Skip to main content

Hope everyone is off to a good Friday. It has been a busy week here in Chicago with plenty to see and do. Friday is the "Big" day with the Lionel seminar this afternoon which will include a nearly full look at the 2018 VII Catalog and one other major announcement directly to the LCCA members in attendence. 

Ryan Kunkle will join me around 5PM CENTRAL time tonight to discuss project updates plus the major announcement. The rest of the catalog will remain mostly a secret up until August 20th when it goes public. I hope you'll join us tonight at Notch6.com and of course on the Lionel Collectors Club of America Facebook page where there will be photos and other items to share from today's event. 

If you missed it, last night was my annual sit down with Howard Hitchcock, President of Lionel. We discussed a few important topics including a new Lionel retail store, the current challenges of overseas manufacturing, and more. You can grab that interview now at Notch6.com. 

Also, three other interviews including Kevin Davis, The Train Lady, and Bob Thomas! 

Thanks to everyone who has tuned in this week. I have seen the future and it looks like brass...

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Peter Araujo posted:

Looking on their Facebook page, I saw a brass streamliner engine.  It looks like it could either be a J or K2a. Can't really tell what it is. And do I see a Pennsy Ten-Wheeler on display as well? I also see a passenger car in there too.

My guess would be a K2a (as all the left side detail isn't there) and a giveaway would be the shroud over the Worthington BL feedwater heater:

Rusty

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0

Well that's interesting. If it had been a N&W K1, I'd be all over it. Maybe since they have the running gear, the K1 could be next.

Since I already have a 3rd Rail K2a, I'll have to pass. FWIW, I already had the Lionel JLC Y6b when 3rd Rail introduced their Y6b. Passed on the 3rd Rail offering. It swings both ways. There's a limit to the $1K+ locomotives I can roster.

Last edited by Gilly@N&W
@T1Titan_ZachF posted:
david1 posted:

Really a K2! Now I really don't care. 

Dave

Should have been Strasburg 90, I agree with you 100%

I was hoping Lionel would produce a first-rate, high-quality steamer modeled after the Strasburg Railroad's # 90. Since Lionel has produced a variety of rolling stock for the SRR, why hasn't a quality proto SRR engine been made? How much do SRR fans have to beg Lionel to acknowledge their needs and fill an obvious gap?

While not one I have to have, I swear some of you guys would complain if you got $500 in $1 bills. 

I'm sure there are folks out there that will be happy it's being made. I also get that's it's not for everyone but it seems if you don't like it or want it then just say so and move on without the drama.  I certainly think they welcome any constructive input. 

Last edited by MartyE

I'm not going to deride the model itself, but I will say that if Lionel wants us to take these type of announcements more seriously, they need to hire either a proofreader that does not exist, or a more experienced one if they already have one on staff.

While the top part of the listing does show brass for the loco and tender body, it's messed up that later on they copied the generic die cast wording from other steam offerings.  This cut and paste laziness is getting a bit ridiculous, IMO.

While much less objectionable, the selection of what got lumped under the (1st) Legacy Railsounds bullet is also questionable.  What the heck do the die cast frame, individually numbered  (I get the road number and crew talk part) and kinematic drawbar have to do with Legacy Railsounds? .  Or maybe that heading should have said something else, since there is a second Legacy Railsounds section further down(with some duplication).  Either way, it shows poor care in the presentation of the features.

-Dave

Attachments

Images (2)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×