Skip to main content

I’m just looking at the details of setting up a small O27 layout with a passing loop, with the trains stopping alternately, controlled by isolated control rails. It seems quite straightforward in principle, but one thing I do notice is a point (in a post on CTT) about ensuring that the couplers on the rest of the train, are isolated from the loco frame (so they do not bypass the control rails through the coupler solenoid coils) 

The article mentions “some plastic tape” but looking at various items of rolling stock, the thumb-tack type couplers, and the dumb couplers on some MPC era rolling stock are plastic, are they not? 

So, as long as either the loco, and/or the leading car of any train running on this layout have a thumbtack or dumb coupler, I am good to go? 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

This is the original source. I had understood from context, that the “control rail” was the outside rail adjacent to the frog. I understand your point, but I had envisaged the “trigger” being an isolated outer rail, made live by the passage of train A and so, charging the outer rails under train B. It only needs to be live for long enough for train B to advance one rail length, after all. 

DB96AF80-4469-49CE-A0AF-1CCF46E609CC

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DB96AF80-4469-49CE-A0AF-1CCF46E609CC
Last edited by Rockershovel

Seems like your last post is responding to a non-existent post but as I understand it, your application is the Automatic Control of Trains configuration per the classic Lionel "how to operate" manual from 1954.

Lionel ATC page 39

...

So, as long as either the loco, and/or the leading car of any train running on this layout have a thumbtack or dumb coupler, I am good to go? 

Presumably by "dumb" coupler you mean one without a solenoid.  As I see it, it has nothing to do with whether the coupler is dumb or smart but rather if there is an electrical circuit whereby the stopped engine can receive outer-rail power from the coupler.  

That is, nothing says a locomotive or rolling stock's "solid" metal-constructed coupler (dumb or smart) must be electrically connected to the frame and outer wheels...whether or not this is standard practice notwithstanding.  Conversely, I am not aware of any O-gauge product which depends on a electrical circuit thru mechanical contact of coupler components as part of normal operation.

Separately, despite the elegance and simplicity of this method, is this really what you want...considering this is apparently a new setup?  I'm not suggesting expensive command-control or anything like that.  It's just that back in 1954 components like relays and diodes were few and far between to say the least!  Now these components are inexpensive and widely available and can enhance automatic train control setups.  Timed stops comes to mind.

 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Lionel ATC page 39

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×