MTH Pennsy 4-8-2 M1a ?

Just to give a different view to SJC I bought a late PS2 version a year ago second hand. Apart from a minor problem with the tether it has run great. The sounds and smoke are excellent and the thing certainly looks huge with the coast to coast tender.

Obviously the PS3 comments don't apply but I can say that the finish on mine was pretty much flawless.

The only thing I have done to it is add a real coal load which has improved the look no end. I can't comment on the PS3 version but overall I am very pleased with the "look" 

What exact problems did you have with the running gear? Can you explain in more detail?

What curves were you running or did the draw bar have problems on the straights too?

I don't get to concerned about the paint after all mine get used and they will get that used look after time. However with that said was all the paint peeling or just look like it was nicked?

What did they do to try and repair the train?

Thanks for your first hand report I appreciate it.

Note: If it means anything the dealer is suppose to have gotten this one back in stock on Tuesday does that make a difference?

Ditto Mike W. I purchased a PS2 version. It is a great running locomotive. I did have the tether replaced. It was a resale, but almost new.  I took the advice of my local LHS man and bought it. Has a great finish to it. Happy I bought it.

I can't remember if they did the Imperial version in PS2 but I would assume it was done at least once. Regardless, I personally would hunt down a new or slightly used PS2 version with cable tether. If it isn't an Imperial version, you could easily add a coal load, darken the rods, add chains, marker lights, etc for a few extra bucks and come out with a solid little locomotive. Just my $0.02...

My version came with firebox glow, darkened rods but no real coal load or builders plates. Either way still one of my favourites.

MIKE

Is yours a PS3? I am still considering but taking in all the info I can on this one.