Skip to main content

So I just recently completed my collection of the "Legends of Lionel" Madison passenger cars and are being pulled by a de-numbered Polar Express engine and Railsounds tender. I was quite happy to watch everything run around until a friend of mine pointed out to me that the "Lawrence Cowen" car is not lettered in "Lionel Lines" Does this mean I have some "rare factory mistake" that might be worth a million dollars that could sell for slightly less than I bought it for 30 years from now right before a giant asteroid hits the planet and wipes all out anyways.

Anybody else seen one that was never lettered?

Is it worth mentioning to Greenberg's just to document a variation, do people care about variations anymore, or does that only count for Post-war stuff?

Should I pull mine and replace it with a "normal" one and box up the unlettered one?

We are all collectors to a point, but I don't care about collecting something just because it is rare, but it would be nice to know if I have something potentially valuable.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have only seen one instance of an error on a modern Lionel Madison car.

It was printed on one side only. When I emailed a question about it to the eBay seller, instead of answering the seller closed the auction early.

I would certainly think that a graphics error will be worth more down the road.

Now you have to buy another one without the error  to complete the set.

Here is a link to an interesting article on postwar Madison car errors:

http://www.tcaetrain.org/artic...g/MADISON/index.html

Seems I read a good number of posts that involve misspellings, letter or images reversed, or as in your case, missing entirely.  The all too often mentioned lack of quality control involved in all overseas manufacturers has unfortunately turned these types of factory errors into an almost common occurrence.  My opinion is you may have a conversation piece but odds are no one is likely to pay a lot more for your car.  The more often these mistakes happen, the less anyone sees them as some type of "rare" collectible.  Sorry to shatter your dreams of early retirement.  

Originally Posted by c.sam:

We don't have 30 years as the asteroid is supposed to hit Dec 21, 1012 - a scant 5 months from now!!!

Actually, it was almost a thousand years ago, so we are probably safe.

 

December 21st, 2012 happens to be my 64th birthday, so maybe I should have a big party.

 

What's the story on the Marlyn Monroe silhouette at the end of the observation car?  I thought that image was copyrighted.

She's not the only famous figure on the window strips of the Legends set.

As far as copyrights I would assume at the time the set was begun it was the power and connections of Neil Young that got the ok for the images.

Don't leave us in suspense, who else
 
Originally Posted by bigo426:
 

What's the story on the Marlyn Monroe silhouette at the end of the observation car?  I thought that image was copyrighted.

She's not the only famous figure on the window strips of the Legends set.

As far as copyrights I would assume at the time the set was begun it was the power and connections of Neil Young that got the ok for the images.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×