Skip to main content

Does the mechanism operate smoothly or with unusually difficult to raise and lower the boom and the smaller hook on your crane car?

 

Recently I bought a “new in the box” Conrail Operating Crane Car 30-7917, it is very attractive; it appeared in MTH's 1998 Volume 3 - S.P. Daylight catalog along with the Chessie 30-7916 version. Then the MTH 1999 Volume 1 catalog had the Nickel Plate Road 30-7919 version and Amtrak 30-7918 version of the same operating crane.

 

I am trying to decide whether to return this crane to the ebay vender, or improve the operation. Lowering the boom and lowering the smaller hook has much more resistance (very harder cranking resistance) and is accompanied by very loud clicking. However, raising the hook and raising the boom is much easier, nearly smooth, and the clicking is not very loud. Did you experience similar operation with your MTH RK crane?

 

Is there anything you would recommend to smooth out the crank lowering operation for the hook and boom? I bought this crane intending it to be a Christmas gift for one of my grandsons (5, 4 or 3 yr old). As it is, I doubt they will have the grip to lower the hook, and as they say: lower the boom!

 

Thanks in advance with your experiences and advise.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • IMG_4181
  • IMG_4180
Last edited by IcyTrains
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

My son-in-law purchased a more recent version for my grandson. It's all black. I looked at it and thought, oh my, as he was 3 and now 4 years old.

 

We decided to hide the crank as we knew that would get lost. The last time that I saw it, all of the lines were tangled and off of the pulleys.

 

I will be doing some maintenance on it, but most likely not in time for you to return yours. I do recall the noise. Perhaps deliberate to imitate the gears of a real crane.

 

My initial thoughts were that it's too complicated for someone that young. He does ok with just a hook crank on crane toys with a magnet. He loves cranes.

Last edited by Moonman

While the MTH crane look great, I don't think they are durable for operation. A fellow club members has a newer MTH crane, likely similar to your grandson's, and it was easy for him to mess-up the lines in his crane while being careful.

 

However, the Lionel one is likely a better toy for a kid to operate. One of my grandsons got a crane with his Lionel RTR set. Lionel's crane cranks are not a removable, it has lasted through one Christmas season with out tangles.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×