Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Buy direct from 3rd Rail. Any benefit you THINK you may have from a dealer, is NOT worth the hassle. Been down that road too many times.

 

All my Golden Gate Depot and 3rd Rail orders go direct, and Scott Mann bends over backwards to take care of his customers. No he did not pay me to say that

Folks: Let me set the record straight. Sunset Models Inc. and Golden Gate Depot, will sell models through any Hobby Retail Store or previously grand fathered in dealer in good standing.

 

Rarely, do any of these dealers stock our models, so that's why you don't see them on shelves. In addition, we don't offer dealers huge mark ups, so they are not putting very much effort into promoting them. So we promote them. If a customer has a favorite dealer they prefer to work with, we will "bend over backwards" for that dealer as well.

 

Also, if reservations are tight, and there are customers and other dealers on standby, we do not transfer reservations back and forth from dealers to customers and back before we cater to those on stand by. In other words, if you get out of line, you lose your place in line.

 

Also, we cannot know whose reservations from dealers are for who. It is the dealers responsibility to fulfill their customers orders. In other words, if your dealer doesn't pay for your order, it won't ship.

 

That's what I know.


Scott Mann

Last edited by sdmann
Originally Posted by Laidoffsick:

Buy direct from 3rd Rail. Any benefit you THINK you may have from a dealer, is NOT worth the hassle. Been down that road too many times.

 

All my Golden Gate Depot and 3rd Rail orders go direct, and Scott Mann bends over backwards to take care of his customers. No he did not pay me to say that

Same here Doug. Scott is fantastic to work with. Well worth any extra $ you might save. I've ordered both direct and through a preferred dealer, but I prefer going direct for the level of service that Scott provides.

I might add that in the past I ordered all of my 3rd Rail from Bill Oberst in Georgetown,SC.  When Bill closed up I switched over to a rather well known and popular dealer.  I had no problems for awhile.  Then I missed out on a couple of items that I had pre ordered. Later on I found out that there were some financial issues with that dealer.  From then on I just place my orders direct with no problems whatsoever.

 

Norm 

Last edited by Norm
Originally Posted by Hot Water:

Another advantage of purchasing direct is,,,,,no sales tax!  In my state/county, the sales tax can sometimes exceed the shipping cost.

Not for me it ain't  and that's why I tried using a dealer... but that bit me in the *ss.. twice. CA rips me off everyday, in various ways. That's why most of my purchases are made online, out of this state.

 
Thanks, everyone .... including Scott.
 
A short time ago, I actually did send an email to a train shop that stated that they carry 3rd Rail .... that they had the engines drop-shipped to customers from 3rd Rail. I never heard back from them .... bad sign. LOL. That's why I asked here.
 
I would be happy to buy directly from 3rd Rail .... everyone here says they are good people.
 
So .... 3rd Rail, Sunset Models, and Golden Gate Depot are kinda/sorta the same company?
 
 
Originally Posted by Hot Water:

Another advantage of purchasing direct is,,,,,no sales tax!  In my state/county, the sales tax can sometimes exceed the shipping cost.

Doesn't Illinois require out of state retailers to collect sales tax at the time of purchase now? Instead of relying on folks to voluntarily report/pay the tax to the state?

 

I was visiting a friend in southern Illinois last year, and he was talking about it. It was being settled in state court, maybe? Or, maybe I had downed too many Bud's when he was talking about it. Lol.

Originally Posted by Matt01:
 
Thanks, everyone .... including Scott.
 
A short time ago, I actually did send an email to a train shop that stated that they carry 3rd Rail .... that they had the engines drop-shipped to customers from 3rd Rail. I never heard back from them .... bad sign. LOL. That's why I asked here.
 
I would be happy to buy directly from 3rd Rail .... everyone here says they are good people.
 
So .... 3rd Rail, Sunset Models, and Golden Gate Depot are kinda/sorta the same company?
 
Yes.
 
Originally Posted by Hot Water:

Another advantage of purchasing direct is,,,,,no sales tax!  In my state/county, the sales tax can sometimes exceed the shipping cost.

Doesn't Illinois require out of state retailers to collect sales tax at the time of purchase now? Instead of relying on folks to voluntarily report/pay the tax to the state?

 

Only if that company has an actual establishment, i.e. "place of business" within the state of Illinois. For example, whenever my wife orders something from say, Pottery Barn, then we have to pay Illinois sales tax. When she orders from say, Omaha Steaks, then no sales tax.

 

I was visiting a friend in southern Illinois last year, and he was talking about it. It was being settled in state court, maybe? Or, maybe I had downed too many Bud's when he was talking about it. Lol.

