Skip to main content

I have this cute little RK 4-8-2 - it's actually a down-scale NYC Mohawk, factory painted for Southern, that

used to run so well - it even liked my Remote Commander. The steam sound was good for Protosound - not

Railsounds, mind you, but it had a bark that RS could do to copy a bit. Great train show layout loco.

 

It will not run. The battery is dead, apparently. Tried another, fresher battery - no go. Let them both charge up for hours.

Nada. When you try to run it in conventional, it just does the click and the generator spools back up. Never moves.

 

It now won't run under DCS at all, when last I checked. I guess that the charger is shot.

 

(Or it is something else entirely.)

 

Not worth repairing with PS2/3/whatever, worth nothing so long as it's dead. I have a bunch of good electronic e-units

from CC upgrade projects, so I guess that I'll put one of those in and make it a runner, then sell it - but it's a project with which I don't want to bother. It's not scaley-enough to install an ERR Cruise Commander. I guess. Maybe. No. 

 

Thanks for listening to this tale of woe. Like, I'd miss one steam locomotive from the herd. Life is hard. Sob.

Last edited by D500
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Is this the 2010 version?  2.4V battery?  Send me the board set should be able to fix the battery issue.  This should run in DCS though.  Delete from remote and re-add.  Should work though it will not retain settings until the battery circuit is fixed.  I would not give up on this one yet.  G

I have  that loco, an early version (about 2004) with the 5-volt board.  Of a sudden, DCS couldn't find it.  No sound.  Would run in conventional.  Worked on it all day, with advice from a couple of forum gurus, and it's working fine.  Did add engine, recover engine, edit engine ID & location, rename engine, and finally got it to work.Can't pin down the cause for sure, but it may have been a weak battery clip.

 

I agree with GGG's last sentence.

I remember when that old dumb Lionel was new.  It had its problems, which taught me how to fix trains.  I still have that old Lionel.  Certainly does not run as well as modern locos.  Depends on what you want your layout to do.  Just like some layouts are a simple loop, to avoid the "complexity" or switches, and give an artist a place to build beautiful scenery.  Other layouts have the entire area covered with track, with no room for scenery.  When you are CEO, engineer, and ROW laborer, you run your railroad the way you want.

 

Whatever turns you on.

I had forgotten my thread on this...

 

GGG - it has an 8.4V battery. My "DCS" system is the Remote Commander, so there is no

adding/deleting. The loco used to run under it, but once the battery started going it acted odd in DCS - and wouldn't run in conventional. I'm not really DCS-savvy; most of the stuff

that I run is TMCC/etc. Thanks for the offer, though.

 

midnightwrecking - ah, thought that you'd pull one over on me, eh? Well, I don't know...it's such a handsome little thing. I do scale, pretty much, but an occasional

Short Stack will follow me home.

I'll keep you in mind.

 

Edstrains - "...good old dumb Postwar Lionel..." you do know that the word "dumb" is in there, don't you? Most of my electronics stuff - and I have a bunch - just keeps on ticking. (BTW, I just got a nice tenderless - so far - Lionel 1666 2-6-2; I'm not without

appreciation - it's smooth and runs pretty slowly - but most of that stuff was not 

so well-done.)

 

 

 

 

Just as an FYI - I did again test this loco in DCS (with a Remote Commander; I do not

have the full DCS setup) and it did, indeed, run just fine. Still no-go in conventional.

I guess that my memory of it not running in DCS either was off.

 

This gives me one PS2 loco -and- one TMCC loco that will not run in conventional. But, I do command only, pretty much, so I guess that's OK.

 

Alas, midnightwrecking, I guess that I'll not be selling it just yet...

If the battery is fully charged, you might need to do a conventional reset.  1W and 5B rapidly iaw instructions.  It just may be locked. out.

 

If you apply power and start it up, than turn power off does it play sounds? If so lockout seems like the issue.  If no sounds, either battery, battery wiring, or a battery circuit issue is preventing conventional ops.  G

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×