Difference between two MTH Engines

Mike,

First, all DCS hardware and software can operate all PS2 and PS3 engines. The caveats are that some features, such a quilling whistle, require newer software and taht DCS 3.1 was a somewhat buggy release.

Second, all DCS hardware can be used with all versions of DCS.

Third, in order to upgrade the sound files in PS3 engines, the latest DCS software, DCS 4.20 and teh latest Loader Program 2.30 are required.

Last, PS3 engines are superior to PS2 engines. They do not require a battery ad, when used with the latest Rev. L TIU, will yield significantly better DCS signal strength under adverse wiring and track topology conditions.

One thing that always strikes me is the presence/absence of a wired tether.  I happen not to like them but they might not bother you.  The PS2 has a wired tether and the PS3 does not.

One of my criteria would be price.  If you are talking the $30 difference in MSRP, it ought to be a no-brainer.  PS3 is the way to go.  However, if money is tight, you might find the PS2 version deeply discounted enough to make it worth buying over the PS3. Only you can decide that.

I'm with Barry though.  The PS3 is superior to the PS2.  I'd wait.

As for upgrading, have no fear.  I would absolutely upgrade DCS on your remote/tiu.  There are a lot of people who can help step you through it.  Some hobby shops will do it for you.  If you go to York, I am sure you will be able to find someone to do it.  As a last resort, there is probably someone on here that would do it for you if you send it to them and cover the postage both ways.

So would you suggest waiting for the October release, since PS3 engines are overall better engines and offer more than better sound?

Hi Mike everyone above hit the nail on the head, But there's one other issue. First

I like MTH and they make great products. But The release date of the newer engine is just an estimate, it says a few months but you might wait a year or more. Any engines I buy from MTH are used this way I don't have to wait.

Thanks, Alex

Sorry, I did not see your post until after I posted my comment. Sounds like I'm better off waiting for the October release. Thanks for the your opinions and feedback. I was under the impression that PS3 engines were only an improvement on the sound, but apparently that is not the case.