Skip to main content

Given the increasing presence of light rail systems in today's urban transportation landscape, perhaps it's time a model of a contemporary light rail vehicle or "LRV" made an appearance in three rail O gauge. From a modeling perspective, much of the equipment running on these systems is designed to specifications provided by the individual transit agencies so it would be extremely difficult to develop a model which would be precisely accurate for an expansive number of systems; however, I believe a model representative of "typical" LRV design could be created and successfully marketed. For example, Kato recently introduced an N scale LRV. Although its design is based upon a Japanese prototype, the car's overall image strikes me as being representative of equipment presently in service on a number of North American systems:

 

http://www.katousa.com/N/JSE/LRV.html

 

I'm interested in purchasing reasonably accurate models of contermporary LRVs. Is anyone else?

 

Bob   

 

      

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I'd agree, though with a slight twist:

 

In Europe there is an increasing trend to build LRV's that are also capable [ from a catenary voltage / signalling / wheel standards, etc  standpoint ] of running over 'main line' railways out into the far suburbs as well as over conventional street running in the city centre portions.  I think a model of this type would sell well in Europe if well executed.

 

If I were MTH -- admittedly a scary thought -- I would consider bringing out a scale, two rail only version aimed primarily at the European [ read "Germany" ] market;  in addition to being a stand alone sale model, it would make a great starter set when combined with their 24" radius track.  Working doors and command would be a prerequisite;  nonpowered vehicles would also be made, which need not have all the bells and whistles.  For North America, a three rail version with tinplate compromises would follow, and it would be more generic. 

 

To answer your question:  I'd probably buy a scale version.

 

With best rgds, SZ

 

 

 

 

 

 

Originally Posted by Steinzeit:

I'd agree, though with a slight twist:

 

In Europe there is an increasing trend to build LRV's that are also capable [ from a catenary voltage / signalling / wheel standards, etc  standpoint ] of running over 'main line' railways out into the far suburbs as well as over conventional street running in the city centre portions.  I think a model of this type would sell well in Europe if well executed.

We already have something to that effect in New Jersey - Newark Light Rail traverses the subway system and runs on street level; the Riverline runs from Trenton to Camden; Hudson Bergen Light Rail.

Originally Posted by DaveP:
Originally Posted by Steinzeit:

I'd agree, though with a slight twist:

 

In Europe there is an increasing trend to build LRV's that are also capable [ from a catenary voltage / signalling / wheel standards, etc  standpoint ] of running over 'main line' railways out into the far suburbs as well as over conventional street running in the city centre portions.  I think a model of this type would sell well in Europe if well executed.

We already have something to that effect in New Jersey - Newark Light Rail traverses the subway system and runs on street level; the Riverline runs from Trenton to Camden; Hudson Bergen Light Rail.

Unfortunately, the FRA's crashworthy standards won't allow LRV's to run on mixed use lines in the US like in Europe. At least maybe not until PTC is in place on all lines.  

Having said that, I'd love to see some O gauge LRV stuff. Then again, I prefer having toy train versions of real trains I can still ride on.

 

Originally Posted by Just a fan:
Originally Posted by DaveP:

 

Unfortunately, the FRA's crashworthy standards won't allow LRV's to run on mixed use lines in the US like in Europe. At least maybe not until PTC is in place on all lines.  

Having said that, I'd love to see some O gauge LRV stuff. Then again, I prefer having toy train versions of real trains I can still ride on.

 

An exception and work around to this is the Sprinter LRV that runs from Escondido to Oceanside CA on track that is used at night by BNSF and during the day by the commuter line. They use German Diesel LRVs. It is a pretty cool operation.

If you want a prototypic excuse to run electric light rail on three-rail track without overhead wires, here it is:          

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alimentation_par_Sol          

 

"Ground-level power supply" is a system with sectionalized electric third-rail between the running rails which are only energized when a railcar is over it, so there is no live third rail exposed to street traffic.

Bordeaux-aps-overhead-wire-transition

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Bordeaux-aps-overhead-wire-transition
Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×