Skip to main content

I have a few Weaver Gold Edition steamers from the early 90s looking for TMCC conversion.  I tried an ERR DC Commander in these and a Williams K4 with unacceptable results.  Extremely jerky, almost on- off sort of scenario, and noisy operation.  At about mid-speed, things would smooth out. It was sent back to ERR as they were not sure why I had this result.  The replacement worked the same and Ken reported the system I returned worked fine.  Kudos to ERR customer service!

In dual can motored diesels, this system works fine and I am very happy with it's performance.  I talked to Ken again about the DC Commander and their use in Weaver and Williams Locos, and he responded that he and his engineer were not at all surprised by this.  I asked about the Cruise Commander for this use and he stated they were not sure it would work either.  What?

Twice the money for the Cruise and no guarantee.  Experiences?  Fix?  

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

These are brass engines, no? How did you run the antenna wire? Also check your headlight for flickering assuming you are driving the headlight from the new electronics which could point to poor signal. Can you take a picture of the motor? Most all large can motors will work OK with cruise but you still need to make sure the antenna is not shielded by what is located in, engine or tender. There are different techniques depending on where you put the electronics.

Pete

Last edited by Norton

I've probably done at least 20-30 brass engine upgrades, I've stopped counting.  I've yet to run across a motor in any brass steamer, be it 3rd Rail, Weaver, or Williams that doesn't handle cruise.  The DC commander should handle virtually any motor, even the ones that "cog" and cause issues with back-EMF cruise control.  I have installed exactly two DC Commanders in the last several years, a handful of AC Commanders, and a ton of Cruise Commanders in everything imaginable.  I own at least five Weaver brass steamers, all have ERR Cruise and run great.  I've upgraded a number of Williams diesels, and a couple of Williams steam, no issues there either.

I'm truthfully a bit surprised that Ken would tell you that, I have no idea why.  I can only imagine that he figured if you were having issues with the DC Commander, you would likely have similar issues with the Cruise Commander.

So these ran fine on there original system?  I have seen brass engines with mechanical issues that need to be resolved first.  The Early stuff normally.

Also, most of those early engine have Mabuchi knock offs or just 3 pole motors (540).  You can make the switch to the 545 series 5 pole motor.  G

Hi John, Although seeing this five years after the fact I found your post searching for Weaver brass conversions to err.   I have some Weaver brass Mikado and Pacifics that I would like to install TMCC from ERR.  How do/did you handle the antenna?  Based on the frequency of the command signal from the rail the hand rails would be ideal but that seems difficult to do after the fact.  Does ERR supply something to use?

Any advice to help update any project or order to ERR?

Thanks!

I have two weaver gold addition steam locos and the inrush amperage is to much for the ERR DC commander. the locos jerked on and off when starting but once moving would run ok. I replaced the motor in one  and need to do the second one. pyymans are getting hard to find , at least ones that would fit these to locos.

Thanks Rick and Ron, I will need to pay attention to the motors in the Weavers.  I do not know all the history of what was used but will at least try to figure out the stall current as I have read on other posts that the Williams locos can have fairly high stall.  I am hoping the Weaver brass locos do not but I have not tested yet.  I really like the brass Weavers and have been able to get a couple for not a lot of money which is a very good thing.  I am fairly cheap but love working on stuff (like my 15 sailboats to date).

I am very new to O and do not have the motor vocabulary/experience that most or some of you do.  And I can imagine that the current supply crush has messed up AC and DC precision motor availability as well.  It is amazing how long it takes to get what were pedestrian chips due to the impact of the pandemic.

Thanks!

Last edited by Robbin

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×