered it, was out of stock of that particular set, and it being close to Christmas, they sent the next better set... I don't think you are likely to see that kind of service anymore.

 

That said. it was always understood that it was my brothers and even though I got to play with it after he went off to college, he eventually reclaimed it.  But by then the wear and tear was significant, and when I eventually had the means to do something about it, I embarked on a quest much like your own.  I eventually replaced all of the damaged cars.. The horse car, the radioactive waste car, the beechcraft bonanza car... and i even restored the J with a few vintage parts.  All the time, I also had an eye on putting together a set of my own, which I also pretty much did.. The Cooper Jarrett car, the log dump car, the smoking caboose... the works.  All but the original J.  I did purchase a new "J" in the mid 1990's,  with similar tooling and railsounds II.  But I have never acquired the original 746.  I also amassed a substantial collection of Super "O" and several "LW" transformers.  

 

So my quest goes on!  You are lucky I wasn't looking at Ebay when you were!  

 

That said, I can rest easy knowing that my older brother has put his train collection in his will as going to me.  A sad day that will be, but one that I will still be grateful for.

 

BTW, nice layout and D56 village pieces!   

Originally Posted by TM Terry:

Very nice story and thanks for the pics.

 

What I'd like to ask is for you to post a pic of the page in the catalog that advertised the J. I haven't seen that catalog to my best memory.

TM Terry,

          I have tried to post photos of the N&W J from the 1957 and 1958 Lionel Catalogs but have been unsuccessful.  Apparently the photos are too large and I am unfamiliar with how to downsize them.  Sorry.  Perhaps someone else possesses the expertise to do so.

Originally Posted by OKHIKER:

Way back in the stone ages when I was 10/11 years old I remember poring through the Lionel 1957 and 1958 catalogs and absolutely drooling over the Norfolk and Western 746 J Class Northern.  At that point in my life I never saw anything so magnificent.  The smooth and exquisite bullet nosed shape of the engine with its striking orange and yellow stripe accompanied by a streamlined tender also with the orange and yellow stripe completely captivated me.  I would stare at the catalog renderings of this beautiful steamer for hours and wished that I could have one.  This was out of the question of course because the price tag on the 746 was far more than we could ever afford.  Instead I had to be content with running my Grandfather's little Lionel 249 2-4-2 but content I was because this little engine and tender also has a matching orange stripes and when I watched it run I made believe I was watching the 746.   An 11 year old kid's imagination is capable of almost anything.  

 

In any event, the years passed but nevertheless my interest in toy trains never completely waned nor did my love of the 746.  When I reached my late 20s  and early 30s the toy train rebirth was in full swing but with increased interest came increased prices.  I had a family to raise so the 746 remained out of reach.  When I retired in 1997 command control systems and larger engines were coming into vogue and like so many I got caught up in the frenzy with TMCC, DCS and scale sized engines.  At train shows and auction sites I would still admire the post-war 746 but I spent my dollars elsewhere.  The 746 was still pretty much holding its value and I felt I wanted more "bang for my buck" so I always went for the bells and whistles of the modern era engines.

 

Over the last couple of years I found that my interest in post-war trains was returning and since I kept all of the old engines I had purchased I began to operate them more and more on my layout.  I also began searching for that old 746.  As I searched I found that a 746 in reasonably good shape still commanded a fairly high  price.  I try to maintain a fairly strict train budget (the operative word there is try) and old habits die hard so I resisted the urge to spend the high dollar amount that most of these engines were going for.  Finally, last week I accidentally stumbled on a 746 in excellent to like new condition with everything working superbly that was listed with a starting bid far below the usual asking price.  The bidding was to end in less than two hours and not a single bid had been made.  I placed my bid and held my breath figuring for sure there would be a bevy of last minute bids on such a fine engine.  It never happened.  I won the auction with a base line starting bid. This was a case of being in the right place at the right time.  This engine was not listed in the regular post war 1945 to 1969 listings but rather the modern era listings.  I guess at this particular point in time all of the 746 bidders were concentrating on the post-war era enabling me to slip through the cracks and virtually "steal" a premier post-war engine.

 

When I received the engine I placed it under the tree and ran it through its paces.  Smooth as silk and a great smoker with a sweet sounding air whistle and barely a scratch on it.  Then I retrieved my 1957 and 1958 catalogs and turned to the pages which advertised the last great steam engine the old Lionel Corporation ever produced.  I turned all of the lights off in the living room save the tree lights and let this venerable old legend strut its stuff.  The smoke billowed from the engine and the soft, haunting sound of its air whistle sweetly echoed from its tender.  I stared at the 746 pictured on the pages of the old Lionel Catalogs.  Time stood still.  I was both eleven and sixty six.  A young boy's dreams had come to fruition to the delight of this old man.  I may be prejudiced but only the magic of toy trains makes such an odyssey possible.     

I always wanted this steam locomotive.I had 1 in h.o. bachmann and could pulling a good sized train.Years later mth came out with its version.But like you I could not afford it.So a few more years went by.But last year on this forum buy sell and trade.1 was for sale a mth railkingI went for it and got it.Althou its doesn,t have all the bells and whistle.Thats o.k. with me.It has a pistion smoke unit which is pretty cool.The only thing the head light didn,t work.So I fixed it now with the head light works.Later on I may add a better sounds to it.With it being a railking I am sure it will pull a far sized train.Oh yea I took a train that was pulled by the real J
.Had a great time on the train.One thing is I will never forget 611 whistle.Talk about a deep sound.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×