Has anyone used this method for their bench work? I am building an 5 X 10 layout and I have assenbled the frame but it doesn't feel entirely stable. I have yet to put the braces on the legs and the plywood on the top. I thought befor I got too far someone could give me an opinion on this. I finished the construction of the benchwork. It isn't great but better than my last one.
Replies sorted oldest to newest
I used 1X2, 1X4, and 2X2's, I am only concerned because I am not the greatest carpenter in the world if I built a bird house it would get condemned.
L-Girder depends on the cross-leg bracing for rigidity. Until it's installed there will be a considerable amount of wobble.
Okay I will repost Saturday after I finish installing the braces
There was a fairly lengthy and informative post about 'L' Girder awhile back. A search should find it. Great method...
The braces are what makes everything sturdy. Any structure is like a house of cards until some shear (preventing lateral movement) bracing is applied. Put a few on and be amazed by geometry.
Thank you I feel much better about my work now. I will defonetly post pictures of the finished product. I used the Greemfrog instructional video on how to do a L girder table.
L Girder is the best way to go.
I am in the process of building a new layout after a move. The train room bench work is a mix of old and new benchwork styles. I found that a new method I use works out real well. As shown in the picture below the basic section is made up of two 2x4s sandwiched between two 1x4. I have the sections sized so that when I connect two sections with a 1x4 I get slightly less than a 4x4 square. using this technique all screws can be driven straight in. No need for pocket holes or driving screws at an angle.
Joe
Attachments
L-girder is especially good for building benchwork with irregular shapes such as kidney shape or any kind of curving benchwork. You just vary the length of the cross members. I am talking about building benchwork that is not square or rectangular.
If you are building a flat table top layout, "open-grid" is is probably easiest. Just frame it like you would a window. However, if you want scenery below track level, valleys and ravines etc., L-girder makes it much easier even for square shaped layouts.
Dennis, that's a heck of an idea, but I don't think the "officer on deck" would go
for it, L O L . . . . .
Hoppy