Skip to main content

Bought a new Legacy Diesel for my grandson for Christmas and am testing it.  It is a New York Central GP-30 Product Number 2433132.

It is to be used with the Lion Chief Universal Remote and the Lionchief App.  He has no Legacy base.

It has some limited functions and acts much like a LionChief Plus 2.0 which I sort of expected, but I noticed that the smoke output is very low.  I put 15 drops of Protosmoke in for starters (manual said 10-20 drops).  Had to puff air into chamber to get it going (normal).  But the smoke volume is very low and stops frequently.

Thinking I flooded it, I turned it upside down and blew out the chamber with compressed air and put in less, but the same thing happened.  It smokes for awhile, but lower than any other engines I have tried with fan driven smoke.

Advice?

Thanks,

John

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

@tom21pa posted:

it has a very odd funnel to the smoke unit if i recall,  my 2 i tilt the back of the engine up so the fluid goes to smoke unit, try downloading the app & you can adjust smoke output

OK.  Tilting definitely helped.

I don't see anything that suggests that the smoke is variable on the app?   Do you need a legacy base for that to appear?

Thanks,

John

You need the base to adjust smoke output but it sounds like to me you do not have enough fluid in it. 15 drops is not enough for a newer fan driven smoke unit. I would add 10 more drops and see what you got. I do recall a past thread about these being difficult to get the fluid to the right place. My experience with my Legacy locomotives is the smoke seems to be defaulted to high. Mine smoke like my MTH locomotives. I am not using a base either. Just the app or universal remote.

Brad

Last edited by B rad

Well,

I gave the Legacy engine to my grandson for Christmas and we ran it on the Legacy Cab 3 I bought.  He loved it, but the first thing he noticed was the low smoke output.  We added fluid, but it seemed like the fan motor wasn't turning.

After he went home I took it apart and discovered that the rectangular funnel that carries the fluid to the smoke unit is at an angle and not parallel to the roof of the shell.

20241228_122502

20241228_122534

20241228_122511

So I worked the funnel back and forth and removed it to get to the heating element and the fan motor (which is under the middle of the funnel.  The fan was stuck and I was able to move it to free it up and I also fluffed up the wick under the heating element.

I tried to find a way to glue the funnel back on the smoke unit differently, but I didn't see that that would work.

20241228_123450

I looked like it was glued correctly so I glued it on the same way I found it.

With the rectangular gasket in place between the roof and the top of the funnel there is still a space.  It causes the smoke to come out in several other locations.

Seems like a bad design.  Has anyone run into this and found a workaround?  I hate to send it back or to Lionel because I have read other complaints about low smoke output with the GP30 and it seems like I'll just end up with another one with the same issue.  I would rather fix it myself.

Thanks,

John

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 20241228_122502
  • 20241228_122534
  • 20241228_122511
  • 20241228_123450
Last edited by Craftech

Obviously, you need to have the smoke funnel mated with the stack opening without a gap.  I'd put a shim block right here that is the correct thickness to align the funnel properly and seat it on the shell stack opening.  It won't be the first time that a lousy design has had to be "adjusted".

Thanks for the suggestion John.  I just looked up the funnel part on the Lionel website.  Guess what it looks like?

Firefox_Screenshot_2024-12-29T01-35-30.489Z

Needless to say, the leveling block is missing from the bottom of mine. 

John

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Firefox_Screenshot_2024-12-29T01-35-30.489Z

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×