Skip to main content

This is one defunct manufacturer that's tough to find any references for (except a general history) and the reason I say this is due to what I don't know (in terms of my having all that they made).  I normally don't concern myself with this sort of thing, and this brand is the one exception.

To date I  have the clockwork and electric versions of their one steam locomotive, the Rock Island diesel ( which is currently being electrically reworked), two of their orange hoppers and their grey boxcar and caboose. Am I missing a item?

Bruce

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Bruce
Over on the Marx Yahoo site, Unique Art is one of our adopted children along with Hafner.
Some other items are the circus cars, both as Unique Lines & Jewel T, all occasionally found with no roof, so really like a hi sided gondola, the stock car, The hi side gondola that looks just like the hopper, a couple of versions of the caboose, a black tender. Once you get past the ones you mentioned, things get real pricey. Probably the hardest thing to find is a power house with a non broken, functioning lever.
 
Steve
 
 
Originally Posted by electroliner:

This is one defunct manufacturer that's tough to find any references for (except a general history) and the reason I say this is due to what I don't know (in terms of my having all that they made).  I normally don't concern myself with this sort of thing, and this brand is the one exception.

To date I  have the clockwork and electric versions of their one steam locomotive, the Rock Island diesel ( which is currently being electrically reworked), two of their orange hoppers and their grey boxcar and caboose. Am I missing a item?

Bruce

Thanks Gary..those passenger cars must be the rarest of the rare, even more so than the circus cars, or, at least, that's my impression. It should not have come as a surprise they all share a similar undercarriage that almost looks European. Their unusual ( larger size) size makes it difficult to come up with a matching consist that does not look ridiculous, although I am very liberal about mixing and matching makes, and I guess that says a lot about their size..I took a comparative set of pictures of the UA placed against other makes, and they nearly look G scale..

 

Here's one question that's related..is UA the maker of the largest equipment made for O gauge? I know that in the U.K running G gauge on O gauge track as a two foot industrial rr representation is common but it is not O scale but sort of a hybrid.

Bruce

Gary

I had completely forgotten about the Marx Santa Fe and 994 (which I have ) and that could be a sign of pending senility but I never heard of the Hoge. The 994 is certainly larger than your average Marx, but to my eyes, it still seems dwarfed by the UA which might be why it slipped from my brain cells ( or at least it's a good excuse for a faulty memory)  I have Marx freight cars with what I  believe are what are called "D" trucks (?) that give them a significant taller appearance that I run with the Santa Fe, which may work with the UA Rock Island ( once it's done).  I do like this larger O gauge equipment even if it is a comparatively small range of choices. Found this and it gets interesting when the Hoge stuff runs..

 

Bruce

Last edited by electroliner

All

I have the impression ( probably mistaken) that the Dorfan passenger cars are then comparable in size to the UA cars. Is this correct? Also, are the Dorfan freight cars sized similarly to the UA freight cars? The reason for asking is the other thread on the resurrection / replication of the Dorfan freight cars. I am thinking ( if similarly sized) they could be added to a consist of UA cars without a large discrepancy in size. BTW...The UA gondola was a surprise to me.

Bruce

Hey Bruce, yes the UA passenger cars were made from those dorfan passenger car molds so yes the bodies and the roofs are exactly the same size.  UA never made an observation car though so that would be a cool custom to try to pull off if one had the means to do so.  As far as the freight cars go they are very very close in size but the UA cars are a little longer but the same basic height.  Not sure if that's because the UA car frames are longer but all the same construction.  Just checked all my Dorfan freight cars and the UA cars are all stretched a tad longer but the basic same thing size/looks wise.  Hope this helps you guys out and im just glad to see UA make some ink somewhere!!     

