Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

IMO, Scrapper blade would have been down, on the deck of the flat car, as well as the front gate. Ejector pan in the fill mode, not forward.   Rarely would they be allowed to set overnight as pictured, in the up position, definitely not shipped that way.  Scrapper blade was always kept near the ground, best stability of a somewhat tip-sy machine.  The scrapper blade was a better brake than what most of the machines had. 

   There is a wild story about the Montour Railroad, and a run-a-way flat with an earth mover on it, that eventually stopped, when it hit the front of the #76 SW9 unit.

 

 Wonderful modeling   Thanks for posting. In the mid-70's I worked with a couple of very old Terrex pans like the AC pan pictured.  Not a human friendly piece of equipment.

Last edited by Mike CT
YOU ARE RIGHT THAT "IS" YOUR OPINION

As far as that gate casting it will not move without breaking it. I also believe it would be left in the back position. Scraper that is another story.




Originally Posted by Mike CT:

       
IMO, Scrapper blade would have been down, on the deck of the flat car, as well as the front gate. Ejector pan in the fill mode, not forward.   Rarely would they be allowed to set overnight as pictured, in the up position, definitely not shipped that way.  Scrapper blade was always kept near the ground, best stability of a somewhat tip-sy machine.  The scrapper blade was a better brake than what most of the machines had.
   There is a wild story about the Montour Railroad, and a run-a-way flat with an earth mover on it, that eventually stopped, when it hit the front of the #76 SW9 unit.

Wonderful modeling Thanks for posting. In the mid-70's I worked with a couple of very old Terrex pans like the AC pan pictured.  Not a human friendly piece of equipment.

       
imageimage

Attachments

Images (2)
  • image
  • image
Last edited by Erik C Lindgren
A convincing argument for sure to implement changes into loading practices. However comma- I model a much earlier era than your reference posted that would appear 1970's maybe even early 1980's judging by the color nature of the print and the prototype of the flat car. My era is 1947-1956- and indeed they implemented tens of thousands of changes in FRA standards between 1950-1980.

Cool picture thanks for sharing. I enjoyed the corespondence this morning.

Originally Posted by Mike CT:

       

Wreck of Montour #76. 

#76 was rebuilt and used again. Though engineers preferred to use it in a consist, said it never tracked right after the crash.

 

I love it Erik.  No doubt, coming out of WWII, we were learning a lot.  Everything was getting larger, leaps and bound larger.  It would have taken time for all to comprehend the intensity of larger, bigger, more powerful, etc. Same applied to the Agriculture industry and their equipment.  You're modeling in very accurate, thank you. 

 

Recent trips on the PA turnpike, I-76, All this type of equipment is gone.  The huge excavator seems to be the machine of choice.  Some large quarry trucks.  Most large earth movement areas, the excavators cut a solid road bed for the quarry trucks.  Safety a big concern.   Here in Western PA the massive project with the PA turnpike I-76 seem to be straighten all the curves.  We have also removed (3) of the seven tunnels. Things change in 70 years. IMO   Mike CT   

 

As I review the pictures, one of the big changes was that a lot of earth moving equipment like this, early, operated by winch and cable lift systems, eventually replaced with hydraulic lifts.  Even early D7 and D8 Cat Dozers used cable lift for the blades.  The high tree, to the front of a couple of the tractor-less pan pictures, most likely was for cable lift.  It would have made sense to ship the pan in the up position, it could have been attached to any tractor to be removed from the flat.  Installing the multiple cable system with the winch, usually on the tractor, would have required a lot of effort, most likely done at the excavation site.   Hydraulics changed a lot of the industry. 

 

 Best wishes, Erik

Mike CT   

Last edited by Mike CT

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×