Skip to main content

I've always liked the B&O and especially the Lionel PW No 2368 which I only recently (past 5 years) discovered is not prototypical.

 

Have assembled a few B&O diesels in the blue/yellow/'other' scheme and am curious what is correct.

 

Here are the Lionel Sharks (rear), a MTH Premier FA B unit and a Williams FA A unit.

 

Considering my toy train roots, I like the MTH unit followed by the Lionel Sharks.  The Williams A unit appears too 'dull' and 'drab' for me at this point. While the other two are lighter they are also not gray - more a very pale blue (especially the MTH) while the Williams is definitely gray.  Big difference in the graphics as well.

 

This is a combination of natural light and an incandescent lamp.

 

Your thoughts please

IMG_3247

IMG_3248

IMG_3249

 

 

PS  - Was there a prototype for the MTH ABA set with the light 'blue' pilot, fuel tanks, and trucks?

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_3247
  • IMG_3248
  • IMG_3249
Last edited by c.sam
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Sam,

Many of us who model the B&O favor Scalecoat B&O colors. In real life, the gray often faded to a light shade whereas many of us think it actually had a slightly greenish tint to it when freshly painted, somewhat like the FA diesel in your photos.

 

As far as pilot colors, freight pilots were black whereas passenger pilots were gray with horizontal blue stripes. The only non black trucks I ever saw on cab units were in builders' photos - not in service.

 

I have a good bit of B&O passenger equipment and the blue and gray colors vary by piece which does not bother me in the least. I very much like the shading of the Golden Gate B&O Columbian which uses slightly different colors than the GGD heavyweight B&O passenger equipment.

 

One solution for you would be to get rid of your diesels and change to all black steam power (with the exception of the Sunset /3rd Rail P-7e which is blue).

 

R. Heil

B&O Historical Society member

Sam, my first Sharks were my Legacy B&O set, and when I bought a WBB B unit to go with them, I repainted its slightly different gray to match the Lionel.  I'd probably prefer a darker gray on all of them, but I love these as they are now.  

 

Of course, in the real world, color on loco units probably varied.  Paint fades, etc.  I recall it bothered me to no end as a child that the A-B-B-A Santa Fe F3s Id' see where visibly different tones of red and silver sheen.  I would think a darker gray would chalk out and fade pretty fast, too, and be noticeable lighter in only a few years.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×