I recently purchased the Rock Island diesel, and it is a basket case.  I really need a wiring diagram or an explanation on how the motors wire.  I am new to the model train hobby.  My dad just drug his 50's lionel out and we made a display, so I wanted to get a Rock Island train going.  We lived along the tracks in illinois, and wanted to pay tribute.  thanks scrappy

thank you for your concern and input, unfortunately I left the motor with my dad, and cannot photo it right now but I will tomorrow.  i have another set of RI engines comming so I will have 2 power and one dummy, I am missing one set of non power rear wheels to make all serviceable.  The wires are in good shape but the motor is removed.  Two wires the same color go to each of the brushes, one red wire comes off the top front of the motor to the copper windings but goes to the front light then to the middle pick-up off track.  another wire comes off the back copper windings. so 2 off the windings and 2 off the brushes, I will post a photo tomorrow.  I fear i will not be able to locate the missing rear wheels, I did not know how lucky i was to find the 3 unique engines listed on ebay at the same time- i have not found anything since. When I get both power trucks in hand I would gladly send them and would gladly compensate for your time.  If you are able to assist from the photo I will send you a t shirt from our museum for your collection.  thanks again jeff- chris 

jeff, looking at the power truck you have photo's of on your july 5, 7:06 reply- it is the same exact power truck- the brushes are on the top side of that photo (the brass nubs sticking out side by side on the top) and the blue wire comming off the back of the center track pick up, is the same color of the wire that goes to the top of the rear copper windings on top back side of motor....   hope i didn't confuse with the wrong description/label-  you know the thing-a-majig that goes on the doo-hicky... 

Hi All,

 

  After a long time lurking around I decided to join this group and start posting. Of all things I never thought it would be about wind up trains!

 

  I recently picked up a set of the Unique Lines trains for 2 reasons, first I study the history of my hometown Newark, NJ, and second I'm a bonified train nut. 

 

  This thread has been incredibally valuable on this line of trains. So much that I'm looking to add to this stupid, crude looking, but beautiful part of the hobby...REAL tinplate trains. 

 

  Back to my set. It came in a plastic tub with the 742 engine, tender, hopper and caboose, and the City Of Joplin car. All the cars have what's left of their boxes, and what's left of the set box. It is original but red, like none other I can find on the Internet. 

 

  By reading this post I have to say I learned a whole lot more about what I have and now you guys have unknowingly set me on a mission to find the rest of the Unique Art lines, and, well...I guess I have to start adding Marx tinplates too.

 

  Thanks for the info, after being away for 20 years I do hope to hit the train hobby hot and heavy again.

 

Nick

Nick
Welcome to the world of UA. There are only a handful of types, but once you get past the common ones, the variations can get hard$$$$ to land.
 
Steve
 
 
Originally Posted by Old Bus:

Hi All,

 

  After a long time lurking around I decided to join this group and start posting. Of all things I never thought it would be about wind up trains!

 

  I recently picked up a set of the Unique Lines trains for 2 reasons, first I study the history of my hometown Newark, NJ, and second I'm a bonified train nut. 

 

  This thread has been incredibally valuable on this line of trains. So much that I'm looking to add to this stupid, crude looking, but beautiful part of the hobby...REAL tinplate trains. 

 

  Back to my set. It came in a plastic tub with the 742 engine, tender, hopper and caboose, and the City Of Joplin car. All the cars have what's left of their boxes, and what's left of the set box. It is original but red, like none other I can find on the Internet. 

 

  By reading this post I have to say I learned a whole lot more about what I have and now you guys have unknowingly set me on a mission to find the rest of the Unique Art lines, and, well...I guess I have to start adding Marx tinplates too.

 

  Thanks for the info, after being away for 20 years I do hope to hit the train hobby hot and heavy again.

 

Nick

 

One thing I really like about UA is that the motors seem to be very robust. I am used to Marx motors and Schilling motors, but UA motors pack a lot more punch, it seems.

 

That extra power can translate to longer operation times without overheating.

 

Also, it looks like it would be easy to put twin motors in the Rock Island diesel set. That would be cool. It's been on my to do list for years.

Last edited by RoyBoy

Thanks for the info guys I appreciate anything I can learn. Hopefully I can make York this year, I now have a new quest train manufacturer to look for. 

 

I guess it's sad I never looked at Marx until that recent article in The Quartly, and with Unique, I can see where people can get hung up with tinplate/wind up trains.

 

It's a long way from the Bob Gale's I usually look for, but hey, it's still trains.