 

Add yet another hobbiest who prefers to order directly from 3rd Rail.

 

These offerings are usually BTO and ordering directly from the source guarantees delivery.  Worth every penny of the extra $50 savings on a $1200 - $1500 purchase!

 

Besides every extra dollar gives Scott the money to travel to Asia to make sure that the items are being made correctly!

 

Jim

 

 

 

 

Scott does bend over for his dealers as well!  We keep a stock of Sunset and Golden Gate Depot, and if anything ever goes wrong Scott takes care of us just like he does for his retail customers.  
 
Originally Posted by sdmann:

Folks: Let me set the record straight. Sunset Models Inc. and Golden Gate Depot, will sell models through any Hobby Retail Store or previously grand fathered in dealer in good standing.

 

Rarely, do any of these dealers stock our models, so that's why you don't see them on shelves. In addition, we don't offer dealers huge mark ups, so they are not putting very much effort into promoting them. So we promote them. If a customer has a favorite dealer they prefer to work with, we will "bend over backwards" for that dealer as well.

 

Also, if reservations are tight, and there are customers and other dealers on standby, we do not transfer reservations back and forth from dealers to customers and back before we cater to those on stand by. In other words, if you get out of line, you lose your place in line.

 

Also, we cannot know whose reservations from dealers are for who. It is the dealers responsibility to fulfill their customers orders. In other words, if your dealer doesn't pay for your order, it won't ship.

 

That's what I know.


Scott Mann

 

I've purchased a fair amount of 3rd Rail (and Sunset HO product) over the last 11 years from the following sources:

 

  • Direct from Scott Mann
  • Chicagoland Hobbies
  • JD Trains
  • ModelTrainStuff
  • Rider's Hobby
  • Oak Creek Hobby

 

They ALL provided great service, and whether or not you purchase from direct from Scott, or thru a dealer, the service is still exceptional. 

 

There is no one and "only" way to go.

 

Regards,

GNNPNUT

 

GRJohn,

 

I respectfully disagree.  I have had several delays and other funky issues with the dealers.  I have NEVER -- starting in 1998 had one single issue with purchasing directly from Scott Mann/Sunset 3rd Rail.  Unlike other manufacturers, Scott's service prior to and during the sale and support after the sale is truly outstanding.

 

So, I find no "value added" in  inserting a dealer between me and Sunset -- other than saving a few bucks.  If it were a true bricks and mortar true full service local hobby shop dealer I would feel different.  But, in my part of the world those days are LONG GONE. 

 

The nearest bricks and mortar dealer who has a full line of Sunset 3rd Rail engines is several weeks away from Austin Texas by stagecoach.  Oops.  Or perhaps a rocket ship ride to the dark side of the moon. 

 

The internet dealers do provide a valuable service to us with the other brands and I do order from them on a regular basis. 

 

Bill

Last edited by Austin Bill
Originally Posted by ed new haven line:

I ordered my FL9s from my local train dealer here in Westchester County, NY. He ordered and sold around 75 of them because that's is where these locomotives ran for the New Haven, Penn Central, Conrail, Amtrak and Metro-North Railroads. I also ordered the FP7s and New York Central T-Motor electric as well. However when I wanted to order the F7s and the SD7 he informed me that it was not worth the effort as he has to pay upfront for these locomotives when placing his orders and since his cost is only $100.00 less then the retail price plus the shipping cost of $30.00 for each engine there is hardly any profit left. 

 

Just my opinion but, your dealer is definitely feeding you a line, about "paying up-front"!!!

 

He had to borrow over $30.000 to send with his order for the FL9s.

 

Well, he may have had to borrow money in order to pay Sunset/3rd Rail when they arrived at Scott's facility in California, otherwise Scott wouldn't have shipped the models to him. But he sure didn't have to "pay up-front", just to reserve/order ANYTHING from Sunset/3rd Rail/Golden Gate Depot.

 

 I wound up paying a little less then if I ordered them directly from Scott. So unless you can find dealer in your area who is willing to pay Scott when placing an order for you it is best to order direct from Scott.

 

So, as just an average customer, you didn't have to "pay up-front", simply to reserve/order anything at all,did you?

 

On the sales tax - California has a statute that says you are obliged to pay tax when you purchase out-of-state.  Most of us have no idea, but you are supposed to self-report at the end of each year, and pay tax on that pair of socks you mail-ordered from Cabelas.

 

Big ticket items get them all excited - do not think you can buy a King Air out if state and operate it in California without either paying the use tax or hiring a fancy lawyer.  Autos are the same way.  But a $500 train might escape notice.  The tax folks just don't have the time to look you up.

