Skip to main content

Evening all! I wanted to ask about some ideas for a project I'm thinking of.  Lionel and MTH have both made camelbacks, more or less using the same locomotive as reference. In the detail category, MTH's was far superior. However, I do not like MTH's control systems, and so do not have one. Instead, I have a Lionel one, which suffices perfectly for my needs.  That being said, I would like to add more detail to my model. I know MTH's had cab details, including gauges and levers. My question was, does anyone have any ideas on adding a more detailed interior to a cab for a locomotive? It doesn't have to be a camelback, I just would like some ideas for how I could add details to mine.

I attached two pictures of the interior of my Camelback along with a picture of MTH's.  You can see the gauges clearly in the cab.

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Camelback Cab1
  • Camelback Cab 2
  • MTH Camelback.
Last edited by PR&NJRR
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I was wondering also about adding detail to the Lionel Camelback model, but I was more fixated on the exterior detail. I haven't actually pulled the trigger on the latest Lionel offering as I much prefer the tooling and details of the MTH version. It was nearly double the price of the Lionel model, but I would be willing to pay for the extra detail.

However, finding and MTH Premier Camelback for sale has been tough. I would consider either release (2008, 2016) of the Reading version but to this point I have exclusively Legacy steam engines so I would have to commit to another control system. Not sure I want to do that, except there are a few other small Premier steam engines I would like to have eventually as well. I doubt Lionel bought all of the ones I'm hoping to get although that would be ideal.

Getting back around to adding exterior detail to a steam locomotive, how are things best attached?

On a camelback, the back-head (firebox face) usually had had two firing doors, a tri-cock and water gauge, steam pressure gauge and an air brake gauge. Sometimes a rack to hold oiling cans (and a coffee pot) as well. There usually was also provision for the bell cord.    On the right (engineer's) side of the loco in the center cab was the throttle, reverser, air brake stand, bolier water injector control valves, sander control valve, whistle and bell cords, a seat (the cab window arm rest was also used as a seat many times), and a manifold with valves for appliances such as the air compressor and turbogenerator.  Also, the boiler pressure gauge, boiler water level sight glass, air brake gauge and speedometer. Electrical switches for the headlights and class lights (when used) as well. And a valve to provide steam heat for passenger cars, if equipped for that service.  Lots of stuff in a very small space!  The camelback's center cab on the left side generally had very little in it other than a seat and maybe plumbing for the left side boiler water injector. 

S. Islander   

@S. Islander posted:

On a camelback, the back-head (firebox face) usually had had two firing doors, a tri-cock and water gauge, steam pressure gauge and an air brake gauge. Sometimes a rack to hold oiling cans (and a coffee pot) as well. There usually was also provision for the bell cord.    On the right (engineer's) side of the loco in the center cab was the throttle, reverser, air brake stand, bolier water injector control valves, sander control valve, whistle and bell cords, a seat (the cab window arm rest was also used as a seat many times), and a manifold with valves for appliances such as the air compressor and turbogenerator.  Also, the boiler pressure gauge, boiler water level sight glass, air brake gauge and speedometer. Electrical switches for the headlights and class lights (when used) as well. And a valve to provide steam heat for passenger cars, if equipped for that service.  Lots of stuff in a very small space!  The camelback's center cab on the left side generally had very little in it other than a seat and maybe plumbing for the left side boiler water injector.

S. Islander   

This is an AWESOME description! I'll defintley try to add some of these. I'm also contemplating taking out the Engineer figures and putting in ones from Woodland Scenics! That being said, would you or anyone else have an idea on how to model these features in O scale? What items would be best used to make these gauges and levers? I could possibly use legos for the gagues, Lego even makes gauge pieces, but I worry they will be too big to fit in the small space.  Perhaps cardstock cut into circles?

@Randy_B posted:

I was wondering also about adding detail to the Lionel Camelback model, but I was more fixated on the exterior detail. I haven't actually pulled the trigger on the latest Lionel offering as I much prefer the tooling and details of the MTH version. It was nearly double the price of the Lionel model, but I would be willing to pay for the extra detail.

However, finding and MTH Premier Camelback for sale has been tough. I would consider either release (2008, 2016) of the Reading version but to this point I have exclusively Legacy steam engines so I would have to commit to another control system. Not sure I want to do that, except there are a few other small Premier steam engines I would like to have eventually as well. I doubt Lionel bought all of the ones I'm hoping to get although that would be ideal.

Getting back around to adding exterior detail to a steam locomotive, how are things best attached?

Do what I did. Get the older TMCC version. I plan on having the sound fiddled with so I get more than one chuff per revolution, but it is a great running model and is more or less visually identical to the new Legacy one other than the fact that it has TMCC.  If you don't mind fewer electronics its a good buy. I got mine for $400 which I don't think is a bad price for a steam loco of that caliber. It's a good puller and looks great.  The fact that it's a Valley engine doesn't hurt either. 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×