Some reference has been made in this thread about the reliability of these new products.
In short, I have purchased 12 engines in the past 15 months. Only one of these was used.
Total number of engines: 12
Number needing repair: 5 (one used)
Cost of repairs: $1180.
Details:
Atlas O TH&B SW Switcher Fine
Atlas O CP GP-9 & Dummy Fine
3rd Rail CP RDCs(2) Both fine
3rd Rail CP Mikado (2) Both fine
3rd Rail CP Selkirk cost of home repair $140 (Bought used). Still quirky but runs. No whistle or bell.
3rd Rail CP 3101 4-8-4 cost of repair $300. Was DOA. Fine after professional repair.
3rd Rail CP D10 New sound board needed. Not yet done. Cost $140
Weaver CP 2816 Factory repair under warranty $70 shipping. Cost of additional home repair $300.
MTH CN 4-8-4 Cost of professional repairs $320.
MTH CP E-8 Fine
Oh, yes. My Legacy HC also malfunctioned, required replacement.
How many of these things will be running a year from now? Ten years? Longer?