 

I suspect other states are the same.

 

As far as being ripped off - how do we think government services are financed?  Money has to come from somewhere.  I suppose we could de-fund the firefighters and bridge builders - leave Interstate 10 closed permanently?

If that was the way the government spent the money I doubt anyone would feel ripped off, but it's not and everyone knows it. 

 

Another +++ for Scott and 3rd Rail. Ordering direct is the only way to go. Really professional people in his organization who care...you don't see that very much in today's world.

 

Butch

 
I was going to use one of the aforementioned dealers for a 3rd Rail engine. It was to be drop-shipped to me, with a significant discount. The dealer suddenly stopped communicating with me when I was ready to purchase. Go figure.
 
I ended up purchasing my one and only 3rd Rail engine directly from Scott .... and will do so in the future if I buy another. 
 
 
 
Originally Posted by bob2:

On the sales tax - California has a statute that says you are obliged to pay tax when you purchase out-of-state.  Most of us have no idea, but you are supposed to self-report at the end of each year ......

Well, its right on the state income tax form we file each year, so I would say that most people *choose* to "have no idea" about it. Lol.

 

In Illinois, I believe the change in tax law concerned how an out of state business registered in the state. Before this year, if a business had a physical presence in the state, it would be required to collect sales tax. Now, merely a legal presence in the state triggers the sales tax collection requirement.

Last edited by CNJ Jim

To Hot Water:

 

I may have misunderstood about paying when the order was placed however this was  three years ago and it was his first order with Scott and since it was such a large order Scott may have required some sought of payment when placing the order. I how ever did not pay anything until my dealer received the FL9s. I have since found another dealer who I can order their product from.

Originally Posted by ed new haven line:

To Hot Water:

 

I may have misunderstood about paying when the order was placed however this was  three years ago and it was his first order with Scott and since it was such a large order Scott may have required some sought of payment when placing the order.

 

Sorry, but that is not correct. No matter what your dealer told you, Scott does NOT request, nor require, ANY sort of payment in advance, i.e when reserving, nor ordering, any of his products.

 

I how ever did not pay anything until my dealer received the FL9s. I have since found another dealer who I can order their product from.

 

Scott did require payment for the first order but not for any future orders but since that was 3 years ago it really does not matter anymore. End of story.
 
 
 
 
 
Originally Posted by Hot Water:
Originally Posted by ed new haven line:

To Hot Water:

 

I may have misunderstood about paying when the order was placed however this was  three years ago and it was his first order with Scott and since it was such a large order Scott may have required some sought of payment when placing the order.

 

Sorry, but that is not correct. No matter what your dealer told you, Scott does NOT request, nor require, ANY sort of payment in advance, i.e when reserving, nor ordering, any of his products.

 

I how ever did not pay anything until my dealer received the FL9s. I have since found another dealer who I can order their product from.

 

 

I just placed my very first order with GGD a few weeks back for the second run of the El Cap. I ordered directly from GGD and not only did Scott take my order but answered a number of questions and helped with at least two changes to my order. All the time he was communicating from China! He took the time to deal with a first time customer like I was the most important customer he had.

Dealing with Scott is a total breeze and while this was my first order it won't be my last.

BTW: my order for the El Cap totaled around 3K and I received an order confirmation from GGD without sending a penny upfront.

 

PS.. now I have my fingers crossed that Scott will come through and get that second run produced... I have faith baby!! 

I have been dealing with all the mentioned dealers at the top of this thread and have never had a problem with anyone of them ever. Beth, Norm the folks at Western Depot (took the time top drive up and meet them one night when I was in sacramento) and last but not least, I'm sure I've driven Jeff nuts over my road number specific orders.

 

That said, Ive found with 3rd Rail/Sunset/GGD by dealing with Scott over the years, speaking with him at York and getting to know one another for the difference you "save" and profit etc, etc. I've been placing orders directly with Scott. That also may have to do with my last minute "get off the fence and order Sam" dilemma I always seem to have with big ticket stuff. But I will always continue to spread things around however.

 

I have seen Scott and Joe Hayter (Weaver) work together to get my N&W Mollie fixed as it did not run right out of the box.

 

Just for the simple fact that we (Forumites) have tortured him over the years for prototypes we all thought we'd never see, is reason enough for me to justify a little extra profit go right back to Scott.

 

I'm sure Mort is proud of what Scott continues to do with the company and the hobby, he carries on with his dad's love for the hobby and dedication to fine products.

 

IMHO, a great guy to deal with and you know your going to get what you want.

 

Sam Caliciotti

Last edited by Samtrak

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×