Skip to main content

Team,

 

I am about to purchase and install my first turntable so I am trying to plan with options. Sorry but I have some very basic questions that I am hoping more experienced modelers can give me some direction on the overall plan and what the scene needs to look like

 

1. From the table pit, what is the average / prototypical length of the visible tracks to the front doors of a round house or Diesel Shed. I have heard anywhere from 8 to 10 inches is best.

 

2. What is the average depth of the Roundhouse or Diesel shed. I am looking at Korber as they provide a scale. Is that the best - scale I should use for planning purposes?

 

3. Did railroads with roundhouses typically have a set or tracks that went around the back of the Roundhouse? I have seen a wide variety of pictures on the Internet but not sure if the RR's did that. Historians - please help. 

 

Thanks in advance.

 

Kevin 

 

Slide1

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Turn Table Planning: Planning Picture
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

This Korber Models page has a lot of detailed information on the 304 house. The 304 house is 30" deep, there are templates.  I have an older Diamond Scale TT that is 27" diameter.   Distance from the edge of the Turntable pit to the RH door is 12"  Note that the spur tracks inside the house are not center in each bay.  The Korber houses were designed for a 32" Bowser turntable.

 

Turntable and house layout takes approximately 7ft (blue cloud wall to the back of the house), X 5 ft as pictured. One additional stall was added to the 304 house.

 

Last edited by Mike CT

Both Rich Redmond, Korber Models, and Al Zamorski, Mill House River Studios, are excellent.  There is additional information on the Korber 304 about floor layout and installation, fabricated roof, gutters and downspouts.

Note:  Smaller TT tends to limit the size of locomotives, but Korber, beyond the 30" length of each bay, does an extender kit, for the 304 house.  This is a picture of the Fort Pitt High Railer's modular RH with one additional bay and the extender kit.  Roof sections, as pictured, are fabricated, not part of the kit(s).

Best wishes with your project.

Both vendors are forum sponsors

 Mike CT

Last edited by Mike CT
Originally Posted by PSU1980:

.............................................

 

Would you mind posting a few additional pictures. Would like to get a little more perspective.

 

Thanks

 Early framing and bench work.  The TT RH was an add to the existing layout that moved into the next room with some remodeling.

Used Diamond Scale TT.  Note the hydrocal, cast, pit wall and pit rail detail.  The base is plywood. 

I fabricate a Roundhouse base template. The paper template provided has to be used (4) times for a (4 bay) house.

 

Layout of track.  Straight lines from the turntable center to the middle of each door.

 Note the three layer floor.

House fabrication is panel by panel on the floor template.  Note that there was a ledge built into the three layers.

Parts/panels windows take some time to get right.  Older 304 Korber model parts were poor, from the box, and required a lot of adjustment work.  The color pictured, is a dye, install as part of the casting, the second  Korber  304, that I did, was painted with Rust-oleum ruddy brown primer for the brick color.

Roof panels were done with 3/16" luan board, 3 accurately fabricated pieces, Front and rear lower level, and the top.  This fabrication is detailed as part of the new Korber 304 assembly instruction.  White paint is a Sherwin Williams Prep-rite Pro-block  primer/sand-able sealer.  A flat black was applied before N gauge ballast both grey and black were used as a roof material.  Korber kit instructions show addition of gutters and downspouts also.

The roof panels are removable. A few small screws hold them in place.

The Diamond Scale Turntable kits required a lot of assembly and adjustment. The bridge removes from the pit relatively easy.  I spent some time on upgrading the pit detail and painted the bridge  Atlas track was installed on the bridge deck.

Ballast detail in the pit.  Paint, Railroad tie brown, applied to the small rail ties that were cast in to the turntable pit.  Completed turntable.

 

 

 

Last edited by Mike CT

Mike and Forum members, 

 

One other question, I am starting to build the bench work, when I get a et a few free moments, Should I use 1/2 or 3/4 plywood for the tabletop. My last layout was a "U" Shaped layout that stretch both sides of my basement, the "U" was because I needed to account for the stairs because I had to climb on it in spots I used 3/4. I am moving the location where I can use 10 * 24 , open and easy to walk around. I will build a few hatches for access. at $50.00 a board for 3/4 inch it is a couple of hundred bucks - but the issue becomes mobility- I want to try to make this a module type of layout and am concerned about the weight so is 1/2 fine?

 

Kevin

Laidoffsick,

 

Thanks, I am trying to get a good look at what people have done. Great work by so many modelers who have been extremely helpful. This is a challenge for me since I have never owned one so I am doing a lot of research before I start this construction.

 

Appreciate the assistance from everyone.

