Skip to main content

Now sure what else to call it other than lurching...

The F3 has 2 motors wired in parallel, when power is applied the rear motor starts before the motor in the front.  The NW2 has the same setup and problem.  Same can motors in both diesels from what I can see.

I was thinking about swapping the rear motor in the NW2 for the front motor in the F3, to see if it's nothing more than the 2 motors not being in sync with each other or simply made a bit differently.

At first I thought it was nothing more than the slop from the design of the truck plates that hold the trucks and the motor together, but when I turn the engines over in a cradle I can see the rear motor on each starts to turn before the front motor.

Anybody else experience this and what have you done or what are your thoughts?

Would wiring them in series solve the problem?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

If you could include part numbers for the engines that does help with some of the troubleshooting.  I'm going to assume that these are PS2 or PS3 engines and the rear motors on both engines have tach tape on the flywheel and a tach reader.

The behavior you describe above is normal for low speeds (1 - 3 SMPH). The PS2/3 board will apply voltage to both motors to reach the desired speed as indicated by only the rear motor.  If the front motor doesn't start moving by 5 SMPH, then I'd investigate the motors more.  One (or both) could be bad. I'd also look to make sure there is no binding in either of the truck gearing.

Sorry, should include in all my posts that I'm using BPRC, no longer using DCS.

Let's just say I have 0-9.6v going to the motors, what would cause the rear motor on each diesel to start before the front one?  No mechanical binding that I can tell.  I'm thinking it's nothing more than the motors are not "matched" or in sync.  When assembled I'm sure they just grab 2 motors out of the bin and put them in.

I'm using a Deltang RX65b receiver.  I've posted on another forum to see what they say about how it handles 2 motors.

I MAY have found the problem...While I had the F3 apart I decided to clean out the old grease on the worm and gearing.  I say old, not sure how old the unit is.

After cleaning it out and making sure there was no debris in the worm/gears I re-greased and gave it a spin.  I can still see the rear truck move just before the front truck but it has drastically reduced, enough that I'm satisfied with it's performance as of now.

Makes me want to do that to all my diesels although these 2 are the only ones giving this problem.

I did not see any big debris in the grease I removed, but I did find out one thing...grease and cat hair are a no-no!!!  That's some fine cat hair but it may have been enough to gunk up the works, mini hairballs!!!

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by MTH Electric Trains

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×