 

Nick

Since posting this thread, the UA RI diesel has been refurbished and Ive added two gondolas , a boxcar and a caboose as well as a second wind up. I wish they had made more as to be more affordable. What I like about them is their larger size that seems to be lodged somewhere between my G gauge equipment and O..perhaps close to Standard Gauge. The only issue I have had is the freight cars light weight that makes them really bang around so I have discretely added some weight to them. The clockworks version of the steamer really has a robust mechanism. The Hornby stuff pales in comparison as it seems to  avoid getting out of square one at a start, at least not without a gentle push. Once going, they are fine. At Christmas I used a Lionel Standard gauge station in conjunction with the UA for running around the tree, and it seemed to be a perfect match..learning about Dorfan made initiating this thread worthwhile.

Originally Posted by Old Bus:

I'm also starting to look into Dorfan. It's odd that a few weeks ago we rode past the old Dorfan factory in Newark. The building looks like it probably has for 75 or so years...I fantasized just what may be hidden in the basement, or loft....

 

Nick

That whole bit about Fandor \ Dorfan threw me a loop until I found the answer here. I recall a search I did for Unique Arts on Ebay and ended up wit ashtrays, coat racks and some really awful paintings. LOL.

I did a similar search for Unique and found a whole other line of wind up non train toys. I guess you really can go nuts with this stuff.

 

What actually put Dorfan out of business was their guarantee to replace any defective parts free. They had a crude die casting system that allowed the zinc to deteriorate over short time. It was replacement parts. coupled with the depression, that nailed the coffin shut.

 

Nick

 I really should have qualified my statement.
 
 You're 100% right, it hard to think today, with all the technology and advances we have, just how new all this was back then. There was no way of knowing what would happen over time to the castings. I should keep thinking of it as a time when what they were doing was state of the art, along with die casting being relatively new here. Because of this we now know what happened then. To them it was just happening.
 
  I guess to try and sum it up for me is they were pioneering a system that was refined over the years, and what we see today isn't what it was back then. It really has come a long way.
 
  My uncle started working at Lionel in 1935 filing burs by hand off die cast parts. Except for serving in WW-2 and special work during the Korean War, he remained in the die casting department, becoming a senior supervisor, until Lionel closed in NJ. I would love to ask him and see what changes he saw in all thjose years!
 
Nick
 
 
Originally Posted by overlandflyer:
Originally Posted by Old Bus:

....  They had a crude die casting system that allowed the zinc to deteriorate over short time.  ...

i would hesitate to term Dorfan's die casting operations as "crude".  in the early 1920's the only available methods of producing a metal locomotive were cast iron and tab & slot sheet metal construction.  Dorfan was pushing the state of the art when they became the first American manufacturer to offer a die-cast locomotive shell.  the zinc-copper alloy used was coined as "unbreakable" by the company and able to withstand much rougher handling than the more fragile cast iron models with much more detail than sheet metal construction.  it was a few years into production before the instability of the zinc alloy surfaced.

 

Originally Posted by overlandflyer:
Originally Posted by overlandflyer:
....  i have seen another car once lettered for City of Jordan, but i have a strong feeling this was modified from a Joplin car. ...

 

I agree completely. Even in that small picture, the "rda" looks suspicious.

Saw a passenger set with the two UA passenger cars and electric #1950 engine and blue UA tender sell on ebay for 1400.00 last year.  Thats a load of cash for that set my friends.  However the two open topped circus cars have evaded me forever and I will find them, they are the only two UA items I need from their whole O scale train lineup.  One of my favorites of all time is the UA cattle car.

 

JEFF 

Originally Posted by jeffnmanda3:

Saw a passenger set with the two UA passenger cars and electric #1950 engine and blue UA tender sell on ebay for 1400.00 last year.  Thats a load of cash for that set my friends.  However the two open topped circus cars have evaded me forever and I will find them, they are the only two UA items I need from their whole O scale train lineup.  One of my favorites of all time is the UA cattle car.

 

JEFF 

I like Bennie the Brakeman too.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • benny the brakeman
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×