A friend of mine brought over to my layout a 40' AtlasO Pennsy gondola. I compared it to the new Menards gondola. Both are 40' and both widths are the same. Of course the Atlas gondola is better detailed and has diecast trucks.
The Menards gondola is very nice, great paint schemes, scale sized and they do seem to ride low.
The cons are, no steps on the corners, they could be added very easily, plastic trucks but I have run them for about 6 hrs. over the weekend and they ran just fine, no wobble, they track very well. With some weight of a load they will be a nice add to my fleet of freight cars.
I would like to see more prototypical paint schemes and where they got the B&O scheme is beyond me. But then again they were $19.99 and for the money it is a good deal. I like them.
Dave