The framing pictured, (16" on center), is premium grade white fir 2" X 4"   

I used an interest top material 1/2" MDO board.  Medium Density Overlay.  It is an exterior grade material used mostly for painted sign construction.  It has a wonderful smooth, paintable, surface that is easy to work with.   Quality grade 1/2" A/C plywood is also an excellent choice.  (A) grade surface would be used for the layout  (C) surface is underneath.

The construction easily supports weight.   Note the extensive framing and double framing.

Trim was done with custom fit clear red oak trim board, top edge was done with an OG router.

  Mike CT

Last edited by Mike CT

 Although space was not a huge issue for me. I based my plans on being 16" between the TT pit and the roundhouse doors. I went with a custom built roundhouse. The only thing I specified was I wanted the tracks to run perfectly straight from the bridge to the doors. I have a Millhouse 28" TT. I would have preferred a greater distance but it ended up being 8  1/2 "s from the pit to the doors. If space becomes an issue it can be done. 

 

 

image

 

 

 The next pic is all I have of the track layout in the roundhouse. If you check out Mike's Korber and mine. You can see the difference in track space. Mike seems to have a lot more floor space. If space becomes an issue. You don't have to limit yourself to stock kits. I believe Altoona Modelworks will custom cut a floor and walls to your specs.

 

 

image

Attachments

Images (2)
  • image
  • image

Track Plan: it was changed where the diesel building is, but everything else is the same. The TT was moved closer to the front of the layout to make room for the RH extension and the reverse loop track behind it. There is also 4 tracks on each side, outside the RH.

 

Final Revision II

 

We left a very large space in the bench work to adjust once we knew "exactly" where the TT was going to go. Once the hole was cut, we adjusted the support.

 

IMG_0553

 

One of the bottom level reverse loops runs around the TT, so we had to make sure everything cleared the TT structure itself, below the middle level.

 

IMG_0659

 

TT & RH were spaced out..... then we remembered we forgot the reverse loop

 

IMG_0845

 

Put the reverse loop in temporarily to we could check clearances again.

 

IMG_0872

 

TT bolted in and leveled out.

 

IMG_0877

IMG_0882

 

I don't know why this picture makes the tracks look bowed, but everything is level. Access holes on each side to work on the RH. Notice the outer tracks at a curve. This is where longer tracks leading into the RH would of been better, but 13" is all we had. In a perfect world, all those tracks go straight.

 

IMG_1057

IMG_1106

 

2 layer plywood floor goes in:

 

IMG_1157

IMG_1158

 

Once all work on the RH was complete, the access were filled in permanently. I would have liked to keep them as hatches, but there was no way I could of made look right. I'm too anal where that is concerned. So now, I have to crawl up there when there is a problem.... but it will hold me

 

IMG_1456

IMG_1812

Attachments

Images (13)
  • Final Revision II
  • IMG_0553
  • IMG_0659
  • IMG_0845
  • IMG_0872
  • IMG_0877
  • IMG_0882
  • IMG_1057
  • IMG_1106
  • IMG_1157
  • IMG_1158
  • IMG_1456
  • IMG_1812

The Korber 304 house was designed with, I think??, 11 degree increments. This worked well with the 32" Bowser TT, at the time.   There was an optimum distance that allowed for the "ROUND" Complete Circle House.

Using spacing of 16.17" (16 3/16") inches between the turntable and the roundhouse allows for the use of straight track to the back center of each stall.

From the Korber website a link to archived Bowser spacing details.

There is a diagram of a 15 stall Korber 304 with each straight track centered in each bay. 16.17" spacing off a 32" Bowser Turntable.  Last page of the Bowser detail.

Carnegie Science Center, Pittsburgh, PA.  10 stalls + 3 outside space-ings.

Last edited by Mike CT

Mke, Laidoffsick and all those folks that have been providing details on how to build the most realistic diorama, this is great information and has given me quite bit to digest. I really appreciate the information. Plan - 28 Inch TT from Millhouse River then based on the comments I need to look at Kober and the others mentioned for a RH. 

 

 

I will be a York for the first time in 15 years so now I have a good idea of hat I need to do - i.e. look at RH's.

 

Should i have the RH before I set the whisker tracks? Is that needed or just make sure I have the schematic of the one I choose first?

 

Seems that the track length from the pit to the front door of the stall needs to be anywhere from 8 ~ 16 inches depending on space. 

 

Again, thanks for all the help.

 

agree...this is such a cool shot I never get tired of it either.
 
Originally Posted by N&W Class J:
Originally Posted by Laidoffsick:
These tracks are 13" from the pit to the stall doors. We would rather have longer tracks, but space limitations prevented pushing the RH back further.
20150228_104406

That is such a mind blowing scene!  I never get tired of seeing that...great modeling!

 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×