Skip to main content

 

 

FOAMERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT'S TIME TO FOAM AT THE MOUTH!!!!! 

 

What do you want to see in the next MTH catalog. Spill your guts, open up those closets and express your hidden 3 rail fantasies  

 

Oh and Matt Panagos from the Trackers....let's hope we see some cool B & O RK rolling stock!! 

 

 

That said...here's what I think would be awesome!! 

 

Premier 

 

GN Light Mikado 

Milwaukee Road Heavy Mikado 

NP SD45

NP U30C/U25C

WC SD45

Milwaukee Road SD40-2 Bicentennial 

C & NW SD40-2 

Soo Line Light Mikado 

C & NW E6

 

Modern SP Box cars

NP Woodchip Cars

SAL Woodchip Cars

GN Woodchip (BSB)

MRL Woodchip 

Modern MRL Box Cars

Seaboard System 3 Bay Centerflow 

GN 3 Bay Centerflow BSB 

 

That's for starters...yourself? 

 

 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

SP diesels, especially an SD-40 tunnel motor. Would happily take it in Cotton Belt as well.

SP bay window caboose.

+1 on modern SP freight cars.

 

I'm still relatively new to O scale - is it just my imagination, or is modern SP kind of ignored? (Lionel tank train aside, of course.)

 

Fred

Originally Posted by fpatton:

       

SP diesels, especially an SD-40 tunnel motor. Would happily take it in Cotton Belt as well.

SP bay window caboose.

+1 on modern SP freight cars.

 

I'm still relatively new to O scale - is it just my imagination, or is modern SP kind of ignored? (Lionel tank train aside, of course.)

 

Fred


       


MTH has been offering the SD45T-2 in SP & Cotton Belt liveries as well as post UP merger & other roads that bought them from UP.  A much more accurate model than Lionel's SD40T-2.

If I recall correctly they will also offer their newly-tooled scale FM Train Master in SP bloody nose scheme so you can relive the past when they pullef commuter trains up there where you live (just need some accurate bi-level commuter cars to go with it).

They also came out with a very good Railking Scale MP15ac in SP livery even with prototype-specific details such as the number boards above the cab & the red gyralites.
Originally Posted by John Korling:
Originally Posted by fpatton:

       

SP diesels, especially an SD-40 tunnel motor. Would happily take it in Cotton Belt as well.

SP bay window caboose.

+1 on modern SP freight cars.

 

I'm still relatively new to O scale - is it just my imagination, or is modern SP kind of ignored? (Lionel tank train aside, of course.)

 

Fred


       


MTH has been offering the SD45T-2 in SP & Cotton Belt liveries as well as post UP merger & other roads that bought them from UP.  A much more accurate model than Lionel's SD40T-2.

If I recall correctly they will also offer their newly-tooled scale FM Train Master in SP bloody nose scheme so you can relive the past when they pullef commuter trains up there where you live (just need some accurate bi-level commuter cars to go with it).

They also came out with a very good Railking Scale MP15ac in SP livery even with prototype-specific details such as the number boards above the cab & the red gyralites.

 

Great info. Thanks!

 

Fred

Here are a few more:

 

GP30's with Alco trucks as owned by Milwaukee Road, Soo Line, and GM&O. which traded in RS-3's and kept the trucks.

 

6-car WWII military flatcar sets, not just with a Sherman tank on each flatcar, but a variety - a tank, a flamethrower tank, a half-track, a self-propelled artillery piece, a pair of deuce and a halfs, a pair of jeeps or a jeep and commo trailer, etc. Let's have them with Pacific theater markings and on flatcars marked for Western roads - SP, Milwaukee, WP, NP, etc. (UP has already been done). 

 

More flatcars without loads, maybe even in four- or six-car sets. Preferably in Milwaukee Road, among others.

This topic is too late for getting a message to Mike Wolf, but maybe MTH will take it under consideration for the future. My wishes are for Rail King steam and trolley cars:

1. Osgood Bradley 12-ench open trolley in 3rd Avenue Railway and Connecticut liveries;

2. Existing Pennsy H Class 2-8-0 in Long Island Rail Road livery;

3. Long Island Rail Road G5s with Sunrise Special livery & standard livery;

4. Rugged Rails 027 heavyweight passenger cars in Long Island Rail Road ligth gray & white livery of 1950;

5. A heavy interurban car of wood construction in New York & North Shore Traction livery.

I think many of us would like to see this...

 

veteran

 

 

Some of the following are wishful thinking because they will require new tooling, but I can dream about them to being offered as Premier engines in the catalog...

 

Southern Railway 2-8-0 No. 630

Southern Railway Mikado, 4501 in Black

 

Southern 610, 2-10-4

steam

 

I would like to see a reissue of this Premier Southern 0-4-0 switcher as I have have not been able to find one...

 

0-4-0

Attachments

Images (3)
  • veteran
  • steam
  • 0-4-0
Last edited by kjstrains

RailKing (3-pak) or Premier (6-pak) uni-body tankers as crude-oil unit trains. Simple decoration, no new tooling needed, can repeat in multiple catalogs with different road numbers/reporting marks. Suggest an Airslide or PS-2 hopper as a buffer car.

 

(puts envelope to turban)

--Amtrak 40th Anniversary train. We have the locomotives, all we need are the Amfleet food-service car, Heritage sleeper and baggage cars.

 

(wishful thinking mode)

--Viewliners. Sleeper/Sleeper and Sleeper/Diner 2-packs. No need for 4-car sets--these would serve as add-ons to existing Amtrak sets, and be completely prototypical.

 

--Amfleet II. The long-distance version with larger windows and doors at one end of the car only. Never before made in 'O'

 

---PCJ

Last edited by RailRide

Early on, MTH earned a reputation for releasing models of unusual prototypes including numerous electric classes, the AGEIR boxcab diesel and PRR's Lima built transfer unit to name just a few. Staying with the theme of the rare and unusual, I'd like to see a model of the New York Central DES-3 tri-power locomotive.

 

Bob

 

 

 

Originally Posted by cmscanuck:

I would love:

 

Premier NYO&W anything... Coal Hoppers and Transition era small steam being highest on my list.

 

Also... single A unit F3's 501-503 or more NW2's

 Yes, I completely agree!  There is a reason why MTH NYO&W items are hard to find, even at York!

 

I am all in for NYO&W stuff!  Realistic stuff that is, no GG1's or Big Boys with NYO&W markings on them.

 

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×