Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

When I saw the title of this thread I thought to my self: It hast o be "The City of New Orleans," and sure enough . . .   

 

I like Arlo Guthrie's version a lot, but I've always been partial to the Willie Nelson version and have an original album cover for that album framed on the wall of my trainroom.

 

Great, great railroad song!

 

 

DSCN1971

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN1971

I always liked Jack Straw by the Grateful Dead, but will be the first to admit it's not the greatest train song ever.  It does ok in a pinch though.

 

And there is always that train part in Johnny Cash's song Folsom Prison which ends in

 

'and when I hear that whistle blowin

I just hang my head and cry'

 

 a true O gauger's lament perhaps... 

Originally Posted by Lee Willis:

       

When I saw the title of this thread I thought to my self: It hast o be "The City of New Orleans," and sure enough . . .   

 

I like Arlo Guthrie's version a lot, but I've always been partial to the Willie Nelson version and have an original album cover for that album framed on the wall of my trainroom.

 

Great, great railroad song!

 

 

DSCN1971


       


You got that right Lee
Nobody does that song like Willie..


You be the Judge...





K.C.
Originally Posted by BLT:

That is Arlo Guthrie doing a Steve Goodman song. Don't like it with the sound effects of the simulator. 

There's also an improved version with a female singer and much better graphics don by the same fella (and no sound effects...)

 

I'll give him credit, it's pretty close to how I imagined the song all these years.

 

Rusty

Originally Posted by William 1:

A Captain Kangaroo reference!  Outstanding!  How could you remember that?  I watched as much Captain Kangaroo as anyone I would say as a kid and I sure didn't recognize it.  Thanks for sharing that.

They didn't play it very often, so you could have missed it as a kid.

But imagine that song with color film of UP Challengers and Big Boys. Really hard to forget for a little train buff. If someone ever found a video of that version, it wouldn't be too tough to edit a copy of it as I now know they used scenes from that UP movie.

To be honest, I only recall a few things from that show overall, I knew Mister Moose used to drop tons of ping pong balls on the poor Captain, which was high comedy when you're about 6 years old. But I can't honestly say I remember much more than that from the show.

Has Lionel, MTH, Golden Gate, anyone, made a City of New Orleans train set.  Growing up, I don't remember it being as famous as the Super Chief, city of LA, or 20th century Limited, but given the song, I'd love to have a set.

 

It would be too much to ask for switch in the dining car that would let you select between Guthie's and Nelsons version of the song to be played as it rolls along, but . . . I can dream!

One of my favorites is also one of the simplest: "I've Been Working on the Railroad".

 

Here's a pretty fair version by Pete Seeger: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgINdoXz-ZY

 

Like its soulmate "You Are My Sunshine", there's really nothing to the song which, perhaps, is part of its charm.  

 

I just love the line "just to pass the time away".  It may be one of the first jokes I ever fully understood when I was a boy.

Last edited by Serenska

The famous story about Steve Goodman writing the song had to do with the phrase, "Passengers will please refrain . . . ," referring to the warning sign in car bathrooms not to flush the toilet while the train was in the station.

 

Goodman was on the Muskie campaign train when someone, apparently disregarding the sign, flushed the toilet in the open platform observation car. A campaign staffer came running through the staff car screaming that the bystanders listening to Muskie speaking from the rear car platform were being sprayed with excrement.

 

It got into the song which, IMO, is fabulous.

 

See my tag line !

Last edited by Scrapiron Scher

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×