Skip to main content

I have a SIT unit that smokes well, but does not generate as loud a choo-choo sound as I would like it to or other SIT units do.  It has an ACG AF piston and cylinder instead of a bellows, which is nice.  I have cleared all the holes and passage ways throughout the unit.  It has an oblong fluted hole or aperture in the choo-choo plate.  I have flipped that plate inside out and rotated it, but that made no difference.  It has an original AF metal piston.  I've also tried a Gilbert AF carbon-graphite piston and an aftermarket plastic/Delrin piston.  The AF carbon-graphite works a tiny bit better, so I'm going with that.  What else do you suggest I try to get it to choo-choo louder?  Is the correct orientation of the plate such that the lip or fluting of the oblong hole is at the bottom (see photo below)?  I've also seen some plates with a circular hole with a raised edge all the way around it.  Did those come before or after the oblong hole?  Do circular-hole plates generally work better (sound louder)?    This smoke unit casting also has an open top and bottom primary or first chamber (see photo).  I've worked on others that are cast shut at the bottom.  I covered the bottom of this one, but that did not make the choo-choo louder.  Thanks.  

PS You'll notice also this unit has a metal drive gear instead of the usual fiber gear.  

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_5913: oblong fluted hole or aperture
  • IMG_5910: open bottom primary chamber
  • IMG_5911
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Agreed, with more room for the sound to get out, SIB choo-choo is typically more discernible and louder than SIT, but I own and have worked on some SIT units that might surprise you and are definitely better than this one.  I'm just wondering what the differentiating factor(s) might be since I can't quite dial it in and out the way I'd like to and can with so many other elements of an engine's performance.  Maybe it comes down to manufacturing tolerances and the fact these are toy trains, old ones no less.   Different SIT units might produce different levels of choo-choo simply b/c the compounded tolerances of their cylinders, pistons (or bellows), air holes, stamped aperture plates, etc. all add up to some work better than others.  Your comment does, however, remind me of a desk plaque I once read "When all else fails, lower your standards."  

That baffle plate looks significantly different than the ones I have seen in SIB choo choo units, which have a much smaller circular hole and a pronounced drawn area.  I suspect the shape of that opening is significant in affecting the sound.  If you have one of those plates, I would try installing